• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Would you guys give up Kadri in a deal for Thornton.

Big Joe would be my number 1 target [would love our Big Joe to learn from THE Big Joe], not sure if hes available, but it may be time for a shake up in SJ.
 
Funny listening to Sportsnet because they seem to believe the Leafs will have no interest in Brad Richards, just talking about the Rangers/Flyers being interested and then suggesting that nobody wants late first rounders in a soft draft.
 
So exactly how are we suppose to get Parise? Has he completely blown his leg out and is the reason the Devils would even entertain an offer? I don't see the LEafs doing anything other than making a play for Richards or moving up in the draft. But as usual, rumors will be the Leafs are in the run for every elite player out there.
 
Last edited:
in voracek and schenn philadelphpia might have walked away with the two best players between the two deals.

and they added an 8th overall pick, and a 22 year old with a 20 goal 40 point season under his belt as well.

they were both very savvy trades.

Voracek has been underwhelming and Schenn has done nothing so far other than be a highly touted prospect (much like Kadri).

But Philly gave up a potential 50 goal guy in Carter and a great gritty scoring captain in Richards.

They definitely lost the best player in both of those deals. There's no guarantee whatsoever that Schenn and Voracek become anything more than borderline second liners or worse.

And all this to sign Bryz to a monster deal for the next decade.

I'm not a fan of the moves for Philly at all in comparison to LA (especially) and Columbus. I was leaning this way yesterday but am now fully shaking my head at Philly for these moves.
 
Carter will burst in Columbus.

His goals will go up and his assists while playing with Nash will soar.

Everyone's all disappointed in Carter because he went from almost scoring 50 to being in the 35 range the last couple of years. He's a young guy though, with immense talent. He'll be back up there soon enough.

And 35 goals is nothing to sneer at anyway, if that's his floor. People seem pretty happy with Kessel's standard 35 for some reason.
 
Oh god.. I can't imagine the disaster of putting Carter on Nash's line. Worst possible combination I can ever dream of. They will (and should) put them on separate lines. One 30 goal scorer on each of your top two lines is a nice luxury anyway.
 
Voracek has been underwhelming and Schenn has done nothing so far other than be a highly touted prospect (much like Kadri).

Voracek has been a little underwhelming, but he has done more at a younger age than either Carter or Richards. Schenn has the bust factor, but we're looking at arguably the best forward prospect in hockey right now.

There is undeniable risk for Philadelphia here. But we have to remember that Voracek and Schenn are both superior prospects than Carter and Richards ever were. Both could bust, but both have upside to be at least as good as Carter and Richards were in their peak seaosns, and quite a bit better than both have been over the past two years. That isn't a given, but then the trades weren't one-for-one swaps.

But Philly gave up a potential 50 goal guy in Carter and a great gritty scoring captain in Richards.

it makes zero sense to write off the trade from Philly's perspective because of potential and hten overstate the case on Richards and Carter. Likewise, Columbus gave up a potential 50 goal guy, and LA gave up a potential great gritty scoring captain (as for citing the captaincy... that's a huge mark AGAINST Richards. I can't believe how many people are ignoring the fact that Philadelphia just elected to trade its 26 year old captain. That's very telling, imo).

I actually like Richards... Carter is a one dimensional scorer, though, and the gaudy totals from 08-09 look to me to be the result of a flukey first half. From January onwards he scored 19 in 45 (35 goal pace). This was followed by seasons of 33 in 74 (36 goal pace) and 36 in 80 (37 goal pace).

He's a 35ish goal guy who can possibly approach 40.

And all this to sign Bryz to a monster deal for the next decade.

Yeah, this to me is a mistake. I'm not convinced that Bryzgalov is the answer in net.
 
The Flyers took a risk, but they picked a few really good guys to take that risk on. Eventually something was going to have to give when Giroux/JVR were up for extentions. They couldn't keep the core together forever.

Holmgren was proactive and got great value for guys, instead of waiting to long, and losing guy for nothing, or putting himself in a bad bargaining position to deal those guys.
 
I am convinced Bryz is NOT the answer in net.

On another note, though its still early, it looks quite probably Burke will not make a move today and will pick with the 3 draft picks in the first 2 rounds.
 
Carter will burst in Columbus.

His goals will go up and his assists while playing with Nash will soar.

Everyone's all disappointed in Carter because he went from almost scoring 50 to being in the 35 range the last couple of years. He's a young guy though, with immense talent. He'll be back up there soon enough.

And 35 goals is nothing to sneer at anyway, if that's his floor. People seem pretty happy with Kessel's standard 35 for some reason.

How is Carter going to magically turn into a play-maker? When he's always been more of a goal-scorer than an assist guy in his junior and professional career?
 
This was a deal organized by the Snider family who were puked out at Richards and Carter getting party time during a 4-0 drubbing by the Bruins.

And when Philly signs Brad Richards who is better than Richards M. and Carter combined, this deal will signify a Stanley Cup most likely. Let the good times roll in Philly.

Kulemin who is as good as M. Richards was offered AND Kadri for M. Richards. Which I think is overpayment. And we STILL got turned down.

That shows what OTHER TEAMS think of Kadri as well as Burke/Nonis. NOT FREAKING MUCH.
 
I don't think we got turned down I think the just liked LA's offer better which is no slight against Kully or Kadri. Apparently Holgrem is the one who came calling for them not vice versa
 
The Flyers took a risk, but they picked a few really good guys to take that risk on. Eventually something was going to have to give when Giroux/JVR were up for extentions. They couldn't keep the core together forever.

Holmgren was proactive and got great value for guys, instead of waiting to long, and losing guy for nothing, or putting himself in a bad bargaining position to deal those guys.
But let's make something very clear. Richards and Carter were very much the 1-2 punch up front, and corner stone of the team for years to come. When Holmgren gave them their long contracts, he wasn't thinking about trading them.

And Holmgren didn't trade these guys because he wants to be prepared when Giroux and JVR hit RFA, and he definitely had other ways to fit Bryz under the cap.

He traded these 2 guys because he wanted to go in a different direction. It tells you what happens behind closed door isn't so rosy in the dressing room, and there's probably some truth to the rumors that both of these young guys were dressing room cancer
 
The Flyers took a risk, but they picked a few really good guys to take that risk on. Eventually something was going to have to give when Giroux/JVR were up for extentions. They couldn't keep the core together forever.

Holmgren was proactive and got great value for guys, instead of waiting to long, and losing guy for nothing, or putting himself in a bad bargaining position to deal those guys.

that's true. hanging on to them probably would have sealed giroux's and JVR's fate... cause once those NTC's kicked in he m ight never have been able to deal richards or carter
 
But let's make something very clear. Richards and Carter were very much the 1-2 punch up front, and corner stone of the team for years to come. When Holmgren gave them their long contracts, he wasn't thinking about trading them.

And Holmgren didn't trade these guys because he wants to be prepared when Giroux and JVR hit RFA, and he definitely had other ways to fit Bryz under the cap.

He traded these 2 guys because he wanted to go in a different direction. It tells you what happens behind closed door isn't so rosy in the dressing room, and there's probably some truth to the rumors that both of these young guys were dressing room cancer

except they weren't the 1-2 punch.. giroux very clearly emerged as their best forward this year. and when push came to shove briere outperformed them both in the playoffs (as he has in every season)... and was comparable during the regular season.
 
Back
Top