• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

If I'm picking a player that projects as a PF in the first round, I'd like it to be one with top six potential.

I don't believe it's particularly hard to find truculent players to play on your third and fourth lines, I think you can get them later in the draft. I do think it's REALLY difficult to find truculence/players with size that can play in your top 6 though.

Really what the Biggs pick comes down to is whether he can become at least a 20 goal 40 point guy in the NHL or not. I think he will. You don't. If he does it was a good pick, if he doesn't it wasn't. We'll see.
 
So now we're lowering our expectations to 20/40 guy?

Yeesh. When he was initially drafted I recalled people expecting 30/60 type production. This sounds like a classic case of moving the goal-posts in terms of expectations.

And really, being satisfied with a 20/40 producer in the first round? It was a weak draft admittedly but if you draft a guy like Rattie you at least open the possibility to star production, even if it's unlikely. Had the Leafs badly wanted to go the power forward route they would have been better served with simply maintaining the position of their two first round selections and selecting Saad at 39.

That would have been the best of both worlds: acquire a power forward, but one with a track record illustrating some sort of tangible offensive upside. The fact that Saad was deemed NHL-ready enough by one of the better clubs in the league to step in on opening night and didn't look particularly out of place against grown men makes that omission even more glaring.
 
Choosing truculence over skill is not a strategy that will lead to success for Burke and the Leafs, IMO. I haven't liked a few of the picks he's made where he's made them.
 
So now we're lowering our expectations to 20/40 guy?

Yeesh. When he was initially drafted I recalled people expecting 30/60 type production. This sounds like a classic case of moving the goal-posts in terms of expectations.

And really, being satisfied with a 20/40 producer in the first round? It was a weak draft admittedly but if you draft a guy like Rattie you at least open the possibility to star production, even if it's unlikely. Had the Leafs badly wanted to go the power forward route they would have been better served with simply maintaining the position of their two first round selections and selecting Saad at 39. That would have been the best of both worlds.

25. Percy
30. Rattie
39. Saad

Two better prospects than Biggs, IMO.

Saad U.S. National Under-18 Team 24gms 12gls 26pts (Pre-Draft Year)
Biggs U.S. National Under-18 Team 20gms 5gls 9pts (Draft Year)
 
So now we're lowering our expectations to 20/40 guy?

Yeesh. When he was initially drafted I recalled people expecting 30/60 type production. This sounds like a classic case of moving the goal-posts in terms of expectations.

And really, being satisfied with a 20/40 producer in the first round? It was a weak draft admittedly but if you draft a guy like Rattie you at least open the possibility to star production, even if it's unlikely. Had the Leafs badly wanted to go the power forward route they would have been better served with simply maintaining the position of their two first round selections and selecting Saad at 39.

That would have been the best of both worlds: acquire a power forward, but one with a track record illustrating some sort of tangible offensive upside. The fact that Saad was deemed NHL-ready enough by one of the better clubs in the league to step in on opening night and didn't look particularly out of place against grown men makes that omission even more glaring.

Saad is a different kind of player though. Biggs isn't just a big forward. He is a physical force. He's the type of guy that can impact the game without the puck. Just like guys like Hartnell, Brown, Lucic, Backes, none of whom are consistent 30/60 type of players.

For Biggs to be a good pick he just has to be able to play hockey and contribute enough to receive minutes. You don't need to be a 30 goal scorer to do that. You just don't. That said don't confuse the 20/40 mark with writing off the possibility of being better than that. Thats just the minimum of what he needs to become to justify the selection.
 
Saad is a different kind of player though. Biggs isn't just a big forward. He is a physical force. He's the type of guy that can impact the game without the puck. Just like guys like Hartnell, Brown, Lucic, Backes, none of whom are consistent 30/60 type of players.

For Biggs to be a good pick he just has to be able to play hockey and contribute enough to receive minutes. You don't need to be a 30 goal scorer to do that. You just don't. That said don't confuse the 20/40 mark with writing off the possibility of being better than that. Thats just the minimum of what he needs to become to justify the selection.

Again, not 'just like'. Almost all of those players showed the ability to contribute significantly at lower levels of hockey.
 
I said he's the type of guy that can impact the game WITHOUT the puck like those guys. Which no matter how much they score, is their prime asset.

He's not just a Brandon Saad-type power forward.
 
This conversation is ridiculous. We're just re-stating the exact same points over and over again. I think it was a bad selection, HL thinks it was a bad selection, and 101 and Player don't.

Who cares? I hope he succeeds because in the end I'm a Leafs fan and want the team's picks to do well.
 
If I'm using my first rounders on guys with 30-40 point third line potential, where the hell am I supposed to be drafting potential top sixers?
 
I think he does have top 6 potential, and obviously the Leafs do too. He may not have first line potential, but he has top 6 potential. Only 138 forwards scored 40 points this year. Teams don't have 6 60+ point players.
 
Last edited:
Bob Mackenzie:

NHL Upside - Has been compared to Los Angeles Kings' forward Kyle Clifford. Should be a tough, intimidating second or third-line winger who will battle hard.

ISS:

NHL Potential:
Top 6 power forward who will fight and be a reliable garbage goal scorer on the powerplay.
 
Yeah and ISS compared him to Keith Tkachuk. Moral of the story, all of these comparisons are stupid and not particularly helpful.
 
Justin Schultz is already generating some heat on his decision to not sign with Anaheim.

http://www.anaheimcalling.com/2012/...rros-schultz-update-tampering-getzlaf-selanne

I asked all of the above, "What's the deal with Justin Schultz and are the tampering rumors true?" here's what each said:

Bob Murray: "Justin Schultz will not be an Anaheim Duck, He's informed us that he wishes to explore talks with the 29 other clubs, and that's his right under the current CBA. I cannot comment on the tampering charges at this time but if situations change I will let all of you know."

Ryan Getzlaf: "I've never seen him play or anything but I hear he's pretty good. He better be really good because a lot of players, not just on this team, don't like the way he's handling this situation. We want guys who want to be here and be a part of our team. No one wants to deal with that sh... uh stuff in the locker room." He corrected himself as my 6 year old son approached. Good dad! He also said he's more disappointed that the organization lost a draft pick rather than losing Schultz.

Bruce Boudreau: "I don't know what the heck happened there. We were in Chicago and we still weren't playing great and I talked to the kid straight up and said we could use you right now on the big club. We won't send you to the Crunch, as soon as you're through with Wisconsin we'll get you down there on the ice. The kid looked me right in the eye and said I can't wait coach, it's what I've always wanted. We also told him since we were playing him now it would move him one year closer to making millions of dollars. The kid seemed really excited and it seemed like a done deal when all of a sudden something dramatically changed. Someone got to the kid, it seems. I don't know exactly what happened but there's something fishy in Denmark." (sic)
 
We know exactly who Boudreau is talking about. Expect Burke to start getting more heat on him as July 1st approaches
 
The tampering thing doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

What would be the purpose of the Leafs as a organization ever directly or indirectly making contact with Schultz? I'm not sure they would be able to tell him anything that wasn't already totally obvious.
 
They are going to claim he used Gardiner to sway his decision if he signs. Good luck proving it but I cann see it happening
 
Back
Top