• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

one thing to note here. burke had the opportunity to overpay for mike richards, a number 1 in most eyes, during the summer. he chose not to despite his pining for a center. idoubt he changes philosophies this time around for nash, a winger
 
but of course it does.

if your argument is that better linemates = better production, and you isolate a particular player and say that his production benefited from the quality of his linemates, you cannot then turn around and ignore the fact that when he no longer had those quality linemates his numbers didn't only not fall appreciably, but in fact increased.

of course that casts doubt on your argument. that is undeniable.

My argument is that Nash's shit linemates have stunted his growth/production.....none of what you put forth, casts doubt on my belief in that.

If a guy flashes the ability to be a 40 goal scorer, or a PPG player, with the likes of Vyborny or Unberger centering him, then I feel confident that with superior linemates, he's capable of reaching those levels again (and more consistently) if not surpassing them.

well, i think you can certainly make a case for gaborik.

I don't......Gaborik played with the likes of Rolston (who was a ppg player in Gaborik's breakout season) PM Bouchard, Demitra, etc....



but the point was really to look at it from the opposite side of the ledger. the assumption is that better linemates = better production and yet the players i listed all saw an appreciable DROP in production when paired with superior players.

No, the point was to look at it from the perspective that Nash has had shittier linemates than anyone you mentioned......



the pa's concession imo will be to staunch the year cap increases in some way. i do not believe you will see a cap that will continue to appreciate as the nhl's has (going from $39mn to $64mn in 7 seasons) beyond this season.

sweet, a new point we can disagree on.......Fehr isn't going to give up increases in the cap/player salaries easily, if at all, and Bettman knows better than to allow another lockout to occur at this junction.


that aside.... the leafs are currently pressed right up against the cap. they do not have a starting goalie. they do not have a first line C. trading for nash will only give them lessr oom to maneuver under the cap, and fewer assets to peddle to get the pieces that they require more than another winger.

We're pressed because we have junk taking up important cap space, if adding a quality player forces Burke to address that, so be it.



i don't think that 'improved fiscal responsibility' is a reason to bring in a player,

No one claimed it's the reason to bring him in......it's simply a nice bonus.


Burke needs to smarten the f*ck up, and start using our cap space more wisely......one area he doesn't need to be so cautious, is for rare commodities like Nash.



At this point we're just going in circles though....you're stuck in on your position, I'm stuck in on mine. Everyone knows where we stand at this point.
 
Last edited:
one thing to note here. burke had the opportunity to overpay for mike richards, a number 1 in most eyes, during the summer. he chose not to despite his pining for a center. idoubt he changes philosophies this time around for nash, a winger

To my recollection, Burke never passed on the opportunity to overpay for Richards.......he was told what it would cost, and while he was mulling it over and going over it with his team, LA swooped in and offered a package that Philly accepted.
 
Rumor was that it was on the table for him, he went to consult with his management group, and Philly swooped in......a report later came out that TO would have done the deal, but Holmgren wanted more, and Philly offered it.

Haven't heard your version before though.
 
Has nash ever played centre??? I mean I know players have preferences, but Nash between Kessel and Lupul would be pretty damn huge.
 
My argument is that Nash's shit linemates have stunted his growth/production.....none of what you put forth, casts doubt on my belief in that.

a player deemed by many to be of a similar caliber to nash (though you did concede he's better), who produced the same numbers... regardless of linemates.. doesn't cast doubt on the belief that rick nash would necessarily score more points by playing with better linemates?

i mean, it couldn't do anything but put a hole in that assumption.

i really can't believe you're denying that.

I don't......Gaborik played with the likes of Rolston (who was a ppg player in Gaborik's breakout season) PM Bouchard, Demitra, etc....

rolston? seriously?

brian rolston was a 32 year old with a career high of 62 points when he joined minnesota. bouchard? a guy who has topped 60 points just once in his career? these are very comparable players to the sorts of players nash has been saddled with.

demitra is better but by the time he joined minnesota was he really much of an upgrade on huselius? not really.


No, the point was to look at it from the perspective that Nash has had shittier linemates than anyone you mentioned......

so now you're trying to tell me what the rationale is of my argument?

again, if your argument is that he'll score more by playing with better players then it's a very reasonable argument to point out players who haven't scored more despite getting to play with better players.

you're just totally ignoring the argument, and it's a perfectly reasonable one.



sweet, a new point we can disagree on.......Fehr isn't going to give up increases in the cap/player salaries easily, if at all, and Bettman knows better than to allow another lockout to occur at this junction.

the players are still going to have to make concessions.

fehr can't afford a lockout about as much as bettman can't. he has to prove that he can work with him and daly.
 
I almost hope Burke does NOT get Ben Bishop for like a second and a third draft pick. If he gets him, he will trade Gardiner PLUS to get Nash. A typical Burke SPLASH.
 
i doubt very much that burke would deal gardiner.

two reasons... first, the kid has been very good. he's having the best rookie season we've seen from a d-man in 14 years, and i admit... his season is starting to become even more impressive than kaberle's.

second... he is currently the only burke-drafted player on the roster. imo it is indisputable that burke has an affinity for him. a pet project of his, kind of like mike brown (who wasn't drafted by burke but was drafted by his scouts/nonis). burke will keep him around.
 
He's not going to trade assets for a goalie he's going to be forced to play or otherwise potentially losing him come free agency.
 
I wonder what is running through Burke's mind now. He has to be hating himself for buying into the Reimer hype. A guy who played magnificently last year with NO pressure.

I really think Kessel and others would resent Nash being brought in. Let Boston, Nashville or someone else who is a contender go for the guy.

I would love to see Boston grab the guy and trade Seguin, in the process, to weaken them over time.
 
i think you're selling reimer way short.

his problems seem to be mental more than physical.

people criticize him for being unathletic but that hasn't really been a problem at all. in fact, he's been pretty awesome post-to-post this year.

and while his (and gus's) numbers aren't starter good... they are still giving the leafs a better sv% than they got out of any other goalie combo they've had since the lockout. so the idea that it has been a total shit show is overstating things quite a bit. they're both above .900. too close to .900, but both above.

reimer has had some trouble this year with his five hole... he also keeps making himself small, not because he isn't challenging shooters, but because he keeps dropping his shoulders in the butterfly.

i don't know if it's because he's worried about pucks beating him under his arms, or on the sides, but he keeps making himself smaller than toskala when he's in teh butterfly, and it has led to a bunch of pucks beating him over teh shoulders which shouldn't happen to a 6'2 goaltender.

in any event, what i'm getting at is that his problems haven't been the fatal flaws that everybody seems to think he has.. the glove, the lack of athleticism, the concussion, etc.

these are more bad habits than anything, imo.
 
IMO getting a coach like Allaire is part of the plan to recruit young goaltenders - which to me means not going after proven vet goalies. Guys like Vokoun, etc can use a coach, but Allaire turns raw tenders into NHL ones.
 
i think you're selling reimer way short.

his problems seem to be mental more than physical.

people criticize him for being unathletic but that hasn't really been a problem at all. in fact, he's been pretty awesome post-to-post this year.

and while his (and gus's) numbers aren't starter good... they are still giving the leafs a better sv% than they got out of any other goalie combo they've had since the lockout. so the idea that it has been a total shit show is overstating things quite a bit. they're both above .900. too close to .900, but both above.

reimer has had some trouble this year with his five hole... he also keeps making himself small, not because he isn't challenging shooters, but because he keeps dropping his shoulders in the butterfly.

i don't know if it's because he's worried about pucks beating him under his arms, or on the sides, but he keeps making himself smaller than toskala when he's in teh butterfly, and it has led to a bunch of pucks beating him over teh shoulders which shouldn't happen to a 6'2 goaltender.

in any event, what i'm getting at is that his problems haven't been the fatal flaws that everybody seems to think he has.. the glove, the lack of athleticism, the concussion, etc.

these are more bad habits than anything, imo.

Agree with pretty much everything.
 
Back
Top