A guy like Frattin shouldn't really be lumped in there. He's played one NHL game.
If the Leafs go out and sign Richards and a guy like Laich, Lagenbrunner, Cole, Arnott, whats the harm in making Frattin beat out a guy like Brown, or Orr, or Bozak, or MacArthur, or whoever for a roster spot? There isn't any.
I don't think there's any downside to holding one third line spot open for a bunch of prospects as good as colborne/frattin/caputi/d'amigo to fight over.
Doesn't seem like a good chance of that to me... of course it's possible....there is a good chance that none of them become even a fourth liner.
Well who to spend the money on is a whole other issue.
But either way you don't just leave spots open for B/C level prospects to fight over, and hope to hell one of them can play.
Doesn't seem like a good chance of that to me... course it's possible.
This.That's what we're suggesting.....if you have to add talent, add 1st or 2nd line FA's.....not 3rd liners like Talbot or Belanger.
If we're not adding a 1st or 2nd line talent that pushes someone else down, then I'd rather have Kadri (who is clearly capable of handling a third line spot at minimum) Frattin (who Burke has confidence in) and Bozak fighting over two spots, than overpaying someone to come in and be a third liner and potentially block the others.
... but not ONE of them is even close to a shoe-in to have nhl success at this point in time.
But why does it have to be overpaying someone to block others. Even a guy like you mentioned in Belanger would be a prudent move. He only made 750k last year. Thats not overpaying. Thats not an immovable contract that will block anyone.
Its a cheap, quality NHLer, that doesn't force you to play guys who aren't quality NHLers.
But yeah. Signing better guys is even better.
Yeah, but there are always guys who get left out in the cold. Happened to Mac last year too.
I think we are all agreed on don't give big money to guys like Talbot though.
What is to stop MLSE from giving him an offer of 14 million for one year?