• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Is he Italian or Portuguese? If he was Italian, MLSE would probably make 5.3 million dollars a year in Luongo items.
 
Ok my take on Luongo is this ...

- We need a veteran goalie. At the very least, a veteran goalie who will provide stability in net for 2-3 years, who can be a 1B to Reimer. And a star goalie who can be an indisputable #1 is even better obviously.

- That said, that goalie doesn't HAVE TO be Luongo. Burke & Co. should explore other options out there - Thomas, Vokoun are 2 names that come to mind immediately.

- We have to realize this will be the last stop for Bobby Lou. With his contract, if there's any reason we need to move him, good luck.

- We also have to keep in mind Bobby Lou, despite being a top goalie in the league, also has his flaws - his slow start in Oct and Nov, and his questionable playoff performance. I said questionable because afterall, he did make it to Game 7 of the SC Finals last year, but then don't forget there's the whole "Thomas didn't pump my tire!" story to go along with it ...

- And that's the other thing. Luongo will never run out of stories for the media and that could be distracting to him and the rest of the team.

So as much as I think the Leafs need stability in goal, I am not sure Luongo is the answer here. And we'd better not be paying an arm and a leg to get him ... VAN shouldn't get anything substantial in return because of his contract.
 
Ok my take on Luongo is this ...

- We need a veteran goalie. At the very least, a veteran goalie who will provide stability in net for 2-3 years, who can be a 1B to Reimer. And a star goalie who can be an indisputable #1 is even better obviously.

- That said, that goalie doesn't HAVE TO be Luongo. Burke & Co. should explore other options out there - Thomas, Vokoun are 2 names that come to mind immediately.

- We have to realize this will be the last stop for Bobby Lou. With his contract, if there's any reason we need to move him, good luck.

- We also have to keep in mind Bobby Lou, despite being a top goalie in the league, also has his flaws - his slow start in Oct and Nov, and his questionable playoff performance. I said questionable because afterall, he did make it to Game 7 of the SC Finals last year, but then don't forget there's the whole "Thomas didn't pump my tire!" story to go along with it ...

- And that's the other thing. Luongo will never run out of stories for the media and that could be distracting to him and the rest of the team.

So as much as I think the Leafs need stability in goal, I am not sure Luongo is the answer here. And we'd better not be paying an arm and a leg to get him ... VAN shouldn't get anything substantial in return because of his contract.

This
 
Yep. Too many people buying the sports media created narratives.

It's the job of those muppets to create stories to sell where there isn't one. The long and the short of it is, Luongo played well, very well in front of a team that can't score goals in the clutch to saves it's ****ing soul (as they proved again, this season)...the same way that he has played well his entire career. He's without argument, a top 5 goalie in this league...better than anything we have in house has the potential of being, and he'll likely remain that way for 5+ seasons minimum.

Better yet, he's in the process of being run out of town in Vancouver as the scapegoat to their numerous problems. He's going to come for pennies on the dollar.

I'm not against either Thomas or Vokoun, but you get 2-3 years out of either, tops. Why not just bring in Luongo and consider our goaltending fixed for the next 5-7 years?
 
I just don't understand the argument that the contract is bad. Why don't you want to give out bad contracts to players? Because you want cap flexibility right? But why? For me it is so you can afford to add guys like Roberto Luongo.

Do I want to give Mike Richards or Jeff Carter 10 year deals? No. Its not prudent to pay non star players as if they were stars. But why wouldn't you want to pay stars as if they were stars?

We're talking about a future Hall of famer here, who is still young enough for a goalie to have a significant career left. But you don't want him because his contract is too long? We will have one of the best goalies in the league for too long?

If there is any type of player that you can afford to give a "bad" contract too its one of the best players in the league. If you are talking about the elite players, I can't say I have any problem with whatever you pay them. Is Kovalchuk signed forever, sure? But would I still take him with that contract? Of course. Its not like we are talking about a Dipietro, or Carter here.

IMO you give the Luongo's and Crosby's and Lundqvists and Kovalchucks whatever they want. Those are the types of players that you can actually build a team around. The fact that Luongo has a relatively cheap cap hit because he is signed for longer is a plus.
 
Last edited:
Is Luongo *really* up there with Crosby and Lundqvist?? Like, REALLY??

There are players you'd just give them a blank check and let them write whatever $$ and terms. I am not 100% sure Luongo is quite up there.

Regardless, I am not saying no to Bobby here. He might as well be the best available goalie in the market this summer, and after SO MANY YEARS Burke should stop gambling with the masked man. Let's finally have some stability in goal.

It STILL doesn't mean it has to be Luongo.

IF, for example, Boston is trading Thomas (I don't buy into the media story where BOS is gonna trade him ... I mean, look at it - with their season on the line, in game 6, and in game 7 there's not even a dispute on who starts for BOS) then Thomas at $5Mx1 yr is more intriguing to me than Luongo with his contract.

Or, if Vokoun somehow is willing to sign with the Leafs.

Or, if another top goalie is suddenly available via trade.

All I'm saying is, Luongo, to me, doesn't quite fall under the category of "If you can get this guy, give up anything to get him" category. I'd consider it, but it comes down to what other options are available and what VAN wants in return.
 
Yeah. If you can get a better goalie than Luongo for cheaper than that is better. The problem is you can count the number of better goalies than Luongo in the NHL on one hand, and the odds of any of them being available to the Leafs aren't particularly good.

And yes. Luongo is that good. List all the other goalies with a career .919 save %, and 30+ playoff wins. Hint: there aren't any other ones currently playing.
 
Last edited:
Is Luongo *really* up there with Crosby and Lundqvist?? Like, REALLY??

There is an absolute negligible difference between Luongo & Lundqvist, however you slice the numbers or career accolades.

There are players you'd just give them a blank check and let them write whatever $$ and terms. I am not 100% sure Luongo is quite up there.

Then Lundqvist shouldn't be either.

Regardless, I am not saying no to Bobby here. He might as well be the best available goalie in the market this summer, and after SO MANY YEARS Burke should stop gambling with the masked man. Let's finally have some stability in goal.

It STILL doesn't mean it has to be Luongo.

availability + longevity

IF, for example, Boston is trading Thomas (I don't buy into the media story where BOS is gonna trade him ... I mean, look at it - with their season on the line, in game 6, and in game 7 there's not even a dispute on who starts for BOS) then Thomas at $5Mx1 yr is more intriguing to me than Luongo with his contract.

Tim Thomas was pedestrian in the 2nd half of the season. .909% after the all star break. At his age, that's an important split. Not to mention the fact that other teams would definitely be in on Thomas due to the contract length, teams that Boston would likely rather deal with instead of moving him in Division to face him a pile of times over the next few years. We would probably have to give up more for Thomas maybe solidifying our goaltending for 2-3 years tops, than we would have to for Luongo doing the same for 5-7 years.

Or, if Vokoun somehow is willing to sign with the Leafs.

again, big if because there will simply be more suitors involved...also, same issue we'd have with Thomas...so we solidify our goaltending for 2-3 years...what do we do in 2-3 years?

Or, if another top goalie is suddenly available via trade.

Like who exactly? Who is trading Lundqvist, Rinne, etc? Goalies that good don't become available often...

All I'm saying is, Luongo, to me, doesn't quite fall under the category of "If you can get this guy, give up anything to get him" category. I'd consider it, but it comes down to what other options are available and what VAN wants in return.

Vancouver is ****ed, in that they're trading the contract and the situation as much as they're trading the goalie. There simply aren't many teams willing and able to absorb that contract. Less still that Luongo would likely waive his NTC to go to. It's more or less the ultimate buyers market.
 
What ME and leafman said...

Any time you have a chance at acquiring top talent at a given position, it's worth pursuing. Especially when that top talent is signed at a reasonable cap hit relative to their expected production (some could even argue Lou's a steal at $5.3 mill), and especially when they can be expected to produce at a similar level (i.e. top of the league) for another 5 years.

For all our bitching and griping about goaltending the last 7 years (and there has been a TON), it's kinda tough to say, 'no, we don't want to acquire one of the top-10 (at very worst) goalies in the league for cheap because he's being run out of town by idiotic fans and media'. Is there any other avenue we could pursue that would have as high a likelihood of shoring up our goaltending situation for not just the immediate future but years down the road?
 
Is Luongo *really* up there with Crosby and Lundqvist?? Like, REALLY??

i don't think anybody other than malkin is 'up there' with crosby, you're just taking leafman's point out of context.

but lundqvist?

uhm, yah.

what the **** has lundqvist accomplished in his career that luongo hasn't?

nyr might get bumped by ottawa in round one but nobody is shouting for biron to start, or laying the rangers problems at lundqvist's feet.

people really have to stop buying into the stupid media hype machine.
 
I like Lundqvist but he's a regular season King who has done nothing in the playoffs(Luongo has accomplished more).

Toronto is a goalie city, Luongo will have a godlike following like Eddie and Cujo did.
 
Yeah. If you can get a better goalie than Luongo for cheaper than that is better. The problem is you can count the number of better goalies than Luongo in the NHL on one hand, and the odds of any of them being available to the Leafs aren't particularly good.

And yes. Luongo is that good. List all the other goalies with a career .919 save %, and 30+ playoff wins. Hint: there aren't any other ones currently playing.

Well that's the thing: unless the Leafs are somehow going to acquire Cory Schneider, Carey Price, or Pekka Rinne they simply have no cheaper options that provide a comparable level of performance, and none of those three names are realistic as far as giving up assets is concerned. Luongo's prohibitive contract and the current status of Schneider as one of the best goaltenders in the game, and cheap, makes him extremely attractive as a realistic option asset-wise that the Leafs could get for pennies on the dollar. We just cannot afford to pass that up with the status of our goaltending since 2006.
 
People said this about Ed Belfour.

They certainly did. And Steady Eddie was coming off of a significantly worse season than Luongo's still borderline elite numbers for Vancouver. He posted a sub-.900 save percentage in the midst of the Dead Puck Era and was coming off of a season in which his personal escapades became more bizarre than ever off-ice. Then he promptly came to the Leafs and compiled two Vezina quality seasons between the pipes for the team.

Track record and previous consistency/ability to be a workhorse trumps all in situations like this.
 
Ok my take on Luongo is this ...

- We need a veteran goalie. At the very least, a veteran goalie who will provide stability in net for 2-3 years, who can be a 1B to Reimer. And a star goalie who can be an indisputable #1 is even better obviously.

No argument there. Quite frankly, it's not really a surprise that Reimer looked significantly better with a quality veteran like Giguere on the bench to mentor him and spot him for stretches than he did with the enigmatic, jittery, and inexperienced Gustavsson. When the inconsistent periods came there was no grace period, no veteran goaltender to take him aside and calm his nerves.

- That said, that goalie doesn't HAVE TO be Luongo. Burke & Co. should explore other options out there - Thomas, Vokoun are 2 names that come to mind immediately.

Luongo is a medium to long-term insurance policy. Vokoun is rapidly getting older and starting to develop the type of nagging groin injuries that have dogged Giguere in his twilight years (and removed much of his previous effectively) as well as many other aging starters, while Thomas is 39 years old and, as previously stated, probably doesn't have much preference for being put into a less than ideal situation on a re-tooling/re-building squad that does not have legitimate championship aspirations. I don't see how either of those two players makes more sense than Luongo.

- We have to realize this will be the last stop for Bobby Lou. With his contract, if there's any reason we need to move him, good luck.

Worry about that if the situation arises. The Leafs cannot afford at this time to continually keep running out the same sieves and hope that the goaltending situation sorts itself out properly. Go big or go home. At least if the experiment (and I hardly think Luongo constitutes an experiment) fails you went down trying to hit a proverbial home run out of the park. The Leafs need that type of impact goaltender.

- We also have to keep in mind Bobby Lou, despite being a top goalie in the league, also has his flaws - his slow start in Oct and Nov, and his questionable playoff performance. I said questionable because afterall, he did make it to Game 7 of the SC Finals last year, but then don't forget there's the whole "Thomas didn't pump my tire!" story to go along with it ...

And yet he's been at minimum the fourth best goaltender in hockey over the last two seasons with a combined save percentage (.924) that no Leafs goaltender has touched since Belfour's .922 mark in 2003 and Jacques Plante's disputed .941 mark in 1971. There's no question that you're going to receive an elite or borderline elite performance from him, with a low range in .915 territory and a high range bordering .930 or so. Are you seriously telling me that you would turn down that prospect if you were Brian Burke, particularly when said goaltender also averages in the neighbourhood of 65-70 games per season without another budding elite starter-in-waiting to take away starts from him?

- And that's the other thing. Luongo will never run out of stories for the media and that could be distracting to him and the rest of the team.

Vancouver has a significant media presence and he seemed to fare just fine there. Why would Toronto be any different? Especially in a city that is well-known for venerating goaltenders and taking forever to turn on them?

So as much as I think the Leafs need stability in goal, I am not sure Luongo is the answer here. And we'd better not be paying an arm and a leg to get him ... VAN shouldn't get anything substantial in return because of his contract.

Who is the answer then? That wouldn't require paying a king's ransom in assets to acquire? Luongo meets the requirements for a goaltender that is (1.) proven (2.) healthy (3.) fairly young still (4.) affordable in terms of both cap-hit and assets necessary to acquire him. There isn't a better option out there that meets those four criteria from my standpoint. Do you know of another goaltender who exceeds Luongo in that respect?
 
I am not too sure about that... I think Luongo would be a huge target if he came here. The media's love affair with the leafs here has really turned, and the people seem to be buying into it just the same. If Luongo has a bad game or let's in a softy, the people and the media would be SOOOO quick to jump on his play against Boston and being ousted by Schneider.

Look at how hard it is to talk about looking at things statistically here on a board that understands that. The general public... not so much.
 
Who is the answer then? That wouldn't require paying a king's ransom in assets to acquire? Luongo meets the requirements for a goaltender that is (1.) proven (2.) healthy (3.) fairly young still (4.) affordable in terms of both cap-hit and assets necessary to acquire him. There isn't a better option out there that meets those four criteria from my standpoint. Do you know of another goaltender who exceeds Luongo in that respect?
The only one I think is better is Schneider - depending on what the asset differential it would take compared to Luongo.
 
Back
Top