• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

International sporting tournaments are just there to drum up nationalistic sentiment for the fatherland. I personally welcome two teams competing in the absence of such base instinctual manufacturing.

There's nothing wrong with having pride in the country you live in/are from as long as it doesn't turn into blind jingoist rubbish.
 
I'm so surprised at how fast he is at coming back defensively and trying so hard. You can compare him and McDavid in that area and it's not even close(McDavid even when he seems to be near his guy, he's nowhere as aggressive). For a guy to be this young and have such compete level, it's unreal. So excited about the season.
 
Possession-wise he has been the worst on the team other than Moore, but the talent is clear. He has been driving the net well, but he needs to get more pucks on net. Part of it may be due to his slow release, and a not-so-great shot but meh, it's only two games. He's definitely pretty pretty pretty good at hockey. Very exciting.
 
The funny thing here is that this euro team is STILL the worst team in the tourney.

Even then, if they stick with this format, I think latvians and norwegians would be surprised by how easily they can legit start rooting for a Team Europe like this eventually.

What sticks out to me about all the criticism is this - if they simply didn't have a team Europe or North America, but just kicked them out of the tourney and didn't replace them with any other teams and went with a 6 team tournament - would there be any valid criticism of this tournament left?
 
They're not sticking to the silly gimmick format. They're going to have a proper qualifying tournament for the final two spots in the 2020 tournament, which they should have done all along, but better later than ever.
 
What sticks out to me about all the criticism is this - if they simply didn't have a team Europe or North America, but just kicked them out of the tourney and didn't replace them with any other teams and went with a 6 team tournament - would there be any valid criticism of this tournament left?

6 teams is a pretty amateur number of teams. I'd actually prefer they expanded it to include 12 or 16 teams like the Olympics/World Championships do. 6 feels unnecessarily small and further takes away from any prestige that this event might otherwise have.
 
The funny thing here is that this euro team is STILL the worst team in the tourney.

Even then, if they stick with this format, I think latvians and norwegians would be surprised by how easily they can legit start rooting for a Team Europe like this eventually.

What sticks out to me about all the criticism is this - if they simply didn't have a team Europe or North America, but just kicked them out of the tourney and didn't replace them with any other teams and went with a 6 team tournament - would there be any valid criticism of this tournament left?
There would certainly be less criticism.

But it'd still be nice to have more than six teams, as well as having some sort of well-thought-out, fair process for countries to qualify for the tournament. Even something as simple as automatically granting the IIHF top-6 entry into the tournament, and having a four-team play-in prior to the tournament for the teams ranked 7-10.

As for the Euro team being the worst team in the tourney, I'd say it's a fair bet at least part of that is due to the fact that it's a team of strangers from several random countries thrown-together with no preparation time, no common mother tongue or culture and nothing really for them to rally around. At least the "Young Gunzz" have the "us vs. the veterans" thing going for them, as well as the fact that for every player, half the team is made up of guys they've grown up with in their country's development system.

Team Europe on the other hand? I'm not really sure what they've got going for them, beyond personal pride. Success may even be counter-productive for them, as it'd validate a format that could entirely shut their countries out of the highest level of international competition. And while this is just anecdotal evidence, I also can guarantee you as a guy that personally knows a bunch of rabid Latvian hockey fans in Toronto, that none of them give a shit about Team Europe just because it has a Latvian or two on the team. Just like Canadians wouldn't give a shit if FIFA admitted a "The other guys" team that included a token Canadian to their World Cup.
 
So many, many people root hard for world cup soccer teams that they have no actual affiliation with.
 
So many, many people root hard for world cup soccer teams that they have no actual affiliation with.

You're not seriously attempting to compare football culture and the draw of the international game in that sport with hockey are you?
 
Haven't you been the one saying we'd be stupid to do anything other than do exactly what fifa does?
 
No, but I still have no idea why you would compare the sport for which international competition is of such importance that players regularly leave their domestic clubs in the midst of title runs to play in friendlies or qualifying tournaments (and it's written into every contract that clubs have to release such players for their national side duties) with hockey, where no such culture exists, and in which players' only outlet for competing is at events run by the IIHF like the World Championships and the Olympics.

And in fact, part of the appeal for fans who cheer for certain nations even though they don't have an ethnic or ancestral origin to those countries, is the fact that proper international competitions in the game have reached a sufficiently high calibre and have such prestige around the world, that cheering for those teams is seen as the mark of cheering for a winner, getting on the bandwagon, and associating oneself with that team's dominance.

Look how many African or Asian fans cheer for Germany. You wouldn't see that level of support for a random continental team.
 
I don't even know what you are arguing, tbh.

are you saying that we are no longer allowed to create new things or something? or that it is impossible to?

what are you talking about, exactly?
 
Here's my problem with this...by this logic none of us should want the Toronto Maple Leafs to make the Stanley Cup Finals, we should just want the two best teams to make the final, because that would produce the best hockey to watch, right?

The whole point of national best on best is bragging rights, no? If team north america wins the whole thing, it will probably be great, fast hockey that we'll all enjoy seeing on display, but will anyone actually ****ing care about who won?

National best on best, in just about every sport on the planet, has a pretty solid history of growing interest in non traditional countries. It tends to lead to the growth of domestic leagues, the development of better international calibre players, and the growth of the game (any game) internationally, broader talent pools to choose from and in the end, a better quality product. No, it's not particularly fun to watch Canada pound the shit out of Norway in 2016, but seeing Norway fight for a bronze medal in 2036 because the game has become a legit passion in Norway would be pretty ****ing fun, no? I mean, if we're really interested in seeing the best hockey and all.

But nah, **** all that, we want to see an amalgamation of the the Canada and USA "B" teams entertain us right now. No vision for the future, just money in the pockets of the NHL owners now, with no vision for the international growth of the game.

if NA beat Canada all anybody will talk about is how Canada should have had mcdavid, etc
 
I don't like mixing with the US. Look at the animosity between Canada and the USA in the weekend games.

I guess it won't ever happen again but McDavid should be on Team Canada, and I have to think that guys like Eichel or Johnny Hockey would easily make Team USA
 
Back
Top