• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Man blueman you do realize that your opinion does not take the place of logic, fact, and statistics in an argument?

If you want to ignore important and real considerations because you have a huge man-crush on Rick Nash, that's fine, but you shouldn't get upset at others for calling you out on it.

Nash may be one of the most overrated players by the mediots since the lockout. He has not come close to producing at a rate that justifies his salary, meaning even if you get the 'good' Nash he is likely overpaid. He's a lazy floater, and has not made those around him significantly better, which is what you expect your star players to do.

Schenn, Frattin, and a 1st I'm fine with. Hell even if you throw Kuly in there I might be okay with it. But not Naz as well. Burkie does that it's a good sign he's panicking.

As mbow (correctly) points out... we've spent three years restocking the shelves and building a young core of talent; let's not throw that away for an albatross contract for an unproven forward who may not even crack our first line (and sorry, for as much talent as Nash may have, cracking 70 pts once in his career means he very much has not proven himself to be a top-10 player in the league, which is what he's paid like and in a cap world that matters... a lot.
 
Pretty fair offer IMO. Ridiculing it because of how much you overrate Gardiner is hilarious though. Two seasons ago I could have easily replaced Gardiners name with Schenn and you'd have had the same answer... take off the homer glasses.

I am in agreement with you in regards to the overrating of Jake Gardiner. Over the last month or so, it has really taken on a life of its own. Not trying to downplay his potential(he has looked fantastic) but when i keep reading about him being a deal breaker to a potential trade that would bring in an elite talent makes me shudder.

You have to give to get.
 
Well, if you compare any outlandish trade rumour to what "most Vancouver fans think" (or you could substitute "what most Toronto fans think", just so it's clear I'm not picking on Canuck fans), it's going to look somewhat sane by comparison. Not the best way to operate though, if you want accuracy.

Difference being I don't believe what I proposed to be all that outlandish. I do agree with you that Vancouver fans should prepare to be disappointed the day Schneider is actually dealt. I know for fact that some fans would lead the pitch-fork mob if Gillis landed a Jake Gardiner for Schneider.
 
You think Sens fans would learn about goalies but they haven't apparently.

You'd think Leaf fans would learn about overrating their young Dmen when they look good over a short period, but apparently they haven't.

Posters here act like Gardiner is a superstar. It's hilarious.
 
Nah he's still using the same passive aggressive tactics where he pretends to talk about the hockey discussion with thinly veiled barbs that he did a decade ago.
 
You'd think Leaf fans would learn about overrating their young Dmen when they look good over a short period, but apparently they haven't.

Posters here act like Gardiner is a superstar. It's hilarious.

Says the man from the fanbase who have annointed Karlsson as the next Bobby Orr.
 
You'd think Leaf fans would learn about overrating their young Dmen when they look good over a short period, but apparently they haven't.

Posters here act like Gardiner is a superstar. It's hilarious.


He's easily the best young d-man I've seen break into the league on the Leafs.

Just like we laughed at Johnny for calling Hot Karl a future PPG player, feel free to laugh at us for how highly we regard Gardiner, but I don't think we're really overrating his potential that much.

If he keeps improving and developing and turns into what many here think is possible... well there are maybe 10 of those guys in the league at any given time.
 
The thing about Gardiner is that I'd be perfectly happy to trade him for the right player. Being unwilling to trade him for Rick Nash or Cory Schneider doesn't mean I think Gardiner's going to be a "superstar". I just don't particularly like Nash (the player and especially the contract) and in the case of Schneider, I'm not interested in the Leafs once again massively overpaying for an unproven goalie in the hopes that he blossoms into a great #1 goalie and solves our problems in net. We've all seen that story before and it doesn't end well.
 
The thing about Gardiner is that I'd be perfectly happy to trade him for the right player. Being unwilling to trade him for Rick Nash or Cory Schneider doesn't mean I think Gardiner's going to be a "superstar". I just don't particularly like Nash (the player and especially the contract) and in the case of Schneider, I'm not interested in the Leafs once again massively overpaying for an unproven goalie in the hopes that he blossoms into a great #1 goalie and solves our problems in net. We've all seen that story before and it doesn't end well.

Don't get me wrong because I like Burke... after all he was the architect of more than half the current Canucks team, but he also was the architect behind our goalie graveyard throughout the 90's and 00's. And you're right, as we've seen that story before and it doesn't end well. Especially for a guy who claims to build teams from the "net out".
 
I think in terms of a quick goaltending help we really have to pin our chances on Nabokov... not really much else out there that's remotely proven.
 
Don't get me wrong because I like Burke... after all he was the architect of more than half the current Canucks team, but he also was the architect behind our goalie graveyard throughout the 90's and 00's. And you're right, as we've seen that story before and it doesn't end well. Especially for a guy who claims to build teams from the "net out".
Hey, you won't see me defend Burke's record on goaltending. Unfortunately, the only good goalie he's ever had (Giguere) he inherited, though I guess he also hit a home-run by signing Hiller (and has been trying to duplicate that feat in Toronto by signing every college and international goalie UFA he can get his hands on, with mixed results at best so far). I don't really see how that relates to this discussion though. Whether you like it or not, Cory Schneider is not a proven star #1 goalie, and the return you get in his eventual trade will reflect that.
 
Back
Top