• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I don't think there's any downside to holding one third line spot open for a bunch of prospects as good as colborne/frattin/caputi/d'amigo to fight over.
 
There is a ton of downside. We've seen it each of the last few years, ending up icing a line up with a bunch of non NHL calibre players.

Even though its "just the 3rd line" it hurts.
 
If the Leafs go out and sign Richards and a guy like Laich, Lagenbrunner, Cole, Arnott, whats the harm in making Frattin beat out a guy like Brown, or Orr, or Bozak, or MacArthur, or whoever for a roster spot? There isn't any.
 
If the Leafs go out and sign Richards and a guy like Laich, Lagenbrunner, Cole, Arnott, whats the harm in making Frattin beat out a guy like Brown, or Orr, or Bozak, or MacArthur, or whoever for a roster spot? There isn't any.

That's what we're suggesting.....if you have to add talent, add 1st or 2nd line FA's.....not 3rd liners like Talbot or Belanger.
 
Well who to spend the money on is a whole other issue.

But either way you don't just leave spots open for B/C level prospects to fight over, and hope to hell one of them can play.
 
I don't think there's any downside to holding one third line spot open for a bunch of prospects as good as colborne/frattin/caputi/d'amigo to fight over.

that's the thing.. they look like decent prospects. but none of them are bluechippers. and while probability suggests that AT LEAST one of them will become a solid nhl'er, there is a good chance that none of them become even a fourth liner.
 
Well who to spend the money on is a whole other issue.

But either way you don't just leave spots open for B/C level prospects to fight over, and hope to hell one of them can play.

If we're not adding a 1st or 2nd line talent that pushes someone else down, then I'd rather have Kadri (who is clearly capable of handling a third line spot at minimum) Frattin (who Burke has confidence in) and Bozak fighting over two spots, than overpaying someone to come in and be a third liner and potentially block the others.

I didn't even think our third line was a big issue last year (in fact quite the opposite) when Armstrong was healthy, and we were throwing him out there with the likes of Tim Brent and Darryl Boyce.

I've little doubt a 'Frattin/Kadri - Bozak - Armstrong' line could perform at an adequate level.
 
Doesn't seem like a good chance of that to me... course it's possible.

of course there is. we're talking about two 4th round picks and a 6th round pick... guys with a 5-10% success rate... and a guy picked in the latter half of the first round (30%ish).

d'amigo couldn't hack it in the ahl this year... caputi and colborne both had extremely disappointing seasons... and frattin is fresh out of ncaa, which doesn't churn out a whole lot of nhl'ers.

don't get me wrong because they're all good prospects... but not ONE of them is even close to a shoe-in to have nhl success at this point in time.
 
That's what we're suggesting.....if you have to add talent, add 1st or 2nd line FA's.....not 3rd liners like Talbot or Belanger.
This.

Nobody's saying hand Frattin a roster spot. Just that it's stupid to spend big UFA bucks on 3rd/4th liners, especially when we have youngsters who stand a good chance of adequately filling the role. And at the same time, nobody's going to have any complaints if Frattin can't crack the roster because we added a couple of top-6 guys via free agency, and it pushed everybody else down the roster and eliminated the open spots on the third and fourth lines.
 
If we're not adding a 1st or 2nd line talent that pushes someone else down, then I'd rather have Kadri (who is clearly capable of handling a third line spot at minimum) Frattin (who Burke has confidence in) and Bozak fighting over two spots, than overpaying someone to come in and be a third liner and potentially block the others.

But why does it have to be overpaying someone to block others. Even a guy like you mentioned in Belanger would be a prudent move. He only made 750k last year. Thats not overpaying. Thats not an immovable contract that will block anyone.

Its a cheap, quality NHLer, that doesn't force you to play guys who aren't quality NHLers. And if Frattin or Bozak prove to be better than him, then that is fantastic. There is no negative to a move like that. Period.

But yeah. Signing better guys is even better.
 
... but not ONE of them is even close to a shoe-in to have nhl success at this point in time.

I never said anyone was a shoe in I just said I thought it was more likely than not that at least one of the four becomes a regular NHLer
 
I know, it's NEVER going to happen...but to fan the fire...

Nick Kypreos
Also heard from #NHL draft #Lightning and RFA Stamkos are not close to getting a deal done. Teams are eligible to submit offer sheet July 1
 
But why does it have to be overpaying someone to block others. Even a guy like you mentioned in Belanger would be a prudent move. He only made 750k last year. Thats not overpaying. Thats not an immovable contract that will block anyone.

Its a cheap, quality NHLer, that doesn't force you to play guys who aren't quality NHLers.

But yeah. Signing better guys is even better.

Getting Belanger for 750K one year deal (which I agree would be incredible) isn't likely very plausible though....he got left out in the cold last free agency period only after he basically had a deal in place with Washington (for more money) but then had to go find a team to sign him in September, once Washington couldn't free up the cap space needed.

It doesn't really make for a great example of something we should hope to see happen again......he'll get upwards of 2 million this year, I suspect, quite possibly on a 2 or 3 year deal even.

Spending 2 million of guys like Belanger or Talbot to play on the third line, in place of Frattin/Kadri/Bozak/Colborne/Caputi who who I think can be safely trusted to fill two of the three spots, just isn't necessary.
 
Yeah, but there are always guys who get left out in the cold. Happened to Mac last year too.

I think we are all agreed on don't give big money to guys like Talbot though.
 
Yeah, but there are always guys who get left out in the cold. Happened to Mac last year too.

I think we are all agreed on don't give big money to guys like Talbot though.

Thats a valid point.....I wouldn't make filling a third line spot a priority, but if we're sitting here in August/September and some worthwhile guys are available for cheap, that could provide an upgrade, I'd absolutely be willing to give them a shot.
 
What is to stop MLSE from giving him an offer of 14 million for one year? Let Komisarek and Lebda rot in the AHL and have a franchise player to stave off the endless attempts from Balsilie to peck away at MLSE branding and fan loyalty.

Would Yzerman match that 14 million, if he did,watch Burke scoop up Ryan Malone.
 
Back
Top