but of course it does.
if your argument is that better linemates = better production, and you isolate a particular player and say that his production benefited from the quality of his linemates, you cannot then turn around and ignore the fact that when he no longer had those quality linemates his numbers didn't only not fall appreciably, but in fact increased.
of course that casts doubt on your argument. that is undeniable.
My argument is that Nash's shit linemates have stunted his growth/production.....none of what you put forth, casts doubt on my belief in that.
If a guy flashes the ability to be a 40 goal scorer, or a PPG player, with the likes of Vyborny or Unberger centering him, then I feel confident that with superior linemates, he's capable of reaching those levels again (and more consistently) if not surpassing them.
well, i think you can certainly make a case for gaborik.
I don't......Gaborik played with the likes of Rolston (who was a ppg player in Gaborik's breakout season) PM Bouchard, Demitra, etc....
but the point was really to look at it from the opposite side of the ledger. the assumption is that better linemates = better production and yet the players i listed all saw an appreciable DROP in production when paired with superior players.
No, the point was to look at it from the perspective that Nash has had shittier linemates than anyone you mentioned......
the pa's concession imo will be to staunch the year cap increases in some way. i do not believe you will see a cap that will continue to appreciate as the nhl's has (going from $39mn to $64mn in 7 seasons) beyond this season.
sweet, a new point we can disagree on.......Fehr isn't going to give up increases in the cap/player salaries easily, if at all, and Bettman knows better than to allow another lockout to occur at this junction.
that aside.... the leafs are currently pressed right up against the cap. they do not have a starting goalie. they do not have a first line C. trading for nash will only give them lessr oom to maneuver under the cap, and fewer assets to peddle to get the pieces that they require more than another winger.
We're pressed because we have junk taking up important cap space, if adding a quality player forces Burke to address that, so be it.
i don't think that 'improved fiscal responsibility' is a reason to bring in a player,
No one claimed it's the reason to bring him in......it's simply a nice bonus.
Burke needs to smarten the f*ck up, and start using our cap space more wisely......one area he doesn't need to be so cautious, is for rare commodities like Nash.
At this point we're just going in circles though....you're stuck in on your position, I'm stuck in on mine. Everyone knows where we stand at this point.