• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

That's like saying that maybe Edmonton thought Hall wasn't a franchise player two years ago and that they would have preferred Schenn+Gudbranson over him. I mean, it's possible that they're really dumb, but my point is that it's highly unlikely. The #1 pick is rarely traded for a reason.. especially when there's a clear #1 like there is this year.

Maybe you guys just think more highly of Schenn than I do. Stay at home d really don't hold much trade value. They are typically worth more to their team than they are to others and often get overrated by their own fans. In Schenns case, he's a stay at home d with no real skills at the moment. He hasn't proven anything yet, and his upside is a #4. If Edmonton trades the #1, maybe they won't get a lot, but they can do much better than Schenn.

Well, I have a hard time accepting that his upside is that of a #4, when we've seen him play for extended stretches at that level in the past already.

as for stay at homes not having much value? Doesn't this argument get blown out of the water every free agent period? GM's consistently pay through the nose for Komisarek's, Volchenkov's, Michalek's....very good GM's pay every summer for stay at home defenders.

and sure...#1 picks don't get traded often, but you also don't often see a team collect so many of them in a short time period, where the best player available was always a forward. Don't get me wrong, I would just take Yak if I was Edmonton and call it a day....but it's not outlandish at all that they would see a recent #5 pick who has established himself as an NHL defender while developing in a pressure cooker, and the #5 pick in this year's draft....where Murray, a guy their GM is so high on that he brought him over to the WC just to get an extended look, is probably available, as a viable option.
 
where Murray, a guy their GM is so high on that he brought him over to the WC just to get an extended look, is probably available, as a viable option.



Now that is something to I would derive from something occuring like that. But I would be taken to task for it. Still, I have to say, well done. Even though, at times, M.E. you might be one of those taking me to the shed for it.

But yes, I thought that was very curious Murray being taken over to the W. C's.
 
where Murray, a guy their GM is so high on that he brought him over to the WC just to get an extended look, is probably available, as a viable option.



Now that is something to I would derive from something occuring like that. But I would be taken to task for it. Still, I have to say, well done. Even though, at times, M.E. you might be one of those taking me to the shed for it.

But yes, I thought that was very curious Murray being taken over to the W. C's.

Teeds, if you simply made inferences, like I did there...I'd never take a run at you. There's nothing wrong with putting 2 & 2 together and then running with it. I just could seriously do without everything being attributed to secret MLSE sources....

As for Murray to the WC....he was good, but not great as an 18 year old in the WHL, and was the first junior to be taken to the WC in a number of years. Lowe just happens to be an Edmonton exec who is also involved in team Canada....and it was Lowe's call to bring him over. It doesn't take a 33rd degree mason to see the apex of that particular pyramid.
 
Yeah, I like a good punch to the face as well as anyone. Even if its thrown my way.
 
That's like saying that maybe Edmonton thought Hall wasn't a franchise player two years ago and that they would have preferred Schenn+Gudbranson over him. I mean, it's possible that they're really dumb, but my point is that it's highly unlikely. The #1 pick is rarely traded for a reason.. especially when there's a clear #1 like there is this year.

Maybe you guys just think more highly of Schenn than I do. Stay at home d really don't hold much trade value. They are typically worth more to their team than they are to others and often get overrated by their own fans. In Schenns case, he's a stay at home d with no real skills at the moment. He hasn't proven anything yet, and his upside is a #4. If Edmonton trades the #1, maybe they won't get a lot, but they can do much better than Schenn.

Its not like teams never do stupid things. Given the rumours that Edmonton is high on Murray, and their obvious lack of a need for another forward, this might just be a prime opportunity to pounce on that you can't just write off. If Edmonton trades the #1 pick it won't be for some huge return, it'll be to move down a couple spots in the draft so they can still get the guy they want and pick up something one top of it. Those types of deals are the kinds of deals that #1 picks are typically traded in.

Then again they might just take Yakupov.
 
I think they assess the situation with their chances of signing Schultz and make a decision from there. There is no indication he will sign there but it's been mentioned a few times its a possibility.

If they like their chances of signing him I think they just go with taking Yakupov. If not, they trade down and take Murray and gain another asset in the process.
 
ESPN:

Jordan Staal's name just continues to come up in possible trade speculation. On first glance, any deal involving the skilled two-way center leaving Pittsburgh seems almost insane. But, with his contract set to expire at the end of the 2012-13 campaign and the Penguins facing salary cap concerns, it might not be quite as ridiculous as it appears on the surface. Even if they don't want to shop him, the last thing they want to do is just lose him next year for nothing.

With that in mind, who would be the top contenders if Pittsburgh did feel they had to make a move here? Josh Yohe of the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review suggests four potential trade partners: the Toronto Maple Leafs, Carolina Hurricanes, Minnesota Wild and Edmonton Oilers.

A swap with Minnesota might start with someone like Cal Clutterbuck and the No. 7 pick this June. Meanwhile, Toronto has a potential shutdown defender like Luke Schenn to put on the table. Carolina boasts an impressive crop of prospects right now, so a strong up-and-coming player could be available alongside someone like Brandon Sutter. And -- maybe still the most intriguing scenario -- Edmonton has the No. 1 overall pick in next month's draft and are one of the few teams that doesn't "need" Nail Yakupov. They could use someone like Staal though. And adding Yakupov to Pittsburgh's already potent lineup could be explosive.

Of course, none of this means the Penguins are even willing to part with Staal. But, if they absolutely have to, these are some of their top options at the moment.
 
I wonder if Clarke MacArthur and Luke Schenn could get it done

No, what it would get is the Pittsburgh GM laughing and then hanging up the phone on Burke. Mac is a mere 3rd liner, they would be trading Staal and basically downgrading their offense. Schenn is a good piece that would intrigue them, but you'd have to throw in more then that to get them to bite but the problem with that is the pens would be looking to she shed salary and not add more on. Staal has a cap hit of $4.5M next season before becoming a UFA on July 1st 2013, Schenn is making $3.5 for the next three seasons, they would be shedding $1M but if they take on Mac he would cost between 2-3M/year, so really they would be adding 1-2M in additonal cap hit.

A realistic trade would be something like this- Kulemin, Kadri and a 2nd rounder for Staal. It would be a fair deal for both sides, they get Kulemin (who played with Malkin several years ago) and can provide a solid 2 way game, they also get Kadri who has a cheap cap hit and can potentially be a second liner if all goes well, we get Staal who is a solid two way 55-70pt centre who is one of the better defensive forwards in the league.
 
23273_123088534385181_6830_n.jpg
 
It's amusing that the total that Pronger has as Staal's offensive floor is five more points than he's ever scored in a single season thus far in his career.
 
Also, it'd be somewhat fitting if we traded for Jordan Staal. That way, instead of having a #1 and #2 center, we'd just have two highly overrated and overpaid 2nd line centers in Staal and Grabovski.
 
It's amusing that the total that Pronger has as Staal's offensive floor is five more points than he's ever scored in a single season thus far in his career.

Yeah, I love how not only is Staal being described as a 70 point centre when he's never even approached that total. His minimum level of production is a level that he's never even attained yet in his career.
 
Back
Top