MindzEye
Wayward Ditch Pig
That's like saying that maybe Edmonton thought Hall wasn't a franchise player two years ago and that they would have preferred Schenn+Gudbranson over him. I mean, it's possible that they're really dumb, but my point is that it's highly unlikely. The #1 pick is rarely traded for a reason.. especially when there's a clear #1 like there is this year.
Maybe you guys just think more highly of Schenn than I do. Stay at home d really don't hold much trade value. They are typically worth more to their team than they are to others and often get overrated by their own fans. In Schenns case, he's a stay at home d with no real skills at the moment. He hasn't proven anything yet, and his upside is a #4. If Edmonton trades the #1, maybe they won't get a lot, but they can do much better than Schenn.
Well, I have a hard time accepting that his upside is that of a #4, when we've seen him play for extended stretches at that level in the past already.
as for stay at homes not having much value? Doesn't this argument get blown out of the water every free agent period? GM's consistently pay through the nose for Komisarek's, Volchenkov's, Michalek's....very good GM's pay every summer for stay at home defenders.
and sure...#1 picks don't get traded often, but you also don't often see a team collect so many of them in a short time period, where the best player available was always a forward. Don't get me wrong, I would just take Yak if I was Edmonton and call it a day....but it's not outlandish at all that they would see a recent #5 pick who has established himself as an NHL defender while developing in a pressure cooker, and the #5 pick in this year's draft....where Murray, a guy their GM is so high on that he brought him over to the WC just to get an extended look, is probably available, as a viable option.