• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I think Burke looks at Grab oand sees a guy that Kadri will probably surpass as early as next year (or even late this year).

That's why I think he's gone. Because there's a premium available in trade, and the replacement is already waiting in the wings.
 
Tucker situation back then, where we could've traded him for a good premium, chose not to, and saw him stall and regress right after, I am sensing something similar with MacA right now.

really? i see that out of kulemin and grabovski. i'd trade them.
 
And as for Beauch, you can feel free to admit whenever you feel it appropriate just how wrong you were about his being a stud first pairing guy.
 
really? i see that out of kulemin and grabovski. i'd trade them.

I really think Grabo and Kuly have a ways to go. I see them both as 35 goal guys. And with Grabo's tenacity and Kuly's power, and both of their passion, I wouldn't trade them for pretty much anything right now.
 
Grabo or Kulemin won't regress. Kulemin has that big body/skating/shot/defensive play to be a top tier two way forward. Grabo is 27 so his best hockey will occur from now to over the next 3-4 years.
 
Unless a name like Stastny is involved, Kadri doesn't need to worry about moving ... the only move he may see, is from the Marlies to the Leafs, if Burke deals 1 of this top 6 ... even that is highly unlikely though
 
Grabo or Kulemin won't regress. Kulemin has that big body/skating/shot/defensive play to be a top tier two way forward. Grabo is 27 so his best hockey will occur from now to over the next 3-4 years.

but that doesn't apply to the 25 year old macarthur
 
but that doesn't apply to the 25 year old macarthur

It's not that, if you look at them statistically and age wise, there is an argument to be made. There isn't, I concede that.

But it's in watching them play. I see uptapped potential in both Grabo and Kuly. I see a reached ceiling in MacArthur.
 
McGuire: LA is most desperate to make moves today. Their fanbase demands them to make the next step, and they have accumulated so many young players over the last few years they are going to make some future for presence move today.

That said, B Schenn is supposedly off-limit.
 
I could see Kadri moving if a player like Statsny was available...but as he's absolutely not, Kadri's staying put.
 
Dude, you're outright lying and you know it. That's why you piss me off sometimes because it's like you have to make shit up to appear correct. Must I dig up from the archives?

You know full well I said that Beauch should return something good because I thought some dumb team would still be high on his Cup win and would pay a decent amount for him. In fact, I PREDICTED Anaheim repeatedly since last year since they knew him best. I called it.

Regarding Boyes, I don't even know what you're talking about? Did we debate about his return? I only remember saying that I liked him (which I still do) and that I would like the Leafs to get him. I don't recall saying anything at all about his return. Maybe I did, but I don't remember it being any sort of issue with me.


Hey, tell yourself whatever you'd like to believe - and keep telling me that I'm wrong despite the evidence to the contrary. I don't care.

As for MacA and Tucker, in my original post, which you did not bother reading, I acknowledged the differences between them. But I said I have a feeling that like the Tucker situation back then, where we could've traded him for a good premium, chose not to, and saw him stall and regress right after, I am sensing something similar with MacA right now. This is our chance to get something really good back for him, and we'll likely never have that shot again, due to his great season, his low $1M salary, and the logjam in the West. It is a unique trade opportunity. Plain and simple. There is no "mistake" in that analysis, much as you want to pretend there is.

If you think Mac will regress and that he's having a career year that's fine.

Comparing him to a 32 year old Tucker doesn't make any sense, though, and can only lead to you making a mistake in assessing the situation. It kind of makes the whole idea of using comparables useless when you make a comparison like this.

If you look at the Tucker example, you'd have to compare the situation to the Lightning choosing to trade Tucker in the midst of his 24 year old season, when he was in the middle of a breakout season, on pace for 23gls/56pts.

How did that trade work out for the Bolts?
 
Back
Top