• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

These picks never get traded anyway. Would you trade the Leafs pick under any realistic circumstances? It just doesn't make sense to move them.

Yup... most teams with a top 1-10 pick are usually rebuilding, for instance it doesn't make sense for Carolina to give up the 5th overall pick for a guy like Kessel who is 28. By the time Carolina is ready to compete he'd be pushing his mid 30's, same thing with a guy like Dion or even JVR! Think guys like Rielly or Nylander to get Carolina thinking, those are the types of players required to get a top 5 pick, players in their early 20's and with high upside.
 
Ya exactly. And I mean Rielly and Nylander are Rielly and Nylander...but the 5th overall pick...well that could be anybody! It could even be Rielly or Nylander... you know how much we've always wanted one of those!
 
So Craig Button has Hanifin in the 12th spot in his rankings! Is this Button being Button or are there real concerns with Hanifin?
 
Seems like he has really been dropping. Perhaps scouts are a bit gun shy on highly ranked NCAA dmen? There hasn't been a college dman ranked as high as Hanifin since the Johnson's. It took them ages to develop and they have never really reached the level most thought they would. Prior busts and lack of recent comparables might be scaring teams off.

Sounds like a bargain. If he falls we should work hard to pick up a 6-12 pick.
 
So Craig Button has Hanifin in the 12th spot in his rankings! Is this Button being Button or are there real concerns with Hanifin?
According to Bob McKenzie, none of the scouts he's talked to while compiling his rankings have had Hanifin rated lower than 4th overall.

So I'd say this is a case of Button being Button.
 
I'm so back and forth on Strome and Marner. On one hand i feel Marner will be better, on the other i feel as though Strome is more of the type of player i'd build a hockey team around. Not sure what makes me feel Marner will be better besides the "eye test".
 
It seems like everyone around here wants Strome or Marner, me included. But After watching Hedman with Tampa last night, man would it be amazing to pick up a big, smooth skating dman who can be dominant at both ends of the ice. They're just as tough to find as that big #1 center. Anybody think Hanifin is the guy?
 
I'm firmly in the as long as we take one of Marner, Strome or Hanifin it's been a good day camp. Plus the meltdown of some posters here if we did take Hanifin almost makes me want it more.
 
It seems like everyone around here wants Strome or Marner, me included. But After watching Hedman with Tampa last night, man would it be amazing to pick up a big, smooth skating dman who can be dominant at both ends of the ice. They're just as tough to find as that big #1 center. Anybody think Hanifin is the guy?

I think I'd be fine with Hanifin. Particularly when paired with Rielly. That's a Keith-Seabrook tyoe pairing that you can build a team around.
 
whoever we take has to be a foundational player though. this is an important pick for the franchise and even getting "only" a top 4 D or top 6 forward isn't really enough for the situation we're in right now.

...although I too wouldn't mind Hanifin just to see LoF lose his shit.
 
I think I want Marner but I'm pretty relaxed about the pick to be honest. Hunter knows Marner better than anyone, the team is almost all OHL guys so they know Strome quite well too... if they pick Hanifan, we'll all know how highly they must think of him. The only thing they could do that'd piss me off is to pass on everyone and take Crouse which I don't see happening.

I feel good about the draft.
 
It seems like everyone around here wants Strome or Marner, me included. But After watching Hedman with Tampa last night, man would it be amazing to pick up a big, smooth skating dman who can be dominant at both ends of the ice. They're just as tough to find as that big #1 center. Anybody think Hanifin is the guy?
I won't feel even a tiny bit of disappointment if we walk up to the podium and select Hanifin. As much as I desperately want a #1 center and am enticed by the two extremely talented hometown guys (Marner & Strome), having another young defenseman of Rielly's calibre in the system would be incredible too.

And this is why I was desperate to finish no lower than 4th from the bottom at the end of the season. We're guaranteed one of Marner, Strome or Hanifin, and it isn't really possible to make a rational argument that any of them would be a bad pick.
 
There is a smaller, but not insignificant portion of the scouting community that believes Provorov will be a better defenseman than Hanifin.
 
I think whenever in doubt, Leafs brass will go with a prospect they are familiar with, which means Marner or Strome. And I can't argue with that either.

Unless they firmly believe Hanifin is better than Marner and Strome, otherwise if they consider them all equal, they'll pick Marner / Strome cause they are (Hunter is) obviously more faimilar with them.

On the 'need' side we need a #1 D as much as we need a #1C / W ... and we should NEVER draft for need anyways. Just pick whoever they feel is the best player.
 
I have a ton of faith in Hunter's scouting ability, so I am not worried at all that he'll pass on two of Marner/Strome/Hanifin for anyone else.

There are some other good names available, but nothing comparable to those three.

If it did happen I would lose some of that faith. This one seems like a no brainer.
 
What happens on this board if the Leafs do something unexpected and take... say Provorov?
I wouldn't really get it if they go off the board at #4.

If they really want someone else outside the established top-5, it'd make more sense to trade down or try to acquire another pick.
 
Back
Top