• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

Agree with that.... that said 16 teams is ridiculous.

For now it is yeah, the depth of talent just isn't there. Fwiw, this is the current IIHF rankings

1) Canada
2) Russia
3) Finland
4) USA
5) Sweden
6) Czech
7) Switzerland
8) Slovakia
9) Belarus
10) Germany
11) Norway
12) Latvia
13) Denmark
14) France
15) Slovenia
16) Kazakhstan

While I wouldn't mind seeing a few of the bottom 7-8 teams qualify for a 10 team tournament, yeah, I have no need to see the whole pile of them.
 
Team Europe ensures more minor nations are included, not less.

and phoenix is not really a comp - at no point has there ever been even a 50th as big a talent gap between the yotes and the other nhl teams as there is between the minor hockey nations and the big boys.
 
Yes, and every little Slovenian boy grows up dreaming about scoring on an overtime breakaway to win the gold for mother Europe.

sometimes you have to make history, not be bound by it.

many a boy dreams of playing for the Windies.
 
Thought experiment - if there was a Team Concacaf in world soccer, not including USA and MEX, which allowed the best canadian players to play in the world cup - would that be better or worse for Canadian Soccer?

I think better.
 
Excluding minor hockey nations from major tournaments is the best way to ensure that they remain minor hockey nations. These tournies are great for exposure, great for getting kids interested in the game, etc. We all shit on the existence of the Coyotes, but 19 yrs later a kid who grew up in Phoenix is our lord and saviour. That's not an accident.

It's no surprise that countries like Switzerland and Denmark are starting to produce first round picks and the level of parity throughout the international game has grown exponentially as a result of them playing consistently against the big boys.

How is one to grow the game if the lower-tier nations never have the exposure to the top-tier ones? I've brought it up many times before, but Canada went from defeating Denmark 47-0 at the 1949 Worlds to tying them 2-2 at the 2003 edition of the tournament (which Canada won the gold medal at).

That's how you grow the game throughout the world and improve the overall level of competition. You don't accomplish that by isolating nations that you deem to be inferior or unworthy of your attention and never allowing them to compete against the more developed programs. Basketball, for instance, never would have grown throughout Europe and a large portion of Asia without exposure to American talent. Baseball never would have become a global game if the authorities did not allow the Americans to play games against Japan and the Cuban/Dominican/other South American and Caribbean national teams.
 
Agree with that.... that said 16 teams is ridiculous.

I have no problem with twelve or sixteen teams. I actually like the larger tournament format because it allows some of the lower-end countries in the top-tier group to gain more exposure to elite talent and learn how to play against them.

Probably the only countries in IIHF top-tier that have almost zero chance of a potential knock-off upset are Slovenia and Kazakhstan.
 
Thought experiment - if there was a Team Concacaf in world soccer, not including USA and MEX, which allowed the best canadian players to play in the world cup - would that be better or worse for Canadian Soccer?

I think better.

By excluding most of the Canadians who would otherwise play in international tournaments? How? There wouldn't be more than a handful of Canadians on such a hypothetical team.

It would be mainly Costa Ricans, Trinidadians, Hondurans, and Panamanians, with the odd Jamaican. Maybe one or two Canadians could make a "best of the rest" CONCACAF squad. It would be of zero benefit to the program.
 
Thought experiment - if there was a Team Concacaf in world soccer, not including USA and MEX, which allowed the best canadian players to play in the world cup - would that be better or worse for Canadian Soccer?

I think better.

Yeah, it would be way better for us to see 1-2 Canadians playing internationally and for our kids to know that they'll never see a major tournament unless they're one of the best 2 players in the country, instead of an entire squad playing internationally.
 
Please do explain to us again how multiple island archipelagos spread out over thousands of square km in the Atlantic Ocean and Caribbean Sea, with a unified culture and shared identity, compares in any way to a multitudinous number of developed, first world nations, with thousands of years of individual history, extremely well-developed independent identities and localized cultures, a history of dozens upon dozens of conflicts against one another, and extremely tight geographic proximity, with a population anywhere from twenty five to thirty times larger?
 
no you didn't.

There's 1 west indies nation in their cricket federation with more than 700-800K in population. They simply don't have the resources to compete internationally without banding together. If Lithuania, Latvia, and Belarus had hockey federations that wanted to band together because they have a total population of 13M and don't have the resources to put together individual national team programs that could compete, I'd understand. Germany though? France?
 
Even in FIFA there exists no "Team Oceania," even though it probably gets awfully tiresome for New Caledonia, Fiji, and Tahiti to be routinely curb-stomped by New Zealand every year (and prior to their defection to the AFC, Australia).
 
There's 1 west indies nation in their cricket federation with more than 700-800K in population. They simply don't have the resources to compete internationally without banding together. If Lithuania, Latvia, and Belarus had hockey federations that wanted to band together because they have a total population of 13M and don't have the resources to put together individual national team programs that could compete, I'd understand. Germany though? France?

GO TEAM BALTIC SEA!
 
shared identity and unified culture?

making things up doesn't help you.

Admitting you don't understand basic human sociological concepts in the context of international competition, which is predicated precisely on exploring these concepts through sport, doesn't help your argument in any way.
 
Back
Top