• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

GDT #33: 24/12/20 - The Poor Dumb Ednas

zeke said:
If all you care about when evaluating a player is their performance over the first 40% of this season only, then...

Marner 32gms, +6.7 (+17.2 pace)
Tavares 31gms, +6.2 (+16.0 pace)
Nylander 32gms, +4.5 (+11.5 pace)
Matthews 23gms, +3.6 (+12.8 pace)
Click to expand...

Tavares near the top? Take those numbers out of the trash. Those numbers are now a 10 with classic good looks and a masculine physique.
 
zeke said:
25 whole games as just a solid 1st liner this year don't completely change that he's proven he's super duper elite over an 8yr career now.
Click to expand...
I have no qualms about that. I keep thinking that rating is just for this season.

Frankly, it really should be. I don't care much about multi-year ratings in a game thread.
 
zeke said:
If all you care about when evaluating a player is their performance over the first 40% of this season only, then...

Marner 32gms, +6.7 (+17.2 pace)
Tavares 31gms, +6.2 (+16.0 pace)
Nylander 32gms, +4.5 (+11.5 pace)
Matthews 23gms, +3.6 (+12.8 pace)
Click to expand...
Nice.
 
LeafOfFaith said:
I have no qualms about that. I keep thinking that rating is just for this season.

Frankly, it really should be. I don't care much about multi-year ratings in a game thread.
Click to expand...

I mean i care more about how good a player is than how good his production has been over the last 30gms.
 
zeke said:
I mean i care more about how good a player is than how good his production has been over the last 30gms.
Click to expand...
Sure, but there's value in both obviously.

More than 30 games and you're looking at performance from 6+ months ago, which doesn't really have much bearing on the current game.
 
LeafOfFaith said:
Sure, but there's value in both obviously.

More than 30 games and you're looking at performance from 6+ months ago, which doesn't really have much bearing on the current game.
Click to expand...

I mean do you really think even 40 or 50 games of matthews being a ppg player means he's actually just a ppg player now?

Tavares had a whole season last year of being like a 60pt type payer and these net ratings still said he was probably better than that going into this season.
 
zeke said:
I mean do you really think even 40 or 50 games of matthews being a ppg player means he's actually just a ppg player now?

Tavares had a whole season last year of being like a 60pt type payer and these net ratings still said he was probably better than that going into this season.
Click to expand...
Of course I don't think that.

I'm just curious about this year's performance. And he's been worse than they other three guys this year, so that superman rating made no sense.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top