• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

Oh wait no. I did it wrong.


THE WORLD CUP IS A FRAUD!! LET'S ALL BOYCOTT AND NEVER WATCH HOCKEY SO WE CAN LIMIT OUR ENTERTAINMENT!!!

I'll tell you what. If this tournament doesn't mean NHL players aren't going to the olympics I will actively sit down and watch some games in 4 years.

Fair?
 
zaitsev sort of looks like svehla on the ice with his stride/ugly skating.

unfortunately he doesn't have his toughness/physicality or even puck skills (though he's certainly faster than svehla - who would have been DOA in the current league with his footspeed).

i think i'm with PM here. he looks like a 4/5 to me. that said, this is his first taste of this competition and russia's coaches have thought well enough of him to play him on the PP so there's a chance he shows more in a few months when he's acclimated.
 
zaitsev sort of looks like svehla on the ice with his stride/ugly skating.

unfortunately he doesn't have his toughness/physicality or even puck skills (though he's certainly faster than svehla - who would have been DOA in the current league with his footspeed).

i think i'm with PM here. he looks like a 4/5 to me. that said, this is his first taste of this competition and russia's coaches have thought well enough of him to play him on the PP so there's a chance he shows more in a few months when he's acclimated.
Yeah, he doesn't really excel at any one thing in particular. Seems pretty average across the board, except for his ugly skating, and from I've seen an above average shot. I've kind of hyped him up a bit much and expected more, but perhaps that was my own fault. Like I said, if he can use his size effectively and play a smart quiet game he can maybe become a 2nd pair guy. I don't see big points in his future - he won't be Marincin-bad offensively, but nothing more than 20-25 points which is more than fine for a second pairing. I just don't think he has enough in his skillset to be an every day 2nd pair guy though. I thought he'd be a better skater and he doesn't really have over-powering attributes (i.e. size, strength, elite puck skills, etc) to compensate for the poor skating. The only thing that we could potentially hope for to compensate for the skating is some elite ass hockey IQ.. But it has to be damn good.

We'll see, I suppose.
 
Still think you're being a bit harsh on a guy who's Russia's top dman at 25, in a game against Team Canada. Especially since he actually looked good for the most part.

Even in 2nd pair NHL duty he'll rarely have to go up against any lines as good as what Team Canada trots out every shift.
 
Obvious it'd be nice if he turned out to be something better, but "legitimate #4/5 NHL defenseman" wouldn't be an awful outcome for Zaitsev. When you're signing these older free agents, whether they be European or US College players, you end up with Fabian Brunnstroms or Christian Hansons a hell of a lot more often than you end up with an Artemi Panarin or even a Tyler Bozak.

And considering his competition on the right-hand side of the Leafs' defense is either mediocre-at-best (Polak, Corrado) or unproven (Carrick), it won't be a steep hill for him to climb to end up at least being an improvement over what we've already got.
 
Still think you're being a bit harsh on a guy who's Russia's top dman at 25, in a game against Team Canada. Especially since he actually looked good for the most part.

Even in 2nd pair NHL duty he'll rarely have to go up against any lines as good as what Team Canada trots out every shift.

I don't care about the ice time thing or the fact that he's one of Russia's best d. They stink back there.

I just don't think it's easy to be a quality defensman in the NHL without above average skating. I'm not ruling out 2nd pair, especially playing with a corsi booster like Gardiner, but it won't be easy. It's still my hope right now, just not my expectation.


Marincin-Rielly
Gardiner-Carrick
Hunwick-Zaitsev

I'd be most comfortable with this to start the year. Carrick and Zaitsev can battle it out to play with Gardiner. They're very comparable players actually, despite the size difference, and both have top 4 upsides.

Hunwick can be a placeholder for Marincin, if/when they get a top pairing d to play with Rielly. In the back of my mind I was hoping/praying that maybe Zaitsev can fill in there this year (not to be a stud, but at least to be a decent placeholder and fulfill the lhd-rhd balance) but after watching him play, that would be a terrible idea.
 
Last edited:
Last year Markov was a #2 dman, Kulikov a #3 dman, Emelin a #4, Orlov a #6, Marchenko and Nesterovs #7s, all on decent to very good teams.

And it looks like Zaitsev is being relied upon more than any of them.

And imo you're being a bit harsh even on his skating - I was surprised by his quickness on a few occasions.
 
Last year Markov was a #2 dman, Kulikov a #3 dman, Emelin a #4, Orlov a #6, Marchenko and Nesterovs #7s, all on decent to very good teams.

And it looks like Zaitsev is being relied upon more than any of them.

And imo you're being a bit harsh even on his skating - I was surprised by his quickness on a few occasions.
Look at those guys advanced stats, especially Markov and Kulikov. It's arguable whether they should even be in the NHL. You put too much faith in NHL coaches. Is Hunwick a top pairing d too now?

If anything, Orlov is their best d. IMO he can be a borderline 4 at times. Zaitsev didn't look out of place playing with a bunch of bottom pair guys, that's for sure. He's got a future in the NHL so it's nice to see that pretty much confirmed.
 
Even Strength

Zaitsev 15:08
Kulikov 14:09
Orlov 13:42
Emelin 13:11
Marchenko 11:48
Markov 11:20

Power Play

Markov 6:23
Zaitsev 4:48
Orlov 2:45
Marchenko 0:18
Kulikov 0:12
Emelin 0:00

Shorthanded

Marchenko 4:50
Kulikov 4:07
Emelin 3:53
Zaitsev 2:00
Markov 0:46
Orlov 0:24
 
Look at those guys advanced stats, especially Markov and Kulikov. It's arguable whether they should even be in the NHL. You put too much faith in NHL coaches. Is Hunwick a top pairing d too now?

If anything, Orlov is their best d. IMO he can be a borderline 4 at times. Zaitsev didn't look out of place playing with a bunch of bottom pair guys, that's for sure. He's got a future in the NHL so it's nice to see that pretty much confirmed.

Not sure you're factoring usage in enough. Orlov played very sheltered #6 dman minutes.
 
For anyone who's interested, here's a shift-by-shift video of Matthews from yesterday's game:

[video=youtube;xKsAl4mO4pk]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKsAl4mO4pk[/video]
 
Not sure you're factoring usage in enough. Orlov played very sheltered #6 dman minutes.

Yup no doubt. They're all within the same quality of player. He was beyond elite in his sheltered role, so it's hard to automatically say he could or couldn't be a #4 guy without him getting the opportunity. I'm more on the side where if you have a good team, you want him on your third pair as an elite #5, but he can probably be competent as a 4.

I'm just saying out of all the guys on the team, I think he's the only one that is POSSIBLY a 4. The others suck dick.
 
Back
Top