• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

And to me, it means I'd much rather go with a Canadian than an American. I think OHL stats typically project very well, and it is easy to read the Q / W numbers. Not so with NCAA. Also, I am never sure what kind of impact playing in the fishtank like Toronto has on American players, whereas a kid from Toronto would at least already know what to expect.

This is awful, awful logic.
 
Okay, no question these picks are valuable, but this is just an insane under-valuing of the assets on Toronto's side.


Wanting to finish 4th instead of 3rd is pretty irrational. Is it because you want one of Strome or Marner, and no one else?

Do you not realize that if we finish in 4th, we're still in a position where both could be gone before we step up to the podium? Finishing 3rd guarantees that we have the chance to pick one of McDavid, Strome or Marner.

The truth is, after the pain of this year, I want exactly what I want out of the draft, and nothing less.

I would be very disappointed if we took Hanifin. Not to say that he won't be a great player, but I want that cornerstone C. We will never get it outside of the draft and this is the one time that there are three of them within striking distance. it would literally kill me to pass it up for a D, and so I want the decision to be out of the hands of management, and focused only on which of Strome or Marner to take. And right now I'm leaning Strome actually - tough to pass up that size, with everything else he's got going for him.

So I do realize 3rd guarantees our SHOT at either Strome or Marner, but it doesn't guarantee we take that shot. It could result in taking Hanifin, and I don't want to see that happen.
 
I want Edmonton to win. I want Arizona and Buffalo to lose.

I'll explain why.

First, Edmonton can catch us. And I'd take Strome over Hanifin anyway. So, doing it at 3 or 4 doesn't really matter. But, we have a better chance at winning the lottery at 3 than at 4.

Second, if a team behind us wins the lottery, we can only move as far back as 4.

Third, if Edmonton doesn't catch us, they're more likely to draft Hanifin than Strome or Marner at the 3rd spot. Phoenix is more likely than Edmonton to draft either Marner or Strome over Hanifin and, as I've previously said, Phoenix's scouts would have seen a lot of both Strome and Marner as two of the Dogs top prospects play in the OHL Midwest.

With our history, we take Hanifin over Strome too, and we can't afford for that to happen.

Now, all of this said, if we finish 3rd somehow, sure it gives us a marginal improvement in odds to get McDavid, but I'd want it only if the plan was to dangle the 3rd to Edmonton for their 4th, and get something nice from them, just to take Strome 4th.

But again, I don't trust anything or anyone anymore, so I'd rather just take 4th.
 
You could have more accurately summed up your position by saying, "I really hope we end up with one of Strome/Marner and not Hanifin". Which people may or may not agree with, but either way, more logical than "I hope we have a worse draft pick"
 
You could have more accurately summed up your position by saying, "I really hope we end up with one of Strome/Marner and not Hanifin". Which people may or may not agree with, but either way, more logical than "I hope we have a worse draft pick"

You're not paying attention.

I don't want management to have the chance of taking Hanifin over those two.

There's only one way to more or less guarantee that.
 
The only valid reason to take a Strome/Marner over Hanifin is if you think they are better.

Position, birth, fandom. None of that matters. Doughty and Kopitar didn't grow up Kings fans. Toews and Kane didn't grow up Hawks fans. Duchene grew up as an Avs fan though. Its completely irrelevant.
 
It is in no way irrelevant.

It doesn't change the on-ice performance in all likelihood, but it brings back that Wendel bleeding blue and white quality which we lack.

We need that back, and no one better to bring it than the best player on the team, which Strome or Marner would be.
 
It is in no way irrelevant.

It doesn't change the on-ice performance in all likelihood, but it brings back that Wendel bleeding blue and white quality which we lack.

We need that back, and no one better to bring it than the best player on the team, which Strome or Marner would be.

All sorts of stupid.

You don't allow passport and " perceived heart attributed from passport" to be a factor in deciding a franchise changing top 5 pick.

It's LoF level dumb.
 
All sorts of stupid.

You don't allow passport and " perceived heart attributed from passport" to be a factor in deciding a franchise changing top 5 pick.

It's LoF level dumb.

Listen, moron, there's an intangible associated with drafting a kid who's wanted to play for the team since he was born.

Not surprising that a dummy who was born in one city and cheers for a team in another doesn't understand this.
 
Back
Top