• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

One thing you have to remember is that Stastny is a phenomenal defensive player.

I would definitely like to see him on this team.
 
Trade the best defensive prospect the Leafs have developed in fifteen years for the Canucks twenty six year-old back-up? Good grief, no.
 
so...

concerns salary considerations = meaningless statement (1 million difference, no big deal)

concerns over assets needed to acquire players = meaningless statement (Nash is better and rarer a talent IMO, so yeah)

fact that stastny and nash have produced comparably over their careers = meaningless statement (yep, stats are not the reason I want Nash as stated)

fact that first line winger should not be a priority right now = meaningless statement (top line talent with size is a major need)

fact that stastny addresses a need = meaningless statement (so does Nash, so yeah)

fact that stastny might allow the leafs to unload salary = meaningless statement this is just conjecture on your part

you're a great debater. your statements are meaningless as usual

meaningless..
 
if true, this is stupid.

this team isn't a rick nash away from being a bonafide playoff team... don't even get me started on contender.

bring in nash and they will still need some size -- and talent -- on the third line, they will still need a #1 centre, and they will still have a huge hole in net.

and if you go ahead and ship out schenn, and kadri and a first to bring in nash you just lose pieces that could either plug holes, or be used in trades to plug those holes.

this would be about as stupid a pickup as you burke could make.


We need size with talent on our 2nd/3rd lines we both agree on that. Neither our center position (currently) nor our scoring (we're top 10) are the problem so i couldn't care less about a center right now. Goaltending and at least 2 players that can play on the boards is all we need. How much easier would the games be if we didn't have to start off being down 2-0 in so many games? We played well after the first 5-10 minutes.(again i partially blame the ceremonies)

As for Nash, you and I can both agree that on that 1st line only Lupul can manage the puck on the boards very well. Imagine if we had Nash on the other wing, it'd be pretty tough to get the puck from them(kinda like Sundin did it for us). That way even if you have to play Phil on a line with speed and skill only, it's ok because during different parts of the game that will help us too.
 
I'd probably trade Schenn for Schneider though.

Schneider has a terrific pedigree. He's been elite at all levels -- NCAA, AHL, NHL.

Would have to be Schenn + Macarther or something like that.

I like Schenn and I think it's just inexperience that is causing all of his mental lapses lately, but he has what it takes to be a solid shut down D man.
 
i don't think it's so hilarious. schneider looks like he might be as good of a goaltender as gardiner might of a defenseman.

given how unpredictable goalies are, though... i wouldn't make it.

but compared to other offers we've heard.. that's very reasonable. potential #1 defenseman for potential top notch starting goalie... seems like a fair swap.
Well, that's the thing. He's a good prospect, and he's put up some terrific numbers as a backup. But until he's been a starting goalie in the NHL and proven himself, you really have no idea what you're getting. The ranks of unemployed ex-NHLers, the minor leagues and Europe are littered with goalies who've excelled as a backup but then have flopped when they've had the starting job thrust on them. Now, if a team offered up a legitimate, proven #1 goalie and wanted Gardiner in return...I'd have to think harder about it. But dealing the best defensive prospect we've had in years (and a guy that's probably consistently been our best defenseman through this disaster of a month) for a maybe in goal...I reiterate my HELL NO.
 
Oh come on, LeafGM. Leafs need a #1 goalie. Schneider is the real deal.

Also, I've seen far worse proposals on this site for Antropov alone.
I guess I missed the part where a guy with a career high of 25 games is a #1 goalie and has proven he's "the real deal".

You're definitely going to be disappointed when the Canucks eventually do deal Schneider. The price of young goalies who haven't proven themselves as #1 goalies is never particularly high in the trade market...even one who's been billed as the second coming of Christ by Vancouverites for the past few years.
 
Well, that's the thing. He's a good prospect, and he's put up some terrific numbers as a backup. But until he's been a starting goalie in the NHL and proven himself, you really have no idea what you're getting. The ranks of unemployed ex-NHLers, the minor leagues and Europe are littered with goalies who've excelled as a backup but then have flopped when they've had the starting job thrust on them. Now, if a team offered up a legitimate, proven #1 goalie and wanted Gardiner in return...I'd have to think harder about it. But dealing the best defensive prospect we've had in years (and a guy that's probably consistently been our best defenseman through this disaster of a month) for a maybe in goal...I reiterate my HELL NO.

No problem, you can have Luongo for Gardiner. Solved. We'll keep Schneider.
 
I guess I missed the part where a guy with a career high of 25 games is a #1 goalie and has proven he's "the real deal".

You're definitely going to be disappointed when the Canucks eventually do deal Schneider. The price of young goalies who haven't proven themselves as #1 goalies is never particularly high in the trade market...even one who's been billed as the second coming of Christ by Vancouverites for the past few years.

Unless your name is Varlamov.

Believe me, I'd rather deal Luongo and keep Schneider. Cheaper, younger, and better imo. But if you read some of what most Vancouver fans think Gillis should get for Schneider compared to me, suddenly Gardiner isn't as laughable.
 
Unless your name is Varlamov.

Believe me, I'd rather deal Luongo and keep Schneider. Cheaper, younger, and better imo. But if you read some of what most Vancouver fans think Gillis should get for Schneider compared to me, suddenly Gardiner isn't as laughable.
Well, if you compare any outlandish trade rumour to what "most Vancouver fans think" (or you could substitute "what most Toronto fans think", just so it's clear I'm not picking on Canuck fans), it's going to look somewhat sane by comparison. Not the best way to operate though, if you want accuracy.
 
That has to be one of the most hilarious trade offers ever posted on this site.

Hell no.

Pretty fair offer IMO. Ridiculing it because of how much you overrate Gardiner is hilarious though. Two seasons ago I could have easily replaced Gardiners name with Schenn and you'd have had the same answer... take off the homer glasses.
 
Schneider would be a solid pick up. Not sure how much i would risk in trying to acquire him.

Gunnarson + MacArthur + 3rd for Schneider?
 
Back
Top