• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

McGuire: LA is most desperate to make moves today. Their fanbase demands them to make the next step, and they have accumulated so many young players over the last few years they are going to make some future for presence move today.

That said, B Schenn is supposedly off-limit.

Lombardi already said he is not off-limits the other day. It just has to be a great offer. Which we already knew.

Burke has to be trying to get Brayden right now. And I'm sure he's chasing the likes of Beach, Del Zotto, and a few other near-ready former first rounders. MacA will go when one of the GMs loses his shit at 11:50.
 
@ pronger

don't respond to my posts, please

images
 
I can understand why B.Schenn would be unavailable. I mean, really, are there any guys supposedly available today that you'd be comfortable trading Nazem Kadri for?
 
Burke wouldn't even move the #7 pick to try and trade up for Tavares.

Kadri isn't going anywhere.
no i don't think that's true. He COULDN'T make a trade to move up to #1 overall ... if he could, he would.

No team has traded away their #1 overall draft pick ... pretty much ever. The only times #1 overall pick was 'traded' was when Lindros made it public he wouldn't play for Quebec ... .
 
Hey, tell yourself whatever you'd like to believe - and keep telling me that I'm wrong despite the evidence to the contrary. I don't care.

Does this statement mean anything? Anyway, we both know the truth. That's good enough. I'd rather focus on trades today than bullshit arguments.


If you think Mac will regress and that he's having a career year that's fine.

Comparing him to a 32 year old Tucker doesn't make any sense, though, and can only lead to you making a mistake in assessing the situation. It kind of makes the whole idea of using comparables useless when you make a comparison like this.

If you look at the Tucker example, you'd have to compare the situation to the Lightning choosing to trade Tucker in the midst of his 24 year old season, when he was in the middle of a breakout season, on pace for 23gls/56pts.

How did that trade work out for the Bolts?

Again, forget about where the players are at in their respective careers. Forget about when Tucker got traded first and all the other irrelevant stuff you're bringing up.

This is a one time opportunity with MacA. He'll hit 60 points this year. But it's not like he's going to hit 70 - 80 next year and beyond. He just doesn't have that in him.

And he'll never cost only $1M again. This logjam in the West is unique as well. The number of really good prospects available for trade is unprecedented right now. As a result, this is a rare chance to - like we could've with Tucker before resigning him - trade a guy at his likely ceiling and get back assets that are worth more than him.
 
The comparison makes no sense. It doesn't shed any light on the situation.

You are choosing a (misdirected) comparable based on what you want to believe, not basing your belief on what actual comparables indicate.
 
The comparison makes no sense. It doesn't shed any light on the situation.

You are choosing a (misdirected) comparable based on what you want to believe, not basing your belief on what actual comparables indicate.

I'm not comparing the players themselves at all. Why don't you get that?
 
incarceratedbob

**NHL HOT RUMOR**Source: Leafs monitoring price for Weiss / Booth still 2high > Liles price is dropping Leafs have competition Caps / Hawks
 
no i don't think that's true. He COULDN'T make a trade to move up to #1 overall ... if he could, he would.

No team has traded away their #1 overall draft pick ... pretty much ever. The only times #1 overall pick was 'traded' was when Lindros made it public he wouldn't play for Quebec ... .

No. Burke tried hard to move up. But he said himself he refused to include the number 7 pick in any proposal. Because he wanted Kadri.
 
So you're just saying that you think Mac will regress because some random 32 year regressed 5 years ago?

fine, I guess.
 
I'm not comparing the players themselves at all. Why don't you get that?

But yet you feel that MacA will suffer the same type of seasonal regression that Tucker did at 32?

There isn't a GM in the league that will trade a potential 80-90pt prospect for an RFA player who will likely take them to arbitration in the midst of a great year. Unless of course it's part of a much larger deal.
 
Was talking to mbow about this yesterday, but I just love how every decent player in Florida is awesome individually, and would produce more on any other team, yet they can't produce or succeed playing together. Horton, Bouwmeester, Jokinen, Weiss, Booth. All these guys are awesome, but MacArthur and Grabo are tweeners who aren't real top 6 players.
 
Weiss would get absolutely crucified in this city, IMO.

Booth is an interesting possibility, though.
 
Back
Top