Oh no i don't question EDM would have to salvage whatever they can from Schultz. It's just if Schultz only (well, 'only') costs a 3rd and EDM is willing to eat half his salary, I think it's a worthwhile trade for TO to at least consider.
There are a few factors to consider. First of all Schultz has all the tools, and was a much sought after college UFA. He had 48 points in 34 AHL games at 21, which is a pretty significant achievement for a young dman. Then in his rookie NHL season he had 27 points in 48 games (shortened season) which equates to 46 points over 82 games season. And that is just 4 years ago.
His numbers has since declined, but last season he still had 31 points, which is above average, even among "offensive dmen" in this league. He cannot play defense, that much is true - but that only makes him a typical Edmonton dman. Plus, in his 4 NHL seasons in Edmonton, he's had 4 different coaches ... there's no stability, and no consistent system, never mind training or development.
And he may never make it as a dman in the NHL, but he sure has the tools as an offensive dman. He was the D partner of Gardiner in college, and the 2 of them had chemistry playing together. To consider we traded a 4th for Marincin, trading a 3rd for 20 games to evaluate Schultz is a worthy deal imo. Especially considering how thin we are on the blueline ... after Rielly and Gardiner, we don't really have any young defenseman on the team or in the system who has top 4 potential except for Dermott and Nielsen, both of whom are at least 4 years away from the NHL if not more.