• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

the only team I really have an issue with is this "young" team

i cant think of a team i would cheer for them against
and they make handicap Canada and usa
 
zeke don't you have a connection to Italy or something? You seem to always talk about them during WC. So that point you made actually doesn't really help you. All those fans who choose to cheer for Brazil, Germany, Spain(usually best ones) when their main country is not in(like i cheer for Croats and Serbs sometimes) are not great examples(it's just temporary replacement of your real team) and have no real connection to any of the countries. LeafGM was spot on in that those Euro guys couldn't care less about some Team Europe(they would much rather play for their country).
 
Honest question - did any of the potential Team Euro players not show up?

Didn't pay attention to that but what if everyone did show up? You honestly think that even in NA players case, McDavid for example wouldn't be a lot happier to represent Canada instead of NA team? I'm not saying this isnt a very exciting tourney, i'm just saying it's not being taken as seriously(it's one step above All Star game for me..which is still cool but come on).
 
I don't think thats a fair criticism at all. The players sure seem to be taking it seriously. They are playing hard in exhibition games.

The pace has been as high level as you will get.

Players not taking it seriously isn't an issue here.
 
I don't think thats a fair criticism at all. The players sure seem to be taking it seriously. They are playing hard in exhibition games.

The pace has been as high level as you will get.

Players not taking it seriously isn't an issue here.

You're now taking it to a literal level where a player doesn't give a shit to a point that he won't even try in the game. Come on man, it's obvious what we're saying here. You ask any Euro player and any NA player right now and I'd bet you any amount that they'd say they don't mind this tourney but they'd rather play for their country.
 
But that is exactly what you are saying. "Its not being taken seriously" "Its a step up from the all-star game".

Maybe they'd rather play for their country, but those statements just aren't true.
 
I don't even know what you are arguing, tbh.

are you saying that we are no longer allowed to create new things or something? or that it is impossible to?

what are you talking about, exactly?

I don't honestly understand what your argument is supposed to be other than something something talent is teh awesomez!!11! and should replace all international events.

And that you have some bizarre antipathy to the growth of the game globally.
 
zeke don't you have a connection to Italy or something? You seem to always talk about them during WC. So that point you made actually doesn't really help you. All those fans who choose to cheer for Brazil, Germany, Spain(usually best ones) when their main country is not in(like i cheer for Croats and Serbs sometimes) are not great examples(it's just temporary replacement of your real team) and have no real connection to any of the countries. LeafGM was spot on in that those Euro guys couldn't care less about some Team Europe(they would much rather play for their country).

Pretty much this.
 
But that is exactly what you are saying. "Its not being taken seriously" "Its a step up from the all-star game".

Maybe they'd rather play for their country, but those statements just aren't true.

lol, Really? How about this..It's not being taken THAT SERIOUSLY? Better? As in, if they played for their country both the players and fans would take it more seriously. But whatever, if you think this is something at the level of Olympics and such, good for you.
 
And i love how the compete level came into this. I could play pond hockey and i would still want to kick ass simply because i am a very competitive person. I hate losing. Of course there will be many out there who will still want to win.
 
I guess I just can't understand what kind of intrinsic level of pride any athlete would get playing for an entirely random continental team comprised of an assorted collection of players primarily from your single biggest international rival, further segregated by a subjective age discriminator, potentially defeating your actual national team. That would be such an awful/conflicted feeling.
 
And i love how the compete level came into this. I could play pond hockey and i would still want to kick ass simply because i am a very competitive person. I hate losing. Of course there will be many out there who will still want to win.

Exactly.

There are reports of Crosby being pissed off for twelve hours because he'd lose a table tennis match to Fleury or Letang in the Pens locker room. These are elite international athletes that represent the pinnacle of their sport. Of course they're going to be competitive.

That isn't an affirmation in any sense of the credibility of the format.
 
I guess I just can't understand what kind of intrinsic level of pride any athlete would get playing for an entirely random continental team comprised of an assorted collection of players primarily from your single biggest international rival, further segregated by a subjective age discriminator, potentially defeating your actual national team. That would be such an awful/conflicted feeling.

these players have competed for teams associated with cities, regions, provinces, countries, etc. etc. their whole lives. When they play for their country they play alongside some their fiercest local rivals. What is the difference?
 
I don't honestly understand what your argument is supposed to be other than something something talent is teh awesomez!!11! and should replace all international events.

er, yes, talent is awesome.

and there's nothing to replace. The olympics is just one of many world's best tournaments I have watched and enjoyed.

And that you have some bizarre antipathy to the growth of the game globally.

this is so backwards it's funny.
 
these players have competed for teams associated with cities, regions, provinces, countries, etc. etc. their whole lives. When they play for their country they play alongside some their fiercest local rivals. What is the difference?

You don't appear to understand the human concept of identity very well or (as I suspect) you do, but you're ignoring it because it calls into question the entire premise of having two random teams in your beloved tournament.
 
er, yes, talent is awesome.

and there's nothing to replace. The olympics is just one of many world's best tournaments I have watched and enjoyed.

You're not getting it or willfully ignoring it. The NHL is very strongly considering pulling out of the Olympics. People do not want this tournament to replace it. Bettman is stupid enough to do something that damaging.

As a pre-season, nice little tournament of relative consequence, it's fine. As a replacement for the greatest international winter sporting event on the planet? No.

this is so backwards it's funny.

Then why do you object to the inclusion of actual top ten hockey nations in international tournaments just because they're unlikely to win the damn thing? How do you achieve growth without allowing lower-tier competitors play against the best?
 
You don't appear to understand the human concept of identity very well or (as I suspect) you do, but you're ignoring it because it calls into question the entire premise of having two random teams in your beloved tournament.

You're the one ignoring the obvious because for some weird reason you think national pride is the one pure and true force in sports or soemthing.
 
I was thinking the same thing, Team Europe particularly will have players who have played against each other in bitter international games. Now, I suppose it's true that this would take place in any professional league as well - but you have to wonder what the dressing room would be like.

I also think, that the NHLPA has sold this tournament to it's members, and the players are sharing in the revenues here. There is also a pride in being selected for any team, by internationally recognized management teams.

On top of that, the simple alternative to this tournament is NHL training camp.

Rockstar preseason tournament -or- skating with AHLers?
 
Exactly.

There are reports of Crosby being pissed off for twelve hours because he'd lose a table tennis match to Fleury or Letang in the Pens locker room. These are elite international athletes that represent the pinnacle of their sport. Of course they're going to be competitive.

That isn't an affirmation in any sense of the credibility of the format.

Yep. You could also make a point against compete level really. I mean, i've seen all the NA-Europe games and Canada-US games so far and the way NA players were skating and using their skill against Europeans, i kept wondering are these guys this good or the Euro guys just not trying that hard(i mean these are the best Euro players, no?). Similar in Canada-US game, where at times there's a lot of standing around going on..but anyways...
 
Back
Top