Yeah, what the Stars would be choosing is a long term financial commitment to a core of Rantanen, Johnston, Hintz, Heiskanen, Harley and Otter. All of those except Harley are already locked in for term, and the choice is really Harley or Robertson. Granlund is just the kind of shorter term guy you have to plug in to get quality filler around that core. I'm sometimes critical of Jim Nill, but that's a pretty good and pretty large group to have locked in until 2029 or further. Robertson is the bridge too far, financially.
From Carolina's perspective Robertson would be the second best winger in the market after Marner and you guys all seem to hate Marner, so ... yeah. More of a scorer/shooter than a playmaker and a bit more streaky. The size for me is irrelevant. Robertson is big enough to not get pushed around even if he's not exactly tough. Put it this way. In Florida terms, he'd fill the Reinhart role with slightly less willingness to can opener a guy. But he's a real scorer and a dangerous shooter from anywhere inside the top of the circles and would be an absolute boon to Carolina's power play setup. He's going to end up making just about as much as Marner and Rantanen eventually, but not until next summer when he's an arbitration eligible RFA. Is he worth returning Dallas' draft capital? Absolutely he is. Do you also throw in a prospect to make it happen? Yup. All day and twice on Sunday.
PS ... if Dallas asks the same question and it's Otter instead of Robertson, the answer is exactly the same. Name the prospect and here's your picks back.