• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I'd like to see Burke package those 1st's for a good young player. If he does, the Kaberle and Versteeg trades will make a lot more sense.

Unless the Leafs land Richards, Burke will likely have to make a trade to improve the forward core because the UFA class is lacking top end talent.
 
i don't know if we need to make 'sense' of those trades any more than by saying they traded a pending ufa for a couple of young assets, and that they traded a guy who was making a lot of money and never really fit with the team for some cap relief and a young asset.

unless they can get into the top five, or murphy falls and they can grab him at ten (or thereabouts) this is still a draft, imo, where you're better off with a pair of picks in the mid 20s than a pick in the 10-15 range. i just don't see anybody really separating themselves outside of the top five plus murphy, who might fall due to size.

in all, though, on their face i don't see anything befuddling about the kaberle and versteeg trades. burke just didn't have the money to re-up kaberle, and i think it's pretty clear that he grew to dislike versteeg.
 
Well, the option was there to keep both players. Or trade them for more established assets (like the Beau deal).

The chances of any of those 1st's turning into players as good as Versteeg and Kaberle are very small.

I can understand why Burke made these moves, he had two players who he didn't really like, so he took the best possible deals. But I'd like to see those picks turned into something tangible instead of hoping late 1sts become NHLers.
 
Dave Morrison and co have done a fantastic job these last few years. I have no problem giving them more and higher picks.

Using the cap space gained gets you immediate "tangible" assets.
 
Well, the option was there to keep both players. Or trade them for more established assets (like the Beau deal).

The chances of any of those 1st's turning into players as good as Versteeg and Kaberle are very small.

I can understand why Burke made these moves, he had two players who he didn't really like, so he took the best possible deals. But I'd like to see those picks turned into something tangible instead of hoping late 1sts become NHLers.

I think the consensus (and Burke's stated plan) is to flip those picks at the draft. I wholeheartedly support that, because just as guys like Versteeg are overvalued at the deadline, 1st rounders are overvalued in the draft.
 
The picks will only be overvalued to teams that are targeting certain players during the draft. To that point, the picks mean very little until the player is still in the stands when that pick is up.

A team like Florida which is doing a bottom-up rebuild will also be interested in those picks. Loading up in a particular draft year is a common rebuild strategy.
 
"The Blue Jackets are expected to make significant changes this offseason after missing the playoffs for the ninth time in 10 NHL seasons. And those changes might not be confined to the dressing room.

Fed up with chronic losing and declining attendance, and searching for ways to finally get the franchise past its expansion persona, Blue Jackets officials plan to take a critical look at every aspect of the organization, from the high reaches of the hockey operations department to the training staff.

"This is something you'd do with any business that hasn't been as successful as you'd like," majority owner John P. McConnell said. "Obviously this year has been a disappointing season for us as an organization.




Welcome to Toronto Rick Nash.
 
"They" being Columbus?

rick nash might be the most overrated player in the league (him or jeff carter).

he just isn't a centrepiece. he's a goal scorer who happens to be big, and that's about it. he is an andreychuk. he needs his gilmour.

good luck adding that gilmour when you have $7.5mn in nash, $5.5mn in kessel and $6.5mn in phaneuf.

above and beyond that nazem kadri is going to be a more productive player than rick nash. because unlike nash, kadri makes the players around him better.

don't get me wrong, i'd love to have a big strong power winger who can dominate teh corners and score goals.

but not at the price of kadri.
 
I don't think it will be an issue. Columbus would laugh at Nash for Kadri offers.

just like tampa would laugh at trading brad richards for mike smith, jeff halpern and jussi jokinen

just like atlanta would laugh at trading ilya kovalchuk for niklas bergfors and jonny oduya

just like ottawa would laugh at trading dany heatley for milan michalek and jonathan cheechoo

just like boston would laugh at trading joe thornton for brad stuart and marco sturm

just like calgary would laugh at trading dion phaneuf for ian white and matt stajan.

it boggles my mind how no matter how many times star players get traded for absolute shit, people think you're somehow crazy for suggesting another trade that is substantially better than practically every other trade involving a star player.
 
I agree with Mbow in terms of, Nash's point totals aren't nearly as spectaular as his reputation. In 3 of the last 4 seasons, he's been a 70 point guy -- which is good production, but not great.

But, in terms of team need -- he brings exactly what the Leafs need -- a combination of size, board play and skill.

The Leafs do have the young assets, draft picks and cap space to make a deal for him if the Jackets decide to really blow things up.
 
I agree with Mbow in terms of, Nash's point totals aren't nearly as spectaular as his reputation. In 3 of the last 4 seasons, he's been a 70 point guy -- which is good production, but not great.

But, in terms of team need -- he brings exactly what the Leafs need -- a combination of size, board play and skill.

The Leafs do have the young assets, draft picks and cap space to make a deal for him if the Jackets decide to really blow things up.

the question is: do you jump at nash, assuming it costs kadri, or do you wait until a centre comes available?

because, let's face it, this team needs help up the middle as much as it needs size on the wings. for me, i think i'd rather have a bona fide first line centre (say, brad richards), and a second line power winger (say, dustin penner), than a first line power winger (rick nash) and a second line centre on the first line (like laich).

and i guess it's possible to add nash and a first line centre... but imo, that's very unlikely.

now, if they can keep kadri to be that centre and use assets like those two first rounders, d'amigo, etc. then it's a different story.

but the thing is i think columbus will have a lot more interest in nhl-ready youngsters, and all the leafs have in that regard is kadri, unless you're looking to move schenn (who, frankly, i wouldn't trade for nash) or aulie (who i might, although i kind of really like the idea of phaneuf-schenn-aulie in the top four for the long run).
 
Ideally, I'd like to keep Kadri -- but he's probably the first guy they would ask for because he's young, cheap, NHL ready and he has 1st line potential.

If we could get him for a combination of players like Schenn, Kulemin, draft picks (or something like that) -- I think I would do it. A line of Nash/Kadri/Kessel would be absolutely sick.
 
I don't see why they'd trade Nash. It finally looks like the found someone for him to play with in Johanssen.

Until now he's been the only thing going right for that franchise.
 
I think we could put together a pretty good package for any star player without having to part with Kadri... Colborne, Gardiner, two first rounders, McKegg, Blacker, D'amigo, Ross, one of our young goalies, etc. Lots to choose from and enough depth to give up a good package pretty comfortably I think.
 
No way they are trading Schenn for Nash. Burke beleafs in Schenn. The kid is a LION, I will give him that, in an era where most men truly remind me of weak kneed wusses. I was going to say women, but women have grown serious balls in the past twenty years, they are almost phsyically discernible now.
 
Back
Top