• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Life is a liquid, dynamic, cycle of ups, downs, life and death. Lupul is having a career season. Career, and a lot of that is due to playing with Kessel who has learned how to pass as well as anyone I have ever seen in a Leaf uniform.


Does anyone remember KULEMIN and GRABVOSKI of 2010/2011????????

Most NHL players have one great season, some good ones and a lot of ones that are standard for them. The time to have traded Grabovski was LAST YEAR.

The time to have traded Kulemin was LAST YEAR.

The time to trade MacArthur was LAST YEAR.

The time to trade Gunnarson, Phaneuf, Kessel and Lupul is THIS YEAR.

The NHL, LIKE pro tennis these days, eats men alive. Lupul, by the time we get that number one center and goaltender in the top six in the NHL SP, will be roasted and DONE.


JUST AS it was GREAT to buy GLDN at .02-.035, and SELL IT at .088 That was GREAT.

Buy LOW(Gardiner and Lupul for Beauchemin last year) SELL HIGH. SELL PHANEUF. SELL GUNNARSON, SELL KESSEL, SELL LUPUL.

Good god guys, we play a merciless schedule where grown men are grinded down into dust in a few years. Do NOT get overly homerish. Don't buy many jerseys. Always trade guys having career seasons. For ultimate GAINS and to save paying their lazy, fat arses(Kulemin) after they get rich.

Love your team, but do NOT be a FAN. Its beneath this forum.
 
Ehhh.... Thornton's already 33, by the time were truly ready to contend he'll be at least 35/36, I'm not sure I'd want to build around that. But yea if Thornton was younger I'd be all over it, his vision is simply uncanny.
Maybe if he was, I dunno, 28 you'd be for it though?
 
Build around Colborne and a slew of first round draft picks. And get rid of the guys having career years. Sign free agents, rinse, repeat. Build a new Detroit Red Wing organization.
 
Life is a liquid, dynamic, cycle of ups, downs, life and death. Lupul is having a cahttp://www.forumice.com/newreply.php?do=newreply&p=1715199reer season. Career, and a lot of that is due to playing with Kessel who has learned how to pass as well as anyone I have ever seen in a Leaf uniform.


Does anyone remember KULEMIN and GRABVOSKI of 2010/2011????????

Most NHL players have one great season, some good ones and a lot of ones that are standard for them. The time to have traded Grabovski was LAST YEAR.

The time to have traded Kulemin was LAST YEAR.

The time to trade MacArthur was LAST YEAR.

The time to trade Gunnarson, Phaneuf, Kessel and Lupul is THIS YEAR.

The NHL, LIKE pro tennis these days, eats men alive. Lupul, by the time we get that number one center and goaltender in the top six in the NHL SP, will be roasted and DONE.


Errr...if you keep trading players after they have good years, what in the sweet **** do you plan building a team with? I mean...does that mean if Jake Gardiner scored 50 points next season, we trade him while is value is high?

I agree in general that you obviously try to trade replaceable assets when they're at their highest value. If anyone cares to remember, I was entirely onside with trading Grabovski last summer for that very reason, MacArthur as well as long as the return was right.

But Kessel is 24 and elite....Lupul has been elite this season, you simply don't trade players who show elite level of ability unless you're getting another elite player back. Phaneuf has been a bit up and down at times, but has been overall good enough to be considered a top 10 defender (though his most recent work has taken him out of any Norris consideration he may have received based on his first half work).

You don't trade players like that, because the moment the ink on the fax dries, you start looking for replacements for the guy you just traded. Perpetual rebuild is for suckers Teeds, give your head a shake. Always acquire elite talent, don't trade it away for anything other than elite talent.
 
Build around Colborne and a slew of first round draft picks. And get rid of the guys having career years. Sign free agents, rinse, repeat. Build a new Detroit Red Wing organization.

This doesn't make any sense though.

Detroit has had probably fewer roster and personnel turnover than any organization in professional sports. The same contributors and coaches at all levels of the system are there EVERY. SINGLE. YEAR.
 
Build around Colborne and a slew of first round draft picks. And get rid of the guys having career years. Sign free agents, rinse, repeat. Build a new Detroit Red Wing organization.

Detroit didn't do anything of the sor that you're suggesting. In fact, they did the opposite. They are incredibly patient and foster long term relationships with players that they feel fit into their program.

and they never, ever trade away elite talent. They always ACQUIRE.
 
and for the record...Kulemin was and is in dynamite shape. Losing a few dozen friends in the biggest tragedy hockey has ever seen has ****ed his head up. Kulemin shows just how important mental preparedness is in the world of elite sports. Dude's head simply isn't even on this continent right now.
 
and for the record...Kulemin was and is in dynamite shape. Losing a few dozen friends in the biggest tragedy hockey has ever seen has ****ed his head up. Kulemin shows just how important mental preparedness is in the world of elite sports. Dude's head simply isn't even on this continent right now.

Yes, he lost a lot of close friends due to a horrific plane crash and yes he should be grieving. However, this is overtaking his life and is becoming an obsession with him, it's clear he needs therapy to get his own life back on track. If an employee in any other job failed to preform his job (like Kulemin is), then he'd be fired in a nano second. Kulemin needs to get his life together, because this obsession he has isn't healthy. Grief is one thing, obsession is a whole different animal.
 
I dunno if Kulemin OR Grabovski were in elite shape to start this season. Their training the previous year, featured on youtube was fairly impressive. But Russian guys get out of shape faster than any other nationality in the NHL. Burke GENERALLY doesnt like them.

I can live with keeping Kessel and Lupul, but if someone blew me away with a trade for Lupul I would do it in a heartbeat. He will be figured out next year and snuffed down to 60 points. In fact, Vancouver exposed Lupul for what he is, a decent powerforward/sniper, who is having a career move and is relying on two strong moves. Over and Over again.
 
I'm with Teeds on this one- Lupul is a good player masked as an elite one this year. I think him getting top line minutes AND playing with Kessel is helping boost his numbers a fair bit. I'm not knocking Lupul, the guys a good player who has a nose for the net and an above average shot, but I just don't see him as this elite player like he is this year, I for one won't be shocked if his numbers drop off a bit next season.

IMO Lupul is a 30/30 guy, nothing more nothing less. If the right trade offer comes along for a real elite player then he should go, if not I have no problems with him staying here either.
 
Yes, he lost a lot of close friends due to a horrific plane crash and yes he should be grieving. However, this is overtaking his life and is becoming an obsession with him, it's clear he needs therapy to get his own life back on track. If an employee in any other job failed to preform his job (like Kulemin is), then he'd be fired in a nano second. Kulemin needs to get his life together, because this obsession he has isn't healthy. Grief is one thing, obsession is a whole different animal.

You assume that he's not in therapy...and frankly I'm not sure why you would. Grief councilling probably would have been insisted, and provided by the organization. There's a lot more to recovery than simply going to therapy though. Your statement is as silly as telling someone with clinical depression to 'get over it and move on with your life'

As for the statement about an under performing worker being fired....obviously you've never worked in a company with a functioning HR department. I've never seen anyone fired due to mental illness at a real job. From a shitty call centre? Sure, but from a professional position with any sort of reasonable company? Nah, stress leave is a common occurance in most corporations. In my capacity with the company I work for, I've referred numerous employees to our program for assisting workers with emotional/psychological disorders.
 
Life is a liquid, dynamic, cycle of ups, downs, life and death. Lupul is having a career season. Career, and a lot of that is due to playing with Kessel who has learned how to pass as well as anyone I have ever seen in a Leaf uniform.


Does anyone remember KULEMIN and GRABVOSKI of 2010/2011????????

Most NHL players have one great season, some good ones and a lot of ones that are standard for them. The time to have traded Grabovski was LAST YEAR.

The time to have traded Kulemin was LAST YEAR.

The time to trade MacArthur was LAST YEAR.

The time to trade Gunnarson, Phaneuf, Kessel and Lupul is THIS YEAR.

The NHL, LIKE pro tennis these days, eats men alive. Lupul, by the time we get that number one center and goaltender in the top six in the NHL SP, will be roasted and DONE.


JUST AS it was GREAT to buy GLDN at .02-.035, and SELL IT at .088 That was GREAT.

Buy LOW(Gardiner and Lupul for Beauchemin last year) SELL HIGH. SELL PHANEUF. SELL GUNNARSON, SELL KESSEL, SELL LUPUL.

Good god guys, we play a merciless schedule where grown men are grinded down into dust in a few years. Do NOT get overly homerish. Don't buy many jerseys. Always trade guys having career seasons. For ultimate GAINS and to save paying their lazy, fat arses(Kulemin) after they get rich.

Love your team, but do NOT be a FAN. Its beneath this forum.
Teeds, buddy, you really need to get past this ridiculous idea that you handle NHL players the same way you handle penny stocks. A team that's constantly trading its best performers is a team that will constantly be going nowhere in the standings. Some element of "buy low, sell high" is needed to be sure, but you also have to identify certain players that you think are building blocks and can consistently perform well for you, and HOLD on to them.

As for Lupul, if he "regresses" to 60 points next year, I don't really see what the problem would be. A 60-point winger is a pretty great thing to have (and when Lupul was acquired, we certainly would have been thrilled if we were told he'd hit 60 points for us). It's also extremely unlikely that you're going to find some team that firmly believes Lupul is going to be a PPG+ player for the rest of his career and will overpay for him in a trade accordingly.
 
Last edited:
I dunno if Kulemin OR Grabovski were in elite shape to start this season. Their training the previous year, featured on youtube was fairly impressive. But Russian guys get out of shape faster than any other nationality in the NHL. Burke GENERALLY doesnt like them.

Kulemin looks ripped in every picture I've ever seen of him, but nothing would surprise me with the summer he's had. The thing with his play though, is that he's never looked slow, or weak...just stupid, just vacant, like he's not thinking.

The long and the short of it though, with a player of his profile at the end of last season (220 pounds, strong on the boards and in front of the net, 24 year old 30 goal scorer) you don't trade that away for short of much better player replacing him....and at this point, trading him would be pointless because his value is a fraction of what it should be. Right now you bump him down the lineup so his lack of production isn't killing the team (he's still never been poor defensively) and wait for his form to return. Will he ever pop 30 again? Don't know...Is he definitely much better than he's been? Absolutely. He's a 20-25 goal power winger at worst, something we desparately need in our top 9.

I can live with keeping Kessel and Lupul, but if someone blew me away with a trade for Lupul I would do it in a heartbeat. He will be figured out next year and snuffed down to 60 points. In fact, Vancouver exposed Lupul for what he is, a decent powerforward/sniper, who is having a career move and is relying on two strong moves. Over and Over again.

Lupul has some holes in his game defensively, but offensively he does so much good work all over the offensive zone that I'm not sure he's worth complaining about. There's pretty legitimate reasons on both sides of the Lupul argument for why he can be expected to regress, or continue to with this type of form. Sure, if someone blows you away with an offer...great, but nobody will unless he proves he's legit...and if he proves he's legit, why trade him? Surprises like Lupul are the things that happen to teams who win championships. Funny, off the wall stuff like 2 Euro late round picks turning into superstars, things like your checking line centres HOF brother wanting to come play with him and only him, likes a 36 yr old goalie who spent most of his career in Finland and the AHL turning in the greatest goaltending performance in NHL history...

You know, the type of luck that we as a franchise have seen none of is decades. Let's not look a gift horse in the mouth.
 
People (and by people I mean Teeds and Pronger) need to let go of the idea that someone is going to blow their brains out in an unsolicited trade offer for Lupul. It's not going to happen unless he proves that A) He can stay healthy over the course of a few seasons, and B) That he really has broken out due to being healthy like he actively claims to be the reason for his break out.

He and Kessel (who is our franchise player at the moment, and living up to the title for the most part) have awesome chemistry (after we spent the better part of 3 seasons trying to find someone to play with Phil). Let's stop talking about subtracting from the small core of guys we have who are performing at an elite level, let's worry about adding to it. You acquire players who perform in their roles at an elite level by whatever means you can, and jettison players who don't.

Acquire talent. Lupul has shown that there is elite talent in there, now it's simply a matter of putting him in a situation where that talent can be maximized for the longest possible time period. You do that by putting more quality around him. Namely, a centre not named Tyler Bozak.
 
lupul is 1 year removed from being a salary dump in the gardiner deal. its worked out famously for the leafs, but no one is putting forth a mega offer until this is a proven trend
 
If anyone gives a **** about my gut feeling...that's exactly who our #1 centre will be next season. San Jose has 1st or 2nd round exit written all over them imo and will look at making a significant change, moving at least Thornton, maybe Marleau or Boyle on top of that in an attempt to get younger and build around Pavelski, Couture, Burns + whatever they get back + whatever the spend the extra cap space on.
I wouldn't pencil him into the Leafs lineup, but I agree Thornton's a prime candidate to get moved in the summer. There's no much reason for a team that has Joe Pavelski, Patrick Marleau and Logan Couture all capable of playing center to hang on to a $7M Joe Thornton, especially if they flame out again in the playoffs this year as they almost certainly will. The only wrinkle is that Thornton has a full NMC, so if he doesn't feel like leaving San Jose after living there for the past seven years, then he won't.
 
Back
Top