• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

I don't think we'll be able to get the 5 away from Carolina - they're in the same boat as us really. Maybe 6.
Not that I think it's likely we acquire their pick, but are they though? They're still hanging on to 31 year-old Eric Staal and his 27 year-old brother Jordan. I'd think that as long as they're committed to keeping those guys, they're still in somewhat more of a "win now" mode than we are.
 
He who shall not be named suggested Kessel for the 5th and Semin a week ago.

Typical bs from him but something that may be worth exploring due to the reasons you previously mentioned.

They are at a cross roads right now of continuing to rebuild while the Staals age or go for it and acquire some top talent to help them compete now
 
Not sure how people actually put these stuff down on paper. Its embarrassing really. "We think the Leafs will give up most of their good players for the privilege of taking on the league's worst contract and a prospect"
 
I mean that's a lot to give up, but if you are getting Marner, Strome or Hanifin there...

I remember people scoffing last year at the idea of trading Phaneuf, and JVR/Kadri, or whatever the rumour was, to move up to #1. Sure its a lot to pay, but having Aaron Ekblad would be pretty damn nice right now.

If you are getting an 18 year old that looks like a safe bet to become a high end player in the league, maybe its fine to "lose" the trade on paper.
 
The latest ISS (International Scouting Service) rankings have come out...and they're a head-scratcher:

UUmeTsW.jpg

5pkCRf8.jpg
 
Crouse is a "safe pick" you know what you'll get, but I don't see too much upside compared to his peers. But he's big and Canadian, and probably filled with intangibles.
 
Last edited:
I mean that's a lot to give up, but if you are getting Marner, Strome or Hanifin there...

I remember people scoffing last year at the idea of trading Phaneuf, and JVR/Kadri, or whatever the rumour was, to move up to #1. Sure its a lot to pay, but having Aaron Ekblad would be pretty damn nice right now.

If you are getting an 18 year old that looks like a safe bet to become a high end player in the league, maybe its fine to "lose" the trade on paper.

Walking away with 2 of Marner/Strome/Hanifin would be a massive step forward in the rebuild

It would be worth losing the trade on paper
 
Crouse is a "safe pick" you know what you'll get, but I don't see too much upside compared to his peers. But he's big and Canadian, and probably filled with intangibles.
Clearly a lot of the guys doing the scouting and ranking for these central scouting services are old school "Eye test FTW" type hockey people.

I left this out for the sheer stupidity of even suggesting it

However the Kessel for the 5th and Semin idea I can live with
The Kadri/Kessel trade suggestion is the typical kind of BS you see from casual or uninformed hockey fans that really don't have the faintest idea about trade value.

If it weren't for David Clarkson or Mike Richards, Alex Semin's contract and the three years/$21M left on it would easily be in contention for the title of "worst contract in the league". Simply taking on that contract alone amounts to a pretty huge amount of trade value, never mind adding a 27/28 year old 35 goal/PPG winger to the other side of the ledger.
 
Is taking on his contract worth potentially getting two franchise players in one draft?
I think you could potentially make the argument that the Leafs should be getting more, but if Kessel for Semin/5th overall was on the table, I'd probably do it.
 
it is only 3 years.... and that horton exemption only kicks in if we are up near the cap by 5 million. So I think we have to keep some salary.

If we lose the 8 from Kessel and the 7 from Dion, then I think we have to take back a Semin and a Weiss to field a squad and to keep our salary up there.

I might do it as well.
 
I don't mind picking up the Semin contract, because in reality, we most likely won't be signing a lot of high profile UFA's in the next 3 yrs as we're rebuilding - BUT it's one thing to take on that contract, it's another to take on that AND not get properly compensated for it.

2 of Kessel, Kadri and Semin contract I can stomach for getting the 5th overall pick, but not all 3.

I mean, sure I love everything I hear about Haninfin / Strome / Marner - but there's no guarantee they'll not turn out to be another Kessel / Phaneuf / Kadri either. Prospects are prospects and even though there's a chance they may pan out to be franchise players, there's also a chance they don't, and we should give up accordingly in a trade because of that.
 
Most would agree any prospect has a probability of not living up to the hype or being a complete bust but if you're going to roll the dice on one then this draft is the one to do it.

The top 5 could arguably be a 1st overall in many of drafts in the past 10 years.
 
The latest ISS (International Scouting Service) rankings have come out...and they're a head-scratcher:

UUmeTsW.jpg

5pkCRf8.jpg

Interesting placements here:

Crouse is too high...he's projectable, true. But there are a lot of guys whose ceilings are higher.

Zacha ahead of Werenski is insanity....Zacha's biggest problem is between his ears. Werenski's greatest asset is between his.

Timo Meier is a little too low.....kid's going to be a stud winger.

People are starting to say there isn't much difference between Bittner and Crouse, other rankings starting to reflect this.

Highest I've seen Joel Eriksson yet. He ended the season really well. He has Thommie Bergmann written all over them. Only Matt Barzal did more for his draft stock at the U-18.

Svechnikov is too low.

Good to see some respect for Colin White. He's the ultimate David Poile type player.

Jeremy Bracco is going to be the interesting player at the end of the first round. He could go anywhere from 25-60. He's also got Montreal written all over him.
 
What happened to Kylington for him to drop completely out of the first?

Ive seen him range from top 10 to bottom 20 in most rankings
 
Back
Top