• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Toronto Marlies Thread

He's not going to come in like a gunslinger, shooting from the hip at everything he sees, Shanahan needs to get a close look at everything.
Plus it gives him more time to keep his eye out for the right people.

I feel like firing a coach with such disastrous results last year, that you publicly acknowledge needs to overhaul his entire system, and who has stated he has no idea what really went wrong isn't exactly gun-slinging.
 
If only holland and ashton and holzer stay with the leafs, here's the probable lineup:

Brown - Nylander - Leivo
Abbott - McKegg - Kozun
Herzog - Carrick - Broll
Ross - Rupert - Biggs
(Devane)

Percy - Granberg
Finn - Loov
MacWilliam - Nilsson
(Marshall - Knodel)

Sparks
Gibson

Whcih would be a pretty excellent young team.

Of course, I expect at least one of those forwards and one of those dmen to have a fairly permanent spot on the big club.
Clarkson would look good on that 4th line.
 
He's not going to come in like a gunslinger, shooting from the hip at everything he sees, Shanahan needs to get a close look at everything.
Plus it gives him more time to keep his eye out for the right people.

It's a positive sign for the organization that Shanahan isn't coming in like a gunslinger. Like the last few GMs to run this team. Remember Fletcher throwing away Steen? Nonis signing the Clarkson deal? Burke's Komi signing? Rask for Raycroft? Those were all gunslinging mentality deals.
 
Regarding this silly shit about "gunslinging", when you've taken over a team that just finished giving up the most shots against by any team in NHL history, and also finished 2-12 to crash and burn out of the playoff race, firing the coach is not "gunslinging", and it's not rushing to judgement.
 
Gun-slinging might not be the right term, but I think what people are saying is he has patience. He is not reacting to one bad year, or one bad 15 game stretch. He is not making moves to appease the fans.

He is taking a calculated and patient approach, and is willing to take the heat that comes with that. Its a good sign. Even if you don't agree with some of the moves in particular. You are never going to agree with every move a GM makes. Its the only way to build a good organization. At the end of the day maybe Carlyle is part of that, or maybe he isn't. But if you have the right approach you'll end up making more good decisions than poor ones in the long run.

So far his only potentially poor decision is not firing people. He hasn't added some immovable, cap killing contract. He didn't go out and trade top young players like Kadri and Gardiner for a quick fix like many called for. He didn't ship out Phaneuf for 10 cents on the dollar. If not firing Carlyle is the biggest mistake he has made so far its hard to complain too much. Coaches are easy to fire, and can always be fired. That is a mistake that is pretty easy to fix if it turns out to be a mistake. Its probably the easiest mistake to fix in hockey.
 
Last edited:
Well, the results themselves are firing worthy, but its always more important to evaluate process more than results....and in these cases the process is even worse than the result.

What kills me is that shanny was fully invested in handing out ANOTHER 5+ mil longterm deal to a guy who is not a good bet to produce more than 3rd line offense, and whose defense is questionable as well.

We literally might have been paying a really mediocre or even crappy third line first line money for years to come, with a komarov-bolland-clarkson trio.
 
First of all, Shanny, as the PResident, should not be making the call on Bolland or any UFA - that's the GM's call. That's problem #1.

In regardless, in the 'saved by Tallon's stupidity' argument regarding Bolland, while I think it is a fair point, fact is we don't really know how much Shanny offered to Bolland. If he offered $3.75M per, then you can argue that IS a good move. Now, I also think Shanny offered closer to $5M than $3.75M, but since we don't know for sure how much he offered, I will give him the benefit of doubt.
 
Its all rumours but I think his agent also said that the Leafs never even came in with a serious offer until the 11th hour and it wasn't in the same ballpark as Florida. It really didn't seem like they were all that interested other than from the Toronto media. It wouldn't have been very hard to keep him here.
 
Nobody was touching that ridiculous deal.

Toronto just did him a favor by making it seem like they would, which enabled him to rape Florida's poor butthole.
 
Didn't Bollands agent say the gap was around 800k from what he got in Florida?

Yes.

In regards to former Leaf Dave Bolland, Toronto did not make an offer even close to the one he accepted from the Florida Panthers until the eleventh hour, according to Bolland’s agent Anton Thun.

“We had indicated to the Leafs from day one when the negotiations started that he was very interested in being with the Leafs and that he would accept a big discount on what we believed the market was to be a Leaf .” Thun said on Sportsnet FAN 590’s Prime Time Sports on Monday. “But we never got to that point.”

Thun indicated that the Leafs offer was “not literally close in any way, shape or form until Noon on July 1” and that the Panther’s offer(5 years, $27.5 Million) was $800,000 better per season than Toronto’s final offer, because of no state taxes in Florida, which would put the Leafs offer at less than $5 Million annually.
 
Yes.

In regards to former Leaf Dave Bolland, Toronto did not make an offer even close to the one he accepted from the Florida Panthers until the eleventh hour, according to Bolland’s agent Anton Thun.

“We had indicated to the Leafs from day one when the negotiations started that he was very interested in being with the Leafs and that he would accept a big discount on what we believed the market was to be a Leaf .” Thun said on Sportsnet FAN 590’s Prime Time Sports on Monday. “But we never got to that point.”

Thun indicated that the Leafs offer was “not literally close in any way, shape or form until Noon on July 1” and that the Panther’s offer(5 years, $27.5 Million) was $800,000 better per season than Toronto’s final offer, because of no state taxes in Florida, which would put the Leafs offer at less than $5 Million annually.
Which is still way, way too much. Bolland's final contract was $5.5M per, this means Toronto offered $4.7M per in the '11th hour final offer'.

Thank God for Tallon.

Can you imagine tieing up $4.7M per season on a 3rd liner who averages 50 games per season (and this is taking into consideration the shortened season, where he played 35 of 48 games, equivalent to 60 games in a regular 82 games season), and 25 points per season????

We have 1 Clarkson already, we don't need another Clarkson who can't even play close to 70 games.
 
But he doesn't mention years or anything. Just that they never even got to the point of discussing a home town discount and the Leafs never even really made legitimate attempt to sign him until the last second.

It doesn't make it sound like the Leafs were too interested.
 
I'm actually still kind of shocked we didn't sign him.

I was resigned to the fact we were signing him again months ago, just like i knew we were signing clarkson a year before we did.
 
But he doesn't mention years or anything. Just that they never even got to the point of discussing a home town discount and the Leafs never even really made legitimate attempt to sign him until the last second.

It doesn't make it sound like the Leafs were too interested.

Dreger was saying 5 years, 4.75 million IIRC.

But it doesn't seem like you want to believe that Shanahan really wanted him. Even though he told us he did.
 
Well I know he said that, but the agent is saying they didn't even make a serious offer till the last second and even then it wasn't even close.

That's not how you go hard after a free agent. He said it, but he didn't act like it. You know what they say about actions and words.

And that comes straight from the agents mouth, not Dreger.

You can't deny that Shany publicly saying they really want him, and then privately not offering a competitive deal ever aren't perfectly aligned.
 
Well I know he said that, but the agent is saying they didn't even make a serious offer till the last second and even then it wasn't even close.

That's not how you go hard after a free agent. He said it, but he didn't act like it. Actions > words.

See, to me, 4.75 for 5 years for a Bolland is still pretty stupid and does make it seem like they wanted him - even if they didn't completely lose their minds like Florida.
 
Back
Top