• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

World Cup

There's 1 west indies nation in their cricket federation with more than 700-800K in population. They simply don't have the resources to compete internationally without banding together. If Lithuania, Latvia, and Belarus had hockey federations that wanted to band together because they have a total population of 13M and don't have the resources to put together individual national team programs that could compete, I'd understand. Germany though? France?

is population a relevant factor if countries can't even ice AHL calibre talent?
 
GO TEAM BALTIC SEA!

I get it in the instances where it's a voluntary sharing of resources among nations that would have to make the decision between national program and no national program. But even in those cases, I'm sure the people of that country and the members of their hockey federation would much prefer being able to stand on their own.
 
Admitting you don't understand basic human sociological concepts in the context of international competition, which is predicated precisely on exploring these concepts through sport, doesn't help your argument in any way.

You're standing by your claim of Shared Identity and Unified Culture?
 
I was pissed about team NA robbing Canada of a few guys like McDavid, but really the U.S. are the ones who have suffered the most. Gaudreau, Eichel, Matthews, Gostisbehere, Saad would be looking pretty useful right now.

should would a bunch of guys they decided not to take
 
You're standing by your claim of Shared Identity and Unified Culture?

In addition to geographic necessity, limited population, relatively low levels of individual member development, and a 1960s/1970s sporting culture that made such an outcome possible in the context of the time that would not be contemplated today, sure.
 
is population a relevant factor if countries can't even ice AHL calibre talent?

There isn't one country in the IIHF top sixteen (and I'd include Austria on the list of teams not in that group) that couldn't compete against any AHL team.
 
In addition to geographic necessity, limited population, relatively low levels of individual member development, and a 1960s/1970s sporting culture that made such an outcome possible in the context of the time that would not be contemplated today, sure.

I can't keep up with the power of your buzzwords.
 
is population a relevant factor if countries can't even ice AHL calibre talent?

It's not the only factor, but it's a relevant factor, yeah. National hockey programs get better through this process of exposure, get kids hooked on the game (that's the real fight, getting your best athletic kids into the game, and parents willing/able to shoulder the load of developing a young hockey player) and over a few generations, turn the program into something competitive on the world stage. Gotta crawl before you can walk, and that's even more important in a nation like Germany or France with a big, relatively wealthy population base. I know you dismiss the nationalism angle here, but it's your blindspot. For good or bad, kids get exposed to people from their country playing in major tournaments and cheer for them, wanting to be like them. That's the next generation of hockey players. There's tons of example of relative backwaters becoming major talent pools because of singular events or players capturing the imagination of a generation of kids. Miracle on Ice and American hockey, the impact Vince Carter had on basketball in Toronto is massive, etc, etc.
 
There isn't one country in the IIHF top sixteen (and I'd include Austria on the list of teams not in that group) that couldn't compete against any AHL team.

hmm, pretty sure most of them don't have more than a handful of ahl calibre players.
 
Neither can I keep up with the potency of your shitty analogies and argument evasion.

It's a clear analogy - the Windies is a legitimate and even legendary team despite having no actual national identity. It exists despite all the member nations having their own NTs. Little boys do indeed grow up dreaming of competing for the Windies - much more than they would dream of playing for their noncompetitive NTs.

Your made up buzzwords are the only evasion here.
 
hmm, pretty sure most of them don't have more than a handful of ahl calibre players.

Most of team Latvia plays in the KHL. If they can play in the KHL, I'd argue they can play in the AHL. They're in the bottom end of the top 16.
 
hmm, pretty sure most of them don't have more than a handful of ahl calibre players.

Being "pretty sure" isn't an argument. Russian teams comprised largely of KHL players have taken down Canadian teams with numerous Olympians on them in international competition routinely throughout the years.

Most European teams, even the lower-tier ones, could defeat AHL teams. And they definitely have AHL-calibre players. But would you choose to stay at home and make bank, where you can play for your local team, or travel to a foreign country where you'll earn a fraction of the pay, be anonymous, under-appreciated, and not receive as many opportunities? Seems like an easy decision to make.

The AHL really isn't appreciably better than the top-tier European leagues. It's arguable that it has less skill and more grinders as well.
 
It's a clear analogy - the Windies is a legitimate and even legendary team despite having no actual national identity. It exists despite all the member nations having their own NTs. Little boys do indeed grow up dreaming of competing for the Windies - much more than they would dream of playing for their noncompetitive NTs.

Your made up buzzwords are the only evasion here.

The West Indies are currently ranked eighth in both the ICC one day international and test match rankings. They haven't made a Cricket World Cup final in 33 years. The two times they won were with rosters largely comprised of British expats and players who had grown up in the United Kingdom.

Let's not make this as disingenuous as you're attempting to frame things here.

And reality is not a buzzword. The fact that you don't understand basic political and sociological concepts really makes sense, because you have a clear inability to understand the purpose of international competition. You've never liked it, you've never appreciated it, you've stated numerous times on here throughout the years how you don't care how Canada does in any tournaments, etc. So just come out and admit it.

And any little boy growing up in the Caribbean would absolutely choose to play for their individual countries over a geographic conglomeration. The same can be said anywhere else in the world.

Most people outside of North America actually have STRONGER attachments to their countries than we do here, not weaker, which might strike some observers as odd given how patriotic a lot of Americans are, but it's not even comparable. They care.
 
It exists despite all the member nations having their own NTs.

Their national teams only compete regionally, not internationally. Calling them national teams is technically accurate but not within the context of international sports as they only compete against other nations in the regions or pro teams within the region.

Little boys do indeed grow up dreaming of competing for the Windies

Because they'll never compete against India, England, etc playing for their national team

much more than they would dream of playing for their noncompetitive NTs.

You didn't know that they only compete in region, did you?
 
The funny thing is that all of the West Indies federation members, as Mindz alluded to, do have their own individual national teams and compete in the Caribbean region. In fact, if you take a look at the current West Indies roster, you'll see that all of their players currently compete "domestically" for Barbados, Guyana, Jamaica, or Trinidad.
 
Most of team Latvia plays in the KHL. If they can play in the KHL, I'd argue they can play in the AHL. They're in the bottom end of the top 16.

looking at their WC '16 team:

NHL: 1
AHL: 2
KHL: 3
CZE: 1
SVK: 1
SWZ: 2
LAT: 13
KZK: 1
HUN: 1
ITA: 1
 
The funny thing is that all of the West Indies federation members, as Mindz alluded to, do have their own individual national teams and compete in the Caribbean region. In fact, if you take a look at the current West Indies roster, you'll see that all of their players currently compete "domestically" for Barbados, Guyana, Jamaica, or Trinidad.

Exactly. Which supports my point.
 
Their national teams only compete regionally, not internationally. Calling them national teams is technically accurate but not within the context of international sports as they only compete against other nations in the regions or pro teams within the region.

Because they'll never compete against India, England, etc playing for their national team

You didn't know that they only compete in region, did you?

I'm not sure what your point is.

are you arguing that their NTs not playing internationally hurts the sports popularity in their country?
 
Back
Top