• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

He's elite. He has a career .919 save%. Only 3 goalies are better than that.

IMO the most important part of the equation isn't any single year. Its a guy who is consistently among the best. Year in and year out. Thats what Luongo is that very few others are. Same goes for Thomas, Lundqvist, Rinne, and I would have included Vokoun in that list too but he may have taken a step back this year. They aren't top 3 every year. But they are near the top of the list every year. And that makes them top 3-5 overall.
 
Last 3 years:
1. Thomas - .926
2. Lundqvist - .924
3. Rinne/Vokoun - .922
5. Miller - .921
6. Luongo/Halak - .920
8. Nabokov - .919
9. Bryz/Price/Quick/Ward - .918
 
Its those same names at the top of the list no matter what set of years you look at. Thomas, Lundqvist, Rinne, Vokoun, Luongo. Thats why they are the best.
 
Like I said, I won't be upset with Luongo, but it's so damn frustrating that it seems that everyone can develop or trade for a decent goalie but us. We overpay for one and still **** it up.
 
2006-07 to 2008-09:
1. Backstrom - .923
2. Vokoun - .921
3. Brodeur - .920
4. Luongo/Thomas - .919
** Rinne - .918 (* only 50 GP)
5. Huet - .916
6. Lundqvist .915

Same 5 guys.
 
Thomas took a big step back this season and he's getting into ancient territory. I'd much rather go with someone who is five and a half years younger and is in much better physical condition to be honest.
 
Last 2 years
1. Thomas - .930
2. Lundqvist - .926
3. Rinne - .926
4. Luongo/Quick/Smith - .924
7. Price/Vokoun - .920
 
Last edited:
Even if Luongo is a step behind of Thomas/Lundqvist/Rinne, he's the next guy in line, and is consistently right there. You can't pass up an opportunity to get a guy who is one of the top 5 goalies in the league if you have that opportunity.

Solidifying your goaltending is one thing. But getting one of the top starters in the game completely transforms your team. You have a chance to compete every year.
 
Last 2 years
1. Thomas - .930
2. Lundqvist - .926
3. Rinne - .926
4. Luongo/Quick - .924
6. Smith - .924
7. Price/Vokoun - .920

People forget: Luongo was coming off of the second-best season of his career save percentage-wise last season (with his .928 mark in 2011 bested only by his .931 performance in 2004) and probably his third best season overall (being 2004 and 2007). He fell back to his career averages this season but was still an elite to borderline elite goalie regardless of the drop. That sort of guaranteed top five quality is insanely valuable.
 
Why not. If anything its better to give it to a goalie than a position player. The elite goalies all last until their late 30's, sometimes early 40s. Most position players don't.
 
Why not. If anything its better to give it to a goalie than a position player. The elite goalies all last until their late 30's, sometimes early 40s. Most position players don't.

This x100.

An elite goaltender with a track record of workhorse levels of performance is far more likely to maintain that performance into their twilight years than a big forward or undersized defender (amongst other groups). Why not go with a long-term investment?

The problem is investing in shitty, injury-prone crap like Rick DiPietro. Luongo is elite and doesn't have nagging injury issues. He always plays between 60 and 75 games every year.
 
Roy, Belfour, Brodeur, Hasek, Thomas. They were all good into their late 30s.

Guys like Lidstrom and Selanne on the other hand are exceptions to the rule.
 
We're talking about another decade.

And if he gets some nagging injury, loses his confidence, or whatever else that could come up, you're dead in the water cap-wise.

5 years, ok. 7 years, maybe. 12 years?
 
Its not ideal, sure. But personally, I'm not passing on a legit top 5 goalie because something bad may or may not happen in the future, and I might have to bury the contract in the minors. I'm grabbing the goalie and giving myself a legit window to compete for a cup.
 
There are some loop holes to get out of this for both sides if it doesn't work out as well.

KNOWN CLAUSES (note: if player has been traded, clauses may no longer apply): NTC (player can supply five-team trade list following final game of 2013-14, valid through July 15, 2014; if player does not submit trade list at that time, team can request a five-team trade list following final game of 2017-18 season, valid through Sept. 1, 2018). If player submitted a trade list in 2014 and was not moved, team loses right to request trade list in 2018.

Regardless though, and its been stated many times before, when goaltending is one of your biggest holes you have to fill and there is a chance to grab one of the top goalies in the game, you have to make a play. You wouldn't be doing your job as a GM otherwise
 
Luongo's deal is a 6 year deal with the potential of being 7 (if he's willing to play for just a $3.8 pay check)....he's not playing the last three years where he makes 1.6, 1, and 1 million...

$5.33 million cap hit per for 6 to 7 years of Luongo?......sign me the f*ck up.
 
Yeah, I heard its only a cap hit of 5.33. I think we have to go with it. All the way.
 
Back
Top