• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

For grins...

3. Strome
4. Marner
5. Hanifin
6. Barzal

For the Leafs, I'd prefer either of Marner or Hanifin over Strome, but I realize that's not a popular opinion for some. Skating is part of it, but he also seems ineffective when he's unable to slow the game down -- and I wonder how this will translate at the next level. It's a question, that's all. Not calling him a bust. That said, if Hunter/Shanny decide Strome is the best choice, it's cool. Totally trust Hunter's judgment. We're going to get a great prospect, regardless.
 
I really want 2 picks in that top 5.

Realize the asking price has been high, but I think it would be a huge, huge turn for the team to get 2 of Strome, Marner, Hanifin.
 
Here's what I think.

Strome goes 3 to Phoenix.

Marner goes 4 to Toronto.

Hanifin goes 5 to Carolina

Crouse goes 6 to New Jersey
And I'd be perfectly fine with that.

I have been watching tons of Strome vs Marner video's lately and I am convinced though I'm fine with Strome, Marner is the guy I really want.

Marner has the underdog mentality, and from reports I've heard, the spirit and the work ethics to go with it. You watch him in those videos and it is very obvious he has MUCH higher level of skillsets compared to Strome. Strome plays a simple game which he can be successful in because of his size, reach, and his vision. Marner make moves that Strome can't, and in a lot of ways remind me of Nylander and his puck skills.

Can Marner play C in the NHL? I'd say Babs is the final judge of that but right now I see him as a W more than a C. So the question becomes who is our 1C if Nylander and Marner are both 'converted' into wingers?

Time will tell but I am VERY optimistic Kadri, given his skills and his vision, will be a different player under Babcocks. And though not a bonafide franchise #1C, I have no problem with Kadri as our 1C especially if he flanks the likes of Nylander, Marner, or a rejuvenated Kessel.
 
I've been saying it for a long time, but give me Marner's skating and skill level. Especially when it is combined with his tenacity/work ethic without the puck. I don't care about size. I don't care about position. The Leafs are too early in the process to bother worrying about those things anyway. They just need elite talent.

And I think he is a center anyway. Watching Tyler Johnson these playoffs makes it pretty tough to write a guy off as a center because of size. And Marner isn't even that small.
 
There are going to be some pretty awesome centers available near the top of next year's draft too. And even if Babcock does motivate whatever roster we assemble into getting us closer to the 10 slot than the top-5, the fact they'll be drawing for the top three picks will give us three chances to move to near the top of the draft order.

As far as next year's centers---there's Auston Matthews, of course, but Logan Brown is particularly interesting. He just turned 17 in March, and scored 43 points in 56 games this year. And he's also a 6'5" 215lb center that's been described as an elite skater. Another fun factoid about him---he was born while his father, former NHLer Jeff Brown, was having a Cup of coffee as a Maple Leaf in the middle of the 97/98 season.

Anyways, point being---as much as the idea of finally landing that big, potential prototypical #1 center in the draft this year is appealing, our top pick in this draft isn't our last and only chance at ending up with that kind of player. If Mark Hunter comes as advertised, maybe we can even land a great center outside of the top of the draft. So don't stress about position, size or place of birth---just draft the most talented player that you believe will turn into the best NHLer. And as we get closer to the draft, I'm increasingly warming to the idea that player might be Mitch Marner.
 
Strong indications are that Leafs will take Marner at 4; they do prefer Strome so don't rule out a possible trade. Also the Leafs brass are very high on Futa
 
really? interesting, I would've thought Marner was their guy.
The thing about that assumption is---sure, we do have Mark Hunter and that other London Knights guy we just hired in the scouting department, and it's probably reasonable to assume that they're fans of Marner. But it's not like they ever had a chance to get Strome when they were with the Knights.

Strome went 2nd overall in the 2013 OHL draft, while London didn't get to pick until the 19th and last overall pick of the first round that year---which they used to draft Marner.
 
I agree.

But I'm thinking more about the scenario where Strome is gone at #3 and we have to choose between Marner and Hanifin. Pretty confident given those relationships that we're taking Marner.

Makes me a happy camper.
 
I firmly believe the Coyotes will draft Dylan Strome and we'll pick Mitch Marner. I'm not certain that it's the right pick and I'm not certain it's not. There's at least as much to like about Noah Hanifin as there is Mitch Marner.

One thing I do want to caution against is letting Tyler Biggs impact the view of bigger players on the board. You will end up with a Jordan Schroeder for every Tyler Biggs.
 
One thing I do want to caution against is letting Tyler Biggs impact the view of bigger players on the board. You will end up with a Jordan Schroeder for every Tyler Biggs.

It's not a bigger player thing, it's a shitty production/low offensive potential thing.

Have nothing against big players. No concerns with taking Hanifan if that's what they go with.
 
It's not a bigger player thing, it's a shitty production/low offensive potential thing.

Have nothing against big players. No concerns with taking Hanifan if that's what they go with.

is it though? i remember the anyone but Trouba comments. it seemed a bunch of people hated the idea of him merely because he was a big physical player
 
It's not a bigger player thing, it's a shitty production/low offensive potential thing.

Have nothing against big players. No concerns with taking Hanifan if that's what they go with.

It may not be for some posters. But there's definitely a common tone that seems to occur when discussing comparable prospects with a considerable size difference.
 
is it though? i remember the anyone but Trouba comments. it seemed a bunch of people hated the idea of him merely because he was a big physical player

I don't think I ever said anyone but Trouba but you're right, I didn't particularly want Trouba which was obviously the wrong opinion.

I do feel that scouts sometimes drool a little too much over big players and ignore red flags (Crouse?). It doesn't mean I think we shouldn't take big players though.
 
Have you noticed this re: Hanifan? I haven't at all?

Not with Hanifin.

But let's look at the two players we spend most of our time talking about and their perceived most evident flaws.

Dylan Strome by all accounts has incredible hands, great size, outstanding vision, a great shot and is a killer in the faceoff circle. His skating is only average for a top NHL prospect.

Mitch Marner by all accounts incredible hands, great hockey sense, is a phenomenal skater and has a high compete level. He's more undersized - not shorter - than you would like to see in a top NHL prospect.

I believe that's a fair description of both prospects.

I will guarantee, if we go back through the thread, we will see more mentions of Strome's skating than Marner's size. I will further guarantee that most mentions of Marner's size are made by people trying to defend a criticism that wasn't, at the time, being made about Marner's size.

My worry is that our experience with Tyler Biggs and Connor Brown is creating a lens that isn't accurate. It's causing us to say that a big player with a skating concern is a higher bust likelihood than an undersized player. That's simply not the case and is far too general an analysis.

Hence for every Tyler Biggs on the one side, you get a Jordan Schroeder on the other.
 
Not with Hanifin.

But let's look at the two players we spend most of our time talking about and their perceived most evident flaws.

Dylan Strome by all accounts has incredible hands, great size, outstanding vision, a great shot and is a killer in the faceoff circle. His skating is only average for a top NHL prospect.

Mitch Marner by all accounts incredible hands, great hockey sense, is a phenomenal skater and has a high compete level. He's more undersized - not shorter - than you would like to see in a top NHL prospect.

I believe that's a fair description of both prospects.

I will guarantee, if we go back through the thread, we will see more mentions of Strome's skating than Marner's size. I will further guarantee that most mentions of Marner's size are made by people trying to defend a criticism that wasn't, at the time, being made about Marner's size.

My worry is that our experience with Tyler Biggs and Connor Brown is creating a lens that isn't accurate. It's causing us to say that a big player with a skating concern is a higher bust likelihood than an undersized player. That's simply not the case and is far too general an analysis.

Hence for every Tyler Biggs on the one side, you get a Jordan Schroeder on the other.

But Marner's 5'11. Perhaps size would be a bigger concern than skating if Marner was listed at 5'9" like Schroeder.

And I still see plenty of people with Strome ranked ahead of Marner. I'm not really seeing this anti-size thing you are.
 
Back
Top