• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

to reply in kind, I don't see the Mats comp in any way, really.

You're thinking of the old mats. Young mats was more dynamic.

I just mean his work on the cycle, ability to protect the puck, 200 ft game and the way he likessel to.cut around d on the outside.
 
I don't think he had a 200ft game back then. And not nearly as lateral as matthews. He was big, fast, with a booming shot. Looked great speeding down the wing and unloading.
 
I don't think he had a 200ft game back then. And not nearly as lateral as matthews. He was big, fast, with a booming shot. Looked great speeding down the wing and unloading.

Yeah i think so too. Matthews has a few more tools for sure(you never know if he'll go left, right, pass it to himself off the boards). Mats did do well down the wing by cutting inside and using his big frame but just didn't have that lateral movement when in close space(not as well as Matthews anyways). Maybe going overboard with this but Matthews has potential to get better production than Mats(he was around 80 pt guy if i'm not mistaken).

Some of his stuff reminds me a bit of Forsberg(that move where he passes to himself i don't remember that many players doing it, doesn't shy away from physical contact either).
 
I personally think Matthews is pretty unique. Players at this level generally don't really have many, if any comparable at all. He has a bit of Malkin, a bit of Mats, a bit of Lindros, and a bit of Sakic. His shot technique is pure Sakic. Now in a time where wrist shots are almost obsolete, it'll be interesting to see Matthews adjust with his extra half second release time. As I tried REALLY ****ING HARD to say last time, he doesn't have a Kadri muffin, so the slower release shouldn't impact him much once he learns to adjust. Especially since he's quicker, more skilled, and will get in better scoring positions than Kadri can.
 
Sakic was a 5'11 195lb full grown man.

Matthews is a 6'2 220lb teenager.

I'm not sure about that comparable. It'd be nice if his numbers compared to Sakic.
 
Well he compared him to a Sakic/Forsberg/Benn/Kopitar hybrid, but those are just also the best players he coached.
 
Vigneault thinks Girardi is one of the Rangers best D.

The Habs think Weber is better than Subban.

USA thinks Justin Abdelkaeder is better than.. Well pretty much any other American not on the US team.

Canucks think Sbisa is an NHL defensman.



laughing-smiley-face-gif-facebook-secret-smileys-codes.jpg



Need I go on?
 
With that said, I don't deny that he could have been great in the last game. I saw his first two and while he was better in the 2nd, he still wasn't great. Based on the numbers, it seems like he was great in the third game though.

However let's not use a coach's opinion as proof . They have shown to be really dumb throughout the league on a number of occasions.
 
kids nowadays.

I don't know how old you are, and I don't really care either. I've seen your posts on HFBoards, and to be honest, I'm not sure how you've managed to last that long on there without being permanently banned. I've watched a lot of hockey since I was a kid in the 90s, so I feel very comfortable with my position that there is absolutely zero resemblance between Lindros and Matthews. You don't have to be 50+ years old to know there's no resemblance whatsoever.
 
I don't know how old you are, and I don't really care either. I've seen your posts on HFBoards, and to be honest, I'm not sure how you've managed to last that long on there without being permanently banned. I've watched a lot of hockey since I was a kid in the 90s, so I feel very comfortable with my position that there is absolutely zero resemblance between Lindros and Matthews. You don't have to be 50+ years old to know there's no resemblance whatsoever.

Welcome new person... we see you have already met Zeke
 
I don't know how old you are, and I don't really care either. I've seen your posts on HFBoards, and to be honest, I'm not sure how you've managed to last that long on there without being permanently banned. I've watched a lot of hockey since I was a kid in the 90s, so I feel very comfortable with my position that there is absolutely zero resemblance between Lindros and Matthews. You don't have to be 50+ years old to know there's no resemblance whatsoever.

welcome new poster! I respect your opinion sight unseen. I stand corrected.
 
Re: Matthews comparisons

Having watched some older Zurich games, the World Championships, and now the World Cup of Hockey, I think I can safely say that the scouting reports on Matthews criminally undersold his skill level. It's hard to describe how good Matthews already is because you can see bits and pieces of his game from shift to shift, game to game and you will come away thinking of a bunch of different players you've seen in the past. I don't see Sundin in Matthews. I don't see Lindros in Matthews. But I do see a lot of Malkin, a little bit of Forsberg. There's so much to like about his skill level, and his hands are unbelievable. His ability to control the puck with such little space defies belief given his size -- a man of that size should not be able to move like that. That's why I think of Malkin.

It's a pretty good possibility that he's going to end up being the best US raised hockey product ever.
 
Welcome new person... we see you have already met Zeke

I lurk HFBoards. I refuse to post on there because there's so much trash. I enjoy reading about prospects and coming up with some ideas for my keeper teams. Naturally, I've checked in on the Leafs forums and have seen Zeke's posts. I'm not a fan.
 
Totally brand new never seen before 50yr old aggressive first time posters are my favorite.
 
Totally brand new never seen before 50yr old aggressive first time posters are my favorite.

I particularly get a good giggle at seeing your prorating posts.

Matthews: 1 gp, 1 gls, 1 a, 2pts (82 gp, 82 gls, 82 a, 164 pts)

Such analysis. Much multiplying.
 
The Preston guide to opinions on young players everyone else is impressed by:

Start with:
"I personally think player X has been poor/unimpressive/*opposite opinion of everyone else*"

Then choose 1:
"Bad skater"
"Slow release / terrible shot"
"Possession stats in this one game last week..."

Now hedge your bet:
"With that said..."
"Might make adjustments..."
"It's still early..."

Rinse and repeat.
 
I like how you took my random post personally, then started attacking me and letting on that you've been stalking me on multiple boards - but never posting - for years.

That's not weird at all.

And a great way to introduce yourself to this brand new board you've never posted on before!

welcome, new and interesting friend!
 
Back
Top