• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

This tournament will likely spell the end of NHL participation in the Winter Olympics.. not sure how I feel about that. While I hate that the league basically has to shut down for 3 weeks - it's really good hockey.

Russia probably can't wait. The KHL probably can't wait. KHL players versus what, our juniors and AHLers? Plus the Russian NHLers who don't give a damn and go anyways?
 
As much as I love Olympic hockey, it is kind of stupid to shut down the league for 2 weeks in the middle of the stretch. If they didn't do this youngstars team, then I think I'd be much more in favour of basically seeing this as the premier hockey championship. I don't mind having the European team in there, since it's not like any of those countries would win anyways and helps get their talent in, but taking talent away from from the other teams is stupid. Even if they let teams name who they wanted, and then after all the other teams were named made their youngstars team, that would at least make sure the other nations are full staffed.

If you're going to start making up teams they should make it interesting. Wonder what would happen if the made a team Atlantic provinces, team quebec, team Ontario and team western provinces
 
Russia probably can't wait. The KHL probably can't wait. KHL players versus what, our juniors and AHLers? Plus the Russian NHLers who don't give a damn and go anyways?

Yeah, I have no interest in Russia being essentially gifted a whole bunch of additional gold medals every four years like they were from 1956 onwards due to the archaic "amateur" vs "professional" definition that the IIHF used to employ.
 
If you're going to start making up teams they should make it interesting. Wonder what would happen if the made a team Atlantic provinces, team quebec, team Ontario and team western provinces

They have that already.

It's called the World U-17 hockey challenge. It's basically the best tournament below the U-18s. Team Ontario or Team USA (more recently) wins in a lot of years.
 
They have that already.

It's called the World U-17 hockey challenge. It's basically the best tournament below the U-18s. Team Ontario or Team USA (more recently) wins in a lot of years.

True. I just let wonder what the adult version would look like.

Probably more interesting than team NA
 
This tournament will likely spell the end of NHL participation in the Winter Olympics.. not sure how I feel about that. While I hate that the league basically has to shut down for 3 weeks - it's really good hockey.
I'm sure this is what Gary Bettman and the rest of the NHL owners desperately hope. But I really don't think this tournament will end up rating highly enough on the "give-a-shit-meter" even for hardcore hockey fans, let alone the casual fans and non-hockey fans that the Olympics draws in.

As much as I love Olympic hockey, it is kind of stupid to shut down the league for 2 weeks in the middle of the stretch. If they didn't do this youngstars team, then I think I'd be much more in favour of basically seeing this as the premier hockey championship. I don't mind having the European team in there, since it's not like any of those countries would win anyways and helps get their talent in, but taking talent away from from the other teams is stupid. Even if they let teams name who they wanted, and then after all the other teams were named made their youngstars team, that would at least make sure the other nations are full staffed.
I dunno...is it any better to disrupt everybody's training camps, along with having most teams' best players jump right into playoff-style hockey fresh off their summer vacations, with no recent game action under their belts, and only a couple of weeks before the regular season starts?

There's no real "good" time to stage one of these tournaments, if what you're mainly focusing on is the impact on NHL competition. But I think I would prefer that it happen mid-season, when all of these guys are in game shape. I'm going to be curious to see how sharp these guys look, and how many injuries are going to come out of this tournament.
 
As much as I love Olympic hockey, it is kind of stupid to shut down the league for 2 weeks in the middle of the stretch. If they didn't do this youngstars team, then I think I'd be much more in favour of basically seeing this as the premier hockey championship. I don't mind having the European team in there, since it's not like any of those countries would win anyways and helps get their talent in, but taking talent away from from the other teams is stupid. Even if they let teams name who they wanted, and then after all the other teams were named made their youngstars team, that would at least make sure the other nations are full staffed.

Any world Cup should start with "the world" how do you grow the sport if they can't make what 1 league is now claiming to be the top international competition? KHL teams in China now,if they catch on who gets dropped, how does one who won't win inspire a fan base?
 
Yeah, I have no interest in Russia being essentially gifted a whole bunch of additional gold medals every four years like they were from 1956 onwards due to the archaic "amateur" vs "professional" definition that the IIHF used to employ.

Why doesn't the nhl just do like soccer? Let the stars go play, don't stop the season ( slow it down maybe?) And play some call ups.
 
Why doesn't the nhl just do like soccer? Let the stars go play, don't stop the season ( slow it down maybe?) And play some call ups.

I agree in principle. Soccer has so many championship games. The FA cup, the Champions League, the world cup, etc...

I don't know why the nhl can't do something similar.

Why can't there be a Champions League of hockey?
 
you guys are nuts.

can't wait to see the young stars kick some ass.
That's really the only part of this tournament that interests me---seeing how Matthews (and to a lesser degree, Rielly) does in another opportunity against top-end competition. Though it would be better if Matthews was doing it as part of a complete Team USA, rather than a contrived "young guns" team.

And even though pre-season play is usually lousy, I'm still a little more eager to see him play with other members of the Leaf organization (like Nylander & Marner) than I am to see him in this format.
 
I'm not the most patriotic person in the world and generally don't give a **** about international tournaments so this has slightly more appeal to me than the typical one. I like the idea of the young star team. If it was just a bunch of nations, how does it make it any different than the Worlds and the Olympics? It's the same shit, different tournament name. I'm not chomping at the bit to watch it or anything, but I'm definitely intrigued.
 
Obviously it doesn't mean much to win a world cup. But it'll still be great hockey to watch. It will be better experience for our young players. It will also be interesting to see if the players in the tournament come out of the gates flying in the regular season. Its a much better tune up than a bunch of AHL games where no one tries.

I don't have a problem with it. Other than it should be HRR and push the cap up.
 
That's really the only part of this tournament that interests me---seeing how Matthews (and to a lesser degree, Rielly) does in another opportunity against top-end competition. Though it would be better if Matthews was doing it as part of a complete Team USA, rather than a contrived "young guns" team.

And even though pre-season play is usually lousy, I'm still a little more eager to see him play with other members of the Leaf organization (like Nylander & Marner) than I am to see him in this format.

i don't see what's contrived.

any more than grouping players together by what borders they were born inside. I' e never taken much joy from canada beating up crap countries in tourneys.

I used to post all star teams by age here (i.e. -22, 23-27, 28-32, 33+). I've always wanted to see this.
 
i don't see what's contrived.

any more than grouping players together by what borders they were born inside. I' e never taken much joy from canada beating up crap countries in tourneys.

I used to post all star teams by age here (i.e. -22, 23-27, 28-32, 33+). I've always wanted to see this.
Yeah, I recall you always being pretty apathetic about the WJC and other international tournaments, so I'm not surprised that this is your viewpoint. And even though it's a view that's not shared by the vast majority of humanity, I can understand where you're coming from, even if I also don't feel the same way. But whether borders are silly artificial divisions or no, the country I'm from and fellow countrymen competing for that country internationally does mean something to me.

But I guess my main issue is, if you're going to have an under-24 all-star team in the mix, then why even go through the pretence that this is a best-on-best tournament between countries, and why limit that under-24 team to players from Canada and the United States?

Why not have guys like Kucherov, Forsberg, Barkov, Laine, Nylander & Draisatl competing for spots on this team as well? And why not just ditch the country format altogether, and come up with other ways to divide the players into more teams, whether by age or some other criteria?
 
Back
Top