• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2014 NHL Draft Thread

MORRISON: You know Brendan himself was a black and blue, skilled player. He was a very competitive, skilled player. I think he himself likes those kind of players as well. We as an organization, we've always sort of wanted those kind of guys. Yes, along the way we've maybe tried to get a different type of player at different times and sometimes that's difficult to do. But I think anybody in our organization would tell you that competitiveness is really important and obviously you need to have skill on your team. Those are important ingredients. But you also have to have a certain number of physical players that play hard and can play the game two ways; preferably everybody plays hard and two ways. You do have different types on your team. Competitiveness is really important to us. Certainly you want to be a big, strong, skilled team if you can be.

MORRISON: That's a million dollar question. Sometimes if you think you can get a third line player, big centre like Fred Gauthier we'll use an example. Is he going to be an impact player in his own way? Well, we believe he is. Is it going to be as an offensive player? No. Is he going to be an integral part of a winning team at some point? We certainly hope so and we think so. So there's a lot of these different things that you think about. And it takes a lot of different pieces to make a winning team and some people get focused on the idea that you have to get 150 points in junior to be a good NHL player and that certainly is a good indicator, but it's not everything. Weighing everything out, yes, you'd love to get that high-impact offensive, first-line player with every pick. The reality is that's very tough to do. So when we're doing that you're weighing 'well what are the odds of this guy getting there versus this guy? And what will he bring to your lineup? And is it going to be valuable? And is it going to be tough to find when you need that?' That's another question. Teams will give up first round picks for players because they don't have [that specific skill] at some point.

http://www.tsn.ca/toronto/blogs/jonas_siegel/?id=455493

It's just my opinion, but I'm not sure changing the mandate is going to change things as dramatically as everyone thinks.
 
Sometimes if you think you can get a third line player, big centre like Fred Gauthier we'll use an example. Is he going to be an impact player in his own way? Well, we believe he is. Is it going to be as an offensive player? No. Is he going to be an integral part of a winning team at some point? We certainly hope so and we think so.

Just in case anyone was still unsure.
 
That statement should be reserved for a 3/4 round pick not a top 30. I am sure Gauthier will be useful down the road but what he described can be picked up outside of the 1st round.
 
Yeah, I'm not liking that Morrison is still sticking to his guns on the Gauthier pick.

We should not be picking guys that our scouts view as having "third line potential" in the first round. Full stop.
 
So there's a lot of these different things that you think about. And it takes a lot of different pieces to make a winning team and some people get focused on the idea that you have to get 150 points in junior to be a good NHL player and that certainly is a good indicator, but it's not everything.

This is the statement that bothers me the most here. Morrison shouldn't really give a damn about what "type" of player we need to build a winner in the NHL, but instead providing the system with the highest volume of skilled players for the GM of the moment to build with. High level skill is easy to trade for anything else you might need to build the winner you want, but when you're a club in need of skill, and you don't have it, you have to fleece other teams to get it.
 
Meh, I know what they think about him, I still disagree.

If they shared your stance on his upside, then I'd be more than OK with picking him where they picked him. At least I'd understand the logic.

My issue is that they have the stance that he's only a third liner and picked him anyway which is irritating.
 
I normally believe in drafting based on need, but you don't draft a 3rd liner in the 1st round... those guys are a dime adozen and can be found in rounds 2-7, as well as by trade or on the open market.
 
I normally believe in drafting based on need, but you don't draft a 3rd liner in the 1st round... those guys are a dime adozen and can be found in rounds 2-7, as well as by trade or on the open market.

Can't believe I'm asking this but... why!?
 
I normally believe in drafting based on need, but you don't draft a 3rd liner in the 1st round... those guys are a dime adozen and can be found in rounds 2-7, as well as by trade or on the open market.

Teams make the most mistakes when they draft for need....pass up superior players to "fill a hole". I'd say I'm surprised you feel that way, but I'd be lying.
 
The reason is this- Nowadays very few good players are available by trade, even fewer make it to the open market.... so if you can address a key need then you use the draft to do it. For instance, if theres an elite centre available but the most skilled player is a winger (as an example) is available at said postion... it's an easy pick, take the centre to address a weakness.
 
What group of NHL scouts have you ever heard talk about selecting "third-line talent" in the first round? Yet he keeps saying it over and over again.
 
Plus that drafted player is probably 1-3 years away from even properly filling that hole and by then your needs could be completely different.

Annnnnd I'm wasting my breath so to speak here, aren't I?

*Edit* Yes. Yes I am. Nevermind.
 
Drafting for need is the dubmest thing a team can do... prospects are 3-4 years away from making an impact and you don't know what your needs will be at that point.

BPA and if 2 players are even then take the one that plays the premium position.

ALWAYS MAXIMIZE YOUR ASSETS IN HOCKEY LIKE IN LIFE
 
The reason is this- Nowadays very few good players are available by trade, even fewer make it to the open market.... so if you can address a key need then you use the draft to do it. For instance, if theres an elite centre available but the most skilled player is a winger (as an example) is available at said postion... it's an easy pick, take the centre to address a weakness.

Nonis is a very adept trader, if he had tradable youth he could very easily get the winning parts he needed at any time.
 
Plus that drafted player is probably 1-3 years away from even properly filling that hole and by then your needs could be completely different.

Annnnnd I'm wasting my breath so to speak here, aren't I?

Not nescessarily, there have been alot of 1st rounders that have made their teams right away and had some type of an impact. You asked for my opinion, I was merely answering your question.
 
Pretty hard to project what a teams needs will be in 5-7 years when the player draft (outside of top 5) is having an impact at the NHL level.
 
Back
Top