we won't be making the 'same mistake'.
The mistake we (well, JFJ and then Burke) made was they spent big $$ on goalies who's the farthest from a sure thing.
JFJ traded Rask for Raycroft, gambling the 26 year old Raycroft could rebound from a poor sophomore season into Calder form. That never happened. Worse, he gave him a big contract before Raycroft even proved anything, and eventually we had to buy him out. This trade basically killed JFJ's career as a GM.
Next thing JFJ did, to 'fix' the problem with Raycroft, he signed Toskala to a big contract. Toskala was a career backup but momentarily stole the #1 job from Nabokov when he had a hot run, and JFJ gambled the hot run was the "real" toskala, and that the backup would have no problem maintaining those good numbers when he takes on a full time load. Of course we all know how that panned out.
Then came Burke. I can't call it a bad trade, because he DID rid Blake and Toskala's contract. However, when he anointed Giguere and Gustavsson as the tandem for the 10/11 season, he was again counting on Giguere rebounding from what was then 2 year of subpar goaltending. He was hoping that reuniting him with Allaire would rebound Giguere's career. He was also hoping Gustavsson could improve on his inconsistent rookie season. Neither happened, and Burke lost both gambles.
All 3 decisions are gambles. Signing a Vokoun or Bryzgalov won't be any gamble. You can't even compare these moves.
We're all poopin our pants because the Leafs are so close to the 8th spot right now.
But more likely than not, Burke didn't expect to challenge for anything this year (he's said many times that he doesn't want to get destroyed in the first round).
This was a transition year, one in which we weren't gonna win the Cup. Perfect time to have Giguere provide veteran leadership and stability while your ace in the wings Gus acclimates and becomes your number 1. All ready for next season and competing.
But there was a hitch in the plans. Gus sucked and Giguere is proving to be finished. Yet in comes Reimer and actually has us close to the 8th spot - something they didn't expect.
It wasn't "dumb" to have Giguere and Gus as the tandem this year. Gus was supposed to be the goalie of the future. Giggs was supposed to be a one year stop gap. Reimer simply emerged without anyone expecting it - maybe it took a little long for them to hand the reigns to him, but they ultimately did it.
And now we're in a fantastic position where we can go into next season with Reimer as our #1, Gus with another shot to prove himself, Giguere's $6M freed up, and Scrivens and Rynnas the tandem on the Marlies.
Beautiful. AND no Jason Blake. How can anyone argue with how it turned out going into next season, the season that actually matters?
Waiving Giggy and going with Reimer from day one, without the benefit of retrospect, would've not only been a total waste of $6M in waived but paid money, but also a huge risk in relying on Reimer and Gus as a tandem, with their being totally inexperienced. Most reasonable observers would've considered that to most likely be a recipe for last overall.
I mean, whatever. If we make the playoffs regardless, it all went flawlessly because we're rid of Blake. If not, we have $6M to spend on a big time player (Richards? Stastny?) this offseason. "But imagine what coulda been" - don't bother, I'll tell you, most likely a first round exit.