• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

You're missing the point.

Again, you and zeke have argued for years that those are the worst type of players to target in free agency because you invariably overpay for them and they are easy to draft and extract performance out of for cheap.

I want no part of having to pay $3.5 million for Colby Armstrong when I can simply draft a player such as Lukas Sutter or Coda Gordon in the third round. I don't want to pay $5 million to Joe Pavelski when I can simply draft a Sebastian Collberg or Pontus Aberg in the first round.

Pay good money for your top players. That's always the top priority.

It's the 3rd/4th liners that you shouldn't spend good money on.

The problem with Colby Armstrong is that he's a 3rd/4th liner. If he could play in the top 6, his salary is reasonable.

But his upside isn't that high anyways, that's the problem.

His upside is based on his position / style of play. If all he becomes is a 30-40 point, 3rd line PF -- that's still a pretty valuable asset compared with your average 2nd/3rd liner that you may draft with a late pick.
 
Pay good money for your top players. That's always the top priority.

It's the 3rd/4th liners that you shouldn't spend good money on.

The problem with Colby Armstrong is that he's a 3rd/4th liner. If he could play in the top 6, his salary is reasonable.



His upside is based on his position / style of player. If all he becomes is a 30-40 point, 3rd line PF -- that's still a pretty valuable asset compared with your average 2nd/3rd liner.

I would argue you can find 30-40 point, 3rd line PFs later in the draft.
 
I would argue you can find 30-40 point, 3rd line PFs later in the draft.

100 percent.

You should be aiming for higher upside players in the first round than a guy who might, might be able to contribute as a third-line physical forward. That's a nice piece, but it's not the type of player I'd target. You can find David Jones/Dustin Penner types in the third and fourth rounds in every draft.
 
Basically, my point is

*Acquire elite talent when available.
*If you're down to choosing between good to average talent -- take the guy who plays a style or position that is more rare, even if there might be a difference in overall production.


I would never take a player like Biggs high in the draft because the high end upside isn't there, but when you're choosing between players who are all likely to be non 1st liners, a player like Biggs provides a skillset that's normally more difficult to find.
 
100 percent.

You should be aiming for higher upside players in the first round than a guy who might, might be able to contribute as a third-line physical forward. That's a nice piece, but it's not the type of player I'd target. You can find David Jones/Dustin Penner types in the third and fourth rounds in every draft.

There aren't many David Jones' around -- which is why the Avs just gave him 4 mill.
 
I think you could've held on to all your picks and still picked a player that could be a power forward someday with higher upside than Biggs at 39, the pick we moved for him.
 
But when they've selected "trucculence" in the later rounds like Broll you say that they suck and shouldn't be signed. So don't take big, physical players ever?

The reason Biggs was a first round pick is because he can play hockey unlike the later round guys like Broll and Devane. That can't be overlooked. It's one of the most important factors that make him a good prospect.
 
The other thing that can't be ignored is that last years draft was fcking awful after the top 10 or so picks. It's not like they passed over a handful of stud prospects even if you could name 2 or 3 guys you'd rather have taken.
 
But when they've selected "trucculence" in the later rounds like Broll you say that they suck and shouldn't be signed.

Broll does suck though.

So don't take big, physical players ever?

No, you take big, physical players that have shown some glimmer of offensive promise at the minor league level. And I don't even mean necessarily just great stats. Note that I've never complained about the Ross or Leivo picks - because it's not big physical players I have an issue with.

The reason Biggs was a first round pick is because he can play hockey unlike the later round guys like Broll and Devane. That can't be overlooked. It's one of the most important factors that make him a good prospect.

Our opinions on how well he can play hockey clearly differ, though. It's just an opinion, sure, but until Biggs does anything to prove me wrong I believe I'm entitled to it.
 
I'd agree with that. But both those guys bring a unique and very useful skillet to the table if it is combined with te ability to play hockey. Neither guy is going to run your PP or lead your team in scoring but I can't say I'm not looking forward to the day when we have a 6'2 220 physical force and a big time pest in the lineup.

If both those guys become the players they project to become they will make the leafs a hell of a lot harder to play against.
 
I'd agree with that. But both those guys bring a unique and very useful skillet to the table if it is combined with te ability to play hockey. Neither guy is going to run your PP or lead your team in scoring but I can't say I'm not looking forward to the day when we have a 6'2 220 physical force and a big time pest in the lineup.

So you agree that you can probably find truculent players with as much or more upside than Biggs beyond the first round and without having to move up in the draft?
 
Last edited:
Well they are different. I think big players that are wrecking balls on the ice go earlier than pest. I've seen a ton of rankings that put Tom Wilson in the first round, and as high as the teens. Especially in shallow drafts like last year. In another year they might have been able to get Biggs at 39.
 
On a side note, this is what I don't get about people who say that Burke doesn't have a vision or a plan. Its right in front of us, its just not in the NHL yet. He's adding all different types of players to the organization to try and build what he thinks is a contending team. He's not just out looking for high end talent, he is looking for everything. first liners, second liners, third liners, fourth liners. Bulldozers, pests, second pairing D like Percy and Blacker.

Maybe down the road when he has the team he wants he will shift his draft strategy to just try and find the most skilled players he can. But right now he is still building the foundation of what will hopefully be a cup contender. The team on the ice right now is just a bandaid.
 
If I'm picking a player that projects as a PF in the first round, I'd like it to be one with top six potential.

I don't believe it's particularly hard to find truculent players to play on your third and fourth lines, I think you can get them later in the draft. I do think it's REALLY difficult to find truculence/players with size that can play in your top 6 though.
 
Well they are different. I think big players that are wrecking balls on the ice go earlier than pest. I've seen a ton of rankings that put Tom Wilson in the first round, and as high as the teens. Especially in shallow drafts like last year. In another year they might have been able to get Biggs at 39.

I don't really want Tom Wilson either though.
 
Back
Top