• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Been told our offer is Schenn, Kulemin, Frattin, 1st for Nash; will see tmr
Will do that in a heartbeat.

If we can land Nash without giving up 1 of Gardiner, Kadri and Colborne, you gotta do it.

Frattin is nothing.

Kuleim's had a terrible season, after a good 2nd half last year. His trade value isn't high at the moment.

Schenn + 1st is the very least you'd have to give up for a franchise player. Gotta do this, but I don't think this is the best offer CBJ gets.
 
and it's cool that you're so sure, but there's absolutely no reason to pay the price to find out when it's not necessary. Acquiring quality goaltending is much, much easier than we've made it look the last 7 years.


Quality goaltending is what we'd get from Schneider (imo) if he didn't live up to my expectations......and even then, I'd gladly trade away Schenn for him.



Schenn is easily replaceable, goaltenders with the potential upside Schneider brings aren't......and as we've seen time and time again, they're game changers. I'll happily part with Schenn for a chance at that, even if the downside is us having a starting goalie demonstrably better than anything we've had in years.

Having said all that, I don't think Gillis would even have the balls to ask Burke for that much.......hence why he's #1 on my list of targets.
 
Schenn + 1st is the very least you'd have to give up for a franchise player. Gotta do this, but I don't think this is the best offer CBJ gets.

I'd be shocked if it wasn't based on everything that has come out of Philly & NYR about their pursuit of Nash. NYR is entirely unwilling to offer up a roster defender, Kreider, or JT Miller if reports are to be believed. So we're looking at some sort of Dubinsky + 1st + spare parts offer. Philly was apparently unwilling to offer up Schenn, Couturier, or JVR. They would have other parts of value like Voracek or Simmonds to base a package around...but nothing that you would go 1 for 1 with Schenn for.

Schenn sounds like the best single asset that any of the involved teams have been willing to offer up. Kulemin would be an intriguing as hell get for them as well, with his age and a 30 goal season already under his belt.

NYR would have to be adding a name like Del Zotto to put them over the top, Philly would have to part with names they've already pulled out of the discussion. If that's a concrete offer from us, it's basically on Howson on whether or not he feels willing to end this bullshit or whether he'd like for it to turn into a proper job ending circus that runs into the summer and ends with his replacement trading Nash.
 
Goalies are game-changers, but unproven goalies are unproven goalies. Schneider may pan out, but he may not. His numbers DO look pretty good but keep in mind 1. he's never had over 25 games in any season 2. he's 26 3. he's played for one of the best NHL teams behind one of the better goaltenders in the league. The games that he gets are easy games, and he always plays with a lead. There's no guarantee he'll come close to his .920-930 numbers when he is the #1 goalie on a very young team that is still developing.

And by saying "even if he doesn't pan out you'll trade Schenn in a sec" you are selling Schenn short.

I am not a big fan of Schenn neither, but understand a 22 year old defenseman who was 5th overall pick just 4 years ago and is still learning his game at the NHL has high trade value. You may not think Schenn will ever fulfill his expectation at 5th overall, and you may not think this team needs Schenn. You are not alone, but that doesn't change the fact Schenn has good trade value at the moment, and it wouldn't be wise to trade Schenn for Schnieder straight up.

VAN would make that trade in a second.
 
I'd be shocked if it wasn't based on everything that has come out of Philly & NYR about their pursuit of Nash. NYR is entirely unwilling to offer up a roster defender, Kreider, or JT Miller if reports are to be believed. So we're looking at some sort of Dubinsky + 1st + spare parts offer. Philly was apparently unwilling to offer up Schenn, Couturier, or JVR. They would have other parts of value like Voracek or Simmonds to base a package around...but nothing that you would go 1 for 1 with Schenn for.

Schenn sounds like the best single asset that any of the involved teams have been willing to offer up. Kulemin would be an intriguing as hell get for them as well, with his age and a 30 goal season already under his belt.

NYR would have to be adding a name like Del Zotto to put them over the top, Philly would have to part with names they've already pulled out of the discussion. If that's a concrete offer from us, it's basically on Howson on whether or not he feels willing to end this bullshit or whether he'd like for it to turn into a proper job ending circus that runs into the summer and ends with his replacement trading Nash.
That's quite an accurate assessment of the situation.

I guess we'll see what happens. Now even if THIS is the best offer for Howsen though, he still might not make it.

First Howsen might not understand deals won't get better in the summer, especially if he's looking for prospects and players, not picks.

Second of all, even if Howsen understands that, as a GM of a small market team, he has to give something to the fans to cheer about. Schenn is the biggest name going back, and that might not be flashy and sexy enough for Howsen to pull the trigger.

Though he might also figure he's gotta rebuild the team from the backend out, and Schenn + Jackson may turn out to be a great pairing too.
 
Quality goaltending is what we'd get from Schneider (imo) if he didn't live up to my expectations......and even then, I'd gladly trade away Schenn for him.

quality goaltending is relatively easy to get as long as you know where to look, and it doesn't usually require a 22 year old former top 5 pick with a boatload of elite shut down potential to get it. We could get quality goaltending out of Nabokov. We could have gotten quality goaltending out of Vokoun or Theodore last summer for cash.



Schenn is easily replaceable,

Which is why NHL GM's continually spend a shit ton of money on defenders of Schenn's profile who weren't near as good as Schenn is right now at 22, right?

goaltenders with the potential upside Schneider brings aren't

Again, I think you're entirely over rating his potential. He's played a starters work load once in his professional career, and saw a significantly drop in performance while doing so. I expect similar when he finally gets a starters work load in the NHL.

......and as we've seen time and time again, they're game changers. I'll happily part with Schenn for a chance at that, even if the downside is us having a starting goalie demonstrably better than anything we've had in years.

That's my point though, there's no reason, and almost never a reason to part with a prime asset like Schenn for that. You can quite easily get your hands on goaltending of that calibre every summer.

Having said all that, I don't think Gillis would even have the balls to ask Burke for that much.......hence why he's #1 on my list of targets.

Gillis has no reason to not ask for the moon right now. Schneider is Luongo insurance for Gillis right now, and still under the teams control for the immediate future.
 
That's quite an accurate assessment of the situation.

I guess we'll see what happens. Now even if THIS is the best offer for Howsen though, he still might not make it.

First Howsen might not understand deals won't get better in the summer, especially if he's looking for prospects and players, not picks.

Second of all, even if Howsen understands that, as a GM of a small market team, he has to give something to the fans to cheer about. Schenn is the biggest name going back, and that might not be flashy and sexy enough for Howsen to pull the trigger.

Though he might also figure he's gotta rebuild the team from the backend out, and Schenn + Jackson may turn out to be a great pairing too.


This situation had a chance of getting better in the summer for Howson, until Nash's agent came out today and said that the list of teams Nash will waive his NTC to go to will not change under any circumstances.

He may have been hoping that some time and convincing could help him get Schenn to accept additional suitors, but with that possibility apparently dead, he's basically stuck with Nash's 5 clubs, 1 of which just traded for Jeff Carter and is capped out, with the other 3 either out of the discussions or unwilling to offer up any sort of premium asset in return for Nash according to reports. Toronto appears to be the only team willing to offer a package that should be able to get the deal done.
 
Dream trade deadline for Burkie tomorrow...

- First, teams that are looking for veteran savvy are willing to take Armstrong's contract ... Armstrong is gone for a 3rd rounder.

- Then Snow and Nabokov's contract extension breaksdown. NYI trades Nabby to Toronto for a 2nd rounder. (Nabby is strictly a rental)

- Around 2pm Burkie makes a surprise move and trades Grabovski for a late 1st

- Seconds after the Grabs trade hits the news, Darren Dreger breaks the big news Nash is a Leaf. Howsen's given up on waiting and taken the best offer on the table from Toronto - Schen + 1st + Frattin + Kulemin, plus a conditional late pick if Toronto makes the playoff

- Toronto calls up Kadri and Colborne for the Tue game ...
 
Goalies are game-changers, but unproven goalies are unproven goalies. Schneider may pan out, but he may not. His numbers DO look pretty good but keep in mind 1. he's never had over 25 games in any season 2. he's 26 3. he's played for one of the best NHL teams behind one of the better goaltenders in the league. The games that he gets are easy games, and he always plays with a lead. There's no guarantee he'll come close to his .920-930 numbers when he is the #1 goalie on a very young team that is still developing.

And by saying "even if he doesn't pan out you'll trade Schenn in a sec" you are selling Schenn short.

I am not a big fan of Schenn neither, but understand a 22 year old defenseman who was 5th overall pick just 4 years ago and is still learning his game at the NHL has high trade value. You may not think Schenn will ever fulfill his expectation at 5th overall, and you may not think this team needs Schenn. You are not alone, but that doesn't change the fact Schenn has good trade value at the moment, and it wouldn't be wise to trade Schenn for Schnieder straight up.

VAN would make that trade in a second.

I'd go as far as saying that there's very little chance that Schneiders SV% would remain above .920 in Toronto, playing 60+ games.

I'm with Montana though, that if the price on Schneider was reasonable, I'm in. But Schenn is not a reasonable price for a goalie who turns 26 in 3 weeks, who has played more than 50 games in a season once in his life.
 
Dream trade deadline for Burkie tomorrow...

- First, teams that are looking for veteran savvy are willing to take Armstrong's contract ... Armstrong is gone for a 3rd rounder.

- Then Snow and Nabokov's contract extension breaksdown. NYI trades Nabby to Toronto for a 2nd rounder. (Nabby is strictly a rental)

- Around 2pm Burkie makes a surprise move and trades Grabovski for a late 1st

- Seconds after the Grabs trade hits the news, Darren Dreger breaks the big news Nash is a Leaf. Howsen's given up on waiting and taken the best offer on the table from Toronto - Schen + 1st + Frattin + Kulemin, plus a conditional late pick if Toronto makes the playoff

- Toronto calls up Kadri and Colborne for the Tue game ...

Yes please.
 
quality goaltending is relatively easy to get as long as you know where to look, and it doesn't usually require a 22 year old former top 5 pick with a boatload of elite shut down potential to get it. We could get quality goaltending out of Nabokov. We could have gotten quality goaltending out of Vokoun or Theodore last summer for cash.

Quality goaltending is Schneider's downside.......and as "easy" as that is to acquire, we sure as f*ck haven't over the last half a decade. I also want more than simply "quality".....I want someone with the potential to be elite, which I feel Scheneider has.



Which is why NHL GM's continually spend a shit ton of money on defenders of Schenn's profile who weren't near as good as Schenn is right now at 22, right?

I don't believe NHL GM's continually spend a shit ton of money on defenders like Schenn......I also think if they do, it's a grave mistake, and one I'd love to avoid by dealing him while we can.


Again, I think you're entirely over rating his potential. He's played a starters work load once in his professional career, and saw a significantly drop in performance while doing so. I expect similar when he finally gets a starters work load in the NHL.

Again, I think you're entirely under rating his potential (while over rating Schenn's).....based on an incredibly small sample size.



That's my point though, there's no reason, and almost never a reason to part with a prime asset like Schenn for that. You can quite easily get your hands on goaltending of that calibre every summer.

The chance to get a quality goalie, with legitimate tools to be elite, is absolutely a reason to part with a guy that hasn't been much better than our 5th/6th defenseman this year......and no, you can't "easily" get your hands on goaltenders with Schneiders potential, every summer.



Gillis has no reason to not ask for the moon right now. Schneider is Luongo insurance for Gillis right now, and still under the teams control for the immediate future.

Given that you guys think he'd jump at the chance to land Schenn for Schneider, I'd gladly moon him by making that swap......I suspect he could be had for cheaper though.
 
Mike Ulmer
My final #Leafstrade predict: grabo, Schenn second for Bernier, Brown. Gunner Mac, col borne Kadri and 1st for Nash.

Um what?
 
Mike Ulmer
My final #Leafstrade predict: grabo, Schenn second for Bernier, Brown. Gunner Mac, col borne Kadri and 1st for Nash.

Um what?

Um how about no? I want Brown, but Bernier is not the answer in net that we are looking for..... also I do not want to empty the cupboards for Nash alone. I might be able to live with Mac, Gunner, and one of Kadri/Colborne but not both. Only way I would include the first is if we do trade Grabo for the rumoured 1st.
 
Back
Top