• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

What about it?

The format of golf makes such an arrangement far more feasible. Also as the game developed two main separate tours divided by continent and various championships of equal standing. Golf has an extremely long history in that respect.

Not really. It was America vs. Britain until like 1980, but it wasn't competitive so they changed Britain to team Europe and ended up with a much better, more competitive tournament.
 

Yeah, between 1958 and 1961.

Moreover, to my previous point, the West Indies Federation was an actual country between 1958 and 1962. They had their own official stamps, currency (West Indian Dollar), capital (Port of Spain), merchant vessels (Canada actually gave them two), sports teams, and courts. There is a lengthy history of attempts to merge the various island nations in that region into one united federation and for four years they had just that. There's always been a collective West Indies identity as well.

It's no different than the British Home Nations being allowed to use their own international sides in FIFA and UEFA play despite the fact that they are not technically countries in the literal sense (due primarily to history). That would never be allowed today.
 
It's almost as if branding something a "world cup" but hand picking teams and not having the international governing body sanction the tournament is ridiculous or something.
 
What about the Ryder Cup?

Not sure why people are so closed minded. May as well give the thing a chance. Its happening either way.

I don't really understand why you and zeke feel this obsessive need to have my validation or approval on this subject. It's kind of weird. You like the format and a lot of us don't. Why is that preventing you from enjoying it?
 
It's almost as if branding something a "world cup" but hand picking teams and not having the international governing body sanction the tournament is ridiculous or something.

It's almost as if calling it a world cup when most of the world doesn't care about save a few leaf fans wanting to watch Matthews makes it ridiculous.

Especially when there is already a tournament that most global hockey fans care about and has been doing just fine.

Olympics or something...
 
Not really. It was America vs. Britain until like 1980, but it wasn't competitive so they changed Britain to team Europe and ended up with a much better, more competitive tournament.

A couple of things here:

1.) Golf is a far more globalized game (particularly in Asia) than it previously was. It used to only belong to the Anglo aristocracy in various British colonies (Australia, Canada, New Zealand, South Africa) and the United States. Far fewer people from quality golf nations like South Korea, Spain, Italy, Argentina, Sweden, and other places played the game en masse like they do now.

2.) Even though Britain invented the game it was still heavily divided on the basis of class. That was not the case in the United States, where it was far more accessible to the average person. It's not surprising that the British were getting things handed to them by the Americans, who already enjoyed a massive population advantage, and far more courses/active participants in the game.

3.) At the time they changed the format, you would still have difficulty creating a team comprised entirely of Europeans. Again, this is far more akin to the Soviet Union occasionally supplementing its national teams (90+% Russian) with the occasional player from Ukraine, Kazakhstan, or the Baltic States like Latvia and Lithuania). Think of the Ryder Cup not as a true international competition, but more as something similar to the 1979 NHL Challenge Cup (European stars like Salming played for the NHL against the Soviets) or Rendez-Vous 87 (same format - North American and European NHL'ers against the Soviet national team).
 
It's almost as if calling it a world cup when most of the world doesn't care about save a few leaf fans wanting to watch Matthews makes it ridiculous.

Especially when there is already a tournament that most global hockey fans care about and has been doing just fine.

Olympics or something...

They should have just called it what it is and been done with it: Gary Bettman's Pre-Season Invitational Fall Classic.
 
Yeah, between 1958 and 1961.

Moreover, to my previous point, the West Indies Federation was an actual country between 1958 and 1962. They had their own official stamps, currency (West Indian Dollar), capital (Port of Spain), merchant vessels (Canada actually gave them two), sports teams, and courts. There is a lengthy history of attempts to merge the various island nations in that region into one united federation and for four years they had just that. There's always been a collective West Indies identity as well.

It's no different than the British Home Nations being allowed to use their own international sides in FIFA and UEFA play despite the fact that they are not technically countries in the literal sense (due primarily to history). That would never be allowed today.

lol.

the windies have been around a lot longer than that.

and the West Indies Federation was less of a country than the EU is. It collapsed before they were even able to agree on a taxation system.
 
It's almost as if branding something a "world cup" but hand picking teams and not having the international governing body sanction the tournament is ridiculous or something.

The only thing looking ridiculous about this tournament right now are the critics.
 
lol.

the windies have been around a lot longer than that.

and the West Indies Federation was less of a country than the EU is. It collapsed before they were even able to agree on a taxation system.

So you agree that something that has had a collective group identity for hundreds of years, formed national aspirations around that shared identity, been a nation briefly, and introduced various political measures might be considered a decent candidate for its own national sporting team?

You're making my argument for me here. They didn't randomly one day decide to cobble together Jamaica, Barbados, Bahamas, Trinidad & Tobago, etc. and make a sports team. There were decades of shared identity and association.
 
The only thing looking ridiculous about this tournament right now are the critics.

People criticize the annual World Championships all the time and that's actually an IIHF sanctioned event with four divisions comprising every official IIHF member federation, qualifying tournaments, official ranking systems, and almost one hundred years of history behind it, not to mention an emotional connection for Europeans that is entirely absent in this format.

Why would Bettman's Gimmick Tournament be any different? You seem to take this criticism personally for some reason.
 
So, zeke and leafman are still desperately trying to "logic" everyone into passionately caring about this tournament, I see?

It hasn't worked on me yet, but maybe if zeke spends more time delving into the history of the West Indies, that might do the trick.
 
I can't speak for anyone else, but I'm not sure that anyone is trying to make anyone do anything. The World Cup is happening. People are caring. It is what it is.

Just using logic to refute some illogical points.
 
So, zeke and leafman are still desperately trying to "logic" everyone into passionately caring about this tournament, I see?

It hasn't worked on me yet, but maybe if zeke spends more time delving into the history of the West Indies, that might do the trick.

LOL
 
I can't speak for anyone else, but I'm not sure that anyone is trying to make anyone do anything. The World Cup is happening. People are caring. It is what it is.

Just using logic to refute some illogical points.

Well yeah, if you keep fighting straw men I could see how you would find it illogical.
 
I for one am going to enjoy the NHL/NHLPA Preseason Jamboree when I'm able to watch, but it's not an IIHF event, so I won't put the winner in the same class as a Olympic Gold Medal winner.
 
So, zeke and leafman are still desperately trying to "logic" everyone into passionately caring about this tournament, I see?

It hasn't worked on me yet, but maybe if zeke spends more time delving into the history of the West Indies, that might do the trick.

heh. you guys trying to logic everyone else out of enjoying the tournament is more like it.

while we mock you for it.
 
I for one am going to enjoy the NHL/NHLPA Preseason Jamboree when I'm able to watch, but it's not an IIHF event, so I won't put the winner in the same class as a Olympic Gold Medal winner.

This is the first time I've ever heard anyone say anything respectful about the IIHF.
 
Back
Top