leafman101
Well-known member
Thats not the point. I was just naming names that have been mentioned of the type of guy you give Kadri up for.
in voracek and schenn philadelphpia might have walked away with the two best players between the two deals.
and they added an 8th overall pick, and a 22 year old with a 20 goal 40 point season under his belt as well.
they were both very savvy trades.
Voracek has been underwhelming and Schenn has done nothing so far other than be a highly touted prospect (much like Kadri).
But Philly gave up a potential 50 goal guy in Carter and a great gritty scoring captain in Richards.
And all this to sign Bryz to a monster deal for the next decade.
Carter will burst in Columbus.
His goals will go up and his assists while playing with Nash will soar.
Everyone's all disappointed in Carter because he went from almost scoring 50 to being in the 35 range the last couple of years. He's a young guy though, with immense talent. He'll be back up there soon enough.
And 35 goals is nothing to sneer at anyway, if that's his floor. People seem pretty happy with Kessel's standard 35 for some reason.
But let's make something very clear. Richards and Carter were very much the 1-2 punch up front, and corner stone of the team for years to come. When Holmgren gave them their long contracts, he wasn't thinking about trading them.The Flyers took a risk, but they picked a few really good guys to take that risk on. Eventually something was going to have to give when Giroux/JVR were up for extentions. They couldn't keep the core together forever.
Holmgren was proactive and got great value for guys, instead of waiting to long, and losing guy for nothing, or putting himself in a bad bargaining position to deal those guys.
The Flyers took a risk, but they picked a few really good guys to take that risk on. Eventually something was going to have to give when Giroux/JVR were up for extentions. They couldn't keep the core together forever.
Holmgren was proactive and got great value for guys, instead of waiting to long, and losing guy for nothing, or putting himself in a bad bargaining position to deal those guys.
Kulemin who is as good as M. Richards was offered AND Kadri for M. Richards. Which I think is overpayment. And we STILL got turned down
But let's make something very clear. Richards and Carter were very much the 1-2 punch up front, and corner stone of the team for years to come. When Holmgren gave them their long contracts, he wasn't thinking about trading them.
And Holmgren didn't trade these guys because he wants to be prepared when Giroux and JVR hit RFA, and he definitely had other ways to fit Bryz under the cap.
He traded these 2 guys because he wanted to go in a different direction. It tells you what happens behind closed door isn't so rosy in the dressing room, and there's probably some truth to the rumors that both of these young guys were dressing room cancer