• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Gotta side with Mindz on Schneider. Yes I'm interested, but the price has to be reasonable. I have said I'm on-board moving Schenn in a Nash deal repeatedly, but that isn't a slight on him. I just really want to get Nash and keep Gardiner. Not shopping Schenn to the highest bidder.

As for Nash, all 3 teams will likely sweeten their offers, and I worry about all the assets the Flyers can dangle.

I predict, Nash will be moved to somebody on monday, and I guarantee burkie brings in a goalie.
 
I'd be stunned if anyone didn't agree with Mindz on this one.....keeping Schenn (someone the majority of the board thinks much higher of than I do) is the safer/easier choice to make, where as Schneider (someone I suspect few have watched a fraction as much as I've been forced to) would represent a much greater risk.

I'll always learn towards the riskier choice, when the upside is elite......which is why I'd have taken Filatov over Schenn in the first place, and been wrong.


Mind you Schenn/Schneider is a sidetrack from the actual discussion, which was how we would prioritize the three goalies........the fact I'd be willing to go as high as offering Schenn, was simply an example of why I don't believe price would be a stumbling block for me.
 
Been told our offer is Schenn, Kulemin, Frattin, 1st for Nash; will see tmr

That would be one of the worst trades in Leaf history, and would set up Columbus for a real nice start on their rebuild.

Kulemin cannot be part of any deal. He'd be going at a massive discount. If he had 22 goals right now, like he probably did last year around this time, would his name even be mentioned in the same sentence as a trade offer for Nash? They better remember this is a fluke, otherwise we'll have given them another Nash, but added on Schenn and a 1st, and Frattin who could be a real player.

Worst proposal ever, and **** that to hell.
 
I'd be stunned if anyone didn't agree with Mindz on this one.....keeping Schenn (someone the majority of the board thinks much higher of than I do) is the safer/easier choice to make, where as Schneider (someone I suspect few have watched a fraction as much as I've been forced to) would represent a much greater risk.

I'll always learn towards the riskier choice, when the upside is elite......which is why I'd have taken Filatov over Schenn in the first place, and been wrong.


Mind you Schenn/Schneider is a sidetrack from the actual discussion, which was how we would prioritize the three goalies........the fact I'd be willing to go as high as offering Schenn, was simply an example of why I don't believe price would be a stumbling block for me.

How many times have we played this game before, of gambling on an unproven starter by paying through the nose? Do we need to do it again?

If we'd just stuck with Rask, we'd have made the playoffs every year since the Raycroft trade. Maybe if we stick with Reimer, the same thing will happen? He's certainly shown he has the ability, just not the consistency, which is not unusual for a guy without a full season's games under his belt thus far.

I am not down for getting Schneider, not because he wouldn't be a good gamble on a pickup, but because we've been burned too many times on unproven goalies. We would be MUCH better served trading scraps for a proven and performing Nabokov and then using the Schenn+ package on Nash or someone similar rather than Schneider. At least Nabokov is a proven commodity.
 
It's not a career comparison. It's a theory proven over and over again that we've learned the hard way.

It rarely makes sense to trade significant assets for a goaltender with limited experience or little to no track record as a full time starter.

Is Schneider going to be SO much better than Nabokov that we should pay Schenn+ to get him? Or does it make more sense to give up a measly draft pick and get Nabby and his very good starter stats, and save the other assets for trades to fill other glaring holes?

The answer is pretty obvious, imo.
 
imo people are starting to underrate schenn quite a bit.

still, if the canucks offered up schneider for schenn... damn, i think you have to think about it.

you're rolling the dice if you're the leafs -- there's no question about that.

but schneider has been damn impressive and is at the age where goalies really start to get it. more importantly he has never looked bad.

as much as we want to compare him to raycroft and toskala, those guys were one year/no year wonders.

schneider has pretty much always been good in the nhl. and this isn't like a guy like craig anderson, who looked good in limited action but was never seen as an ace prospect. schneider has been under the glare of expectations since he was a first round pick and has not disappointed.

if you can get harding or somebody else on the cheap then imo it's ok to take the risk.

but if they're all going to cost something substantial, schneider is a guy i'd roll th edice on so long as the cost doesn't get too crazy.
 
IMHO the Leafs would be stupid to turn down Schneider for Schenn. The Leafs are far more adept at acquiring or developing defense than goalies. Goaltending is just not a Toronto development strong-suit. Schneider is the real deal.
 
It rarely makes sense to trade significant assets for a goaltender with limited experience or little to no track record as a full time starter.

Boston made a mistake trading for Rask....Florida made a mistake trading for Luongo....Calgary made a mistake trading for Kipper...Anaheim made a mistake trading for Giguere....

[/s]

Is Schneider going to be SO much better than Nabokov


yes, and for significantly longer.


that we should pay Schenn+ to get him?


Where's Schenn+ coming from?......everyone seems in agreement, that my extreme example of Schenn for Schneider, would be an example of us "overpaying" for him. Gillis would jump at a Schenn for Schneider 1 for 1 deal.


Or does it make more sense to give up a measly draft pick and get Nabby and his very good starter stats, and save the other assets for trades to fill other glaring holes?


Makes the most sense to acquire the 26 year old with elite upside, over the 36 year old who can fall off the map at any moment.


The answer is pretty obvious, imo.


agreed.
 
Last edited:
well it isn't even that.


we don't even know if they can acquire nabokov. we also don't know if he would have any interest in re-signing with the team if they did acquire him.

trading for schneider would at least bring some certainty that they actually can acquire somebody.
 
well, imo you would be foolish to ignore the risk that schneider brings. raycroft and toskala are but two examples of guys who were good in limited action but struggled once the league became familiar with them and they had to handle a full starter's load.

there is always that risk.

schneider is as good a bet as any to succeed, though.
 
well, imo you would be foolish to ignore the risk that schneider brings. raycroft and toskala are but two examples of guys who were good in limited action but struggled once the league became familiar with them and they had to handle a full starter's load.


The thing I keep coming back to with Schneider, is that examples like Raycroft and Toskala, etc who flashed solid numbers in the NHL but then got figured out, were all relatively average/small sized tenders.

I can't think of many goaltenders who are Schneiders size, that came into the league and produced at the level he has......then got figured out, and ended up being a bum. (maybe there's a ton, and I'm just not thinking of them, but none really come to mind in recent memory)


I'll be stunned if Schneider ends up anywhere and is anything less than a .915 goalie as a starter.

[video=youtube;1GAVUUCfq4U]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GAVUUCfq4U[/video]


Just like any highlight video of Gus, he's bound to look good in this, but if you watch the confidence he exudes, the way he challengers shooters, the angles he takes, how economical he is with his movements, and the athletic ability he flashes etc.....it'll give those of you that haven't seen Schneider much, a taste of what he brings to the ice.
 
Last edited:
I can't think of many goaltenders who are Schneiders size, that came into the league and produced at the level he has......then got figured out, and ended up being a bum. (maybe there's a ton, and I'm just not thinking of them, but none really come to mind in recent memory)

How about James Reimer? Remember him? He's currently on that path unless things turn around.

You're also neglecting to factor in that Schneider plays for a team that lost the Cup in Game 7 last year and is tearing up the league this year. Would his stats be that great on a team that wasn't nearly as good?

If you think it isn't a huge risk to give up a prime asset for Schneider, you're nuts. And if you think we're in a position to take yet another risk like this while we have no center and need upgrades in more than a few spots, you're not taking everything into account.
 
i agree with montana and will take it a step further. with vancouver looking at ott, maybe they dig armstrong too. imo schenn,army,and a pick for schnieder and raymond makes sense
 
By the way, Luongo's stats over the last two seasons are eerily similar to Schneider's.

Mere coincidence?

And what do we think of Luongo?
 
eerily similar?

that's a bad thing?

you're crazy.

'oh, the leafs shoudln't get him, he has just produced comparably to one of the best goalies in the league.'
 
Back
Top