• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

No way you bring in a guy like Nash who does NOTHING except produce a few points here and there. He is a nice player, but he would piss off all the guys who are really starting to buy into the fast and truculent image of the new look leafs.

We traded two good players who didn't fit the philosophy(Versteeg and Kaberle) and the team actually got better. Nash would be a MAJOR step backward. Major.

Ya gotta understand team/dressing room dynamics.
 
I think we could put together a pretty good package for any star player without having to part with Kadri... Colborne, Gardiner, two first rounders, McKegg, Blacker, D'amigo, Ross, one of our young goalies, etc. Lots to choose from and enough depth to give up a good package pretty comfortably I think.

If Burke's intention is to bring in a 1st line talent (which it should be), he's likely going to have to make a trade. Because unless he signs Richards, there's nothing but 2nd/3rd line talents available in free agency.
 
If Columbus was going to blow things up, I'm not sure why Rick Nash is the first place they'd want to start. But I wouldn't be interested in parting with Kadri in a deal for Nash either. For all of the hype around Nash as a player, he's a 60-70 point player who's getting paid like an elite 80-90 point producer (7.8M per season) for the next seven years. I wouldn't be enthusiastic about the Leafs signing him as a UFA to that contract, let alone giving up a blue chipper like Kadri for the privilege of absorbing that contract from the Blue Jackets.
 
Ideally, I'd like to keep Kadri -- but he's probably the first guy they would ask for because he's young, cheap, NHL ready and he has 1st line potential.

If we could get him for a combination of players like Schenn, Kulemin, draft picks (or something like that) -- I think I would do it. A line of Nash/Kadri/Kessel would be absolutely sick.

the only way i'd trade schenn is for a legitimate star.

nobody's talking about it, but he has now eclipsed 20 points. that isn't an outstanding total, but there's an important factor to take into consideration: he hasn't posted a single point on the powerplay.

now, that might be a little bit concerning because he has gotten enough powerplay time this season to have posted a few points here and there. but i can't say i'm too concerned, because the leafs powerplay has been awful. phaneuf has 3 G 9 A on the pp. but all three of those goals and 5 of those assists have come since february.

in other words... even phaneuf, a former 20 G, 60 pt defenceman, has struggled to produce on the leafs' pp.

we're looking at a 21 year old who has clear 5-10 goal, 30 point potential, who is arguably the most physical defenseman in hockey.

i'd be very hard pressed to trade that guy.



though i do admit i didn't really take kulemin into account. he might be a decent anchor. i don't think guys like colborne and d'amigo would be awfully interesting to columbus, though, to be perfectly honest. those are just filler pieces, imo.
 
Again, No way does Columbus move their franchise player for Kadri. Don't do drugs. Stay in School.

i just posted a whole bunch of trades involving players who are all better than nash, none of whom netted the team trading that player a good young player, let alone a good young player with kadri's talents.

stop saying 'no way does columbus move their franchise player for kadri.'

boston traded their franchise player for a lot less.

ottawa traded their franchise player for a lot less (in fact, you could multiply that by 2 if we include havlat).

atlanta traded their franchise player for a lot less.

tampa traded their franchise player for a lot less.

people have to rid themselves of the notion that star players net star returns.

they usually get traded for depth these days.

and the funny thing with nash is that he really isn't much of a franchise player.
 
Meh, just because he doesn't pick up pointless secondary assists to inflate his point totals like a lot of players doesn't detract from the fact that Nash is an elite goal-scorer. He'd be an absolute demi-God in this city that's for certain.
 
I have not seen him play much because he plays in Columbus but in the for that Gold metal team he was one of if not our best forward during the tournament IMO. I would not trade Kadri for him as i see kadri as the idea C for him and kessel.

I would not hesitate to give up a package of Mac/Kuly + 1st + Blacker/Gardnier ++
 
I wouldn't part with Kuley. To me he's a guy who can be part of a championship team. The guy just does it all so well and so consistently
 
I have not seen him play much because he plays in Columbus but in the for that Gold metal team he was one of if not our best forward during the tournament IMO. I would not trade Kadri for him as i see kadri as the idea C for him and kessel.

I would not hesitate to give up a package of Mac/Kuly + 1st + Blacker/Gardnier ++

That's not surprising at all though. Nash is a complete STUD for Team Canada at the international level. He always turns in a great performance.
 
To me the guy thrives when pressure is on him to produce. Columbus is a small market with little attention paid to it, in Toronto he would thrive IMO.
 
To me the guy thrives when pressure is on him to produce. Columbus is a small market with little attention paid to it, in Toronto he would thrive IMO.

and yet he has just 1 goal in 4 career playoff games... and couldn't even prevent a sweep.

that's a huge assumption to make, with little to back it up.

he's been great internationally... at the world championships, where he has dominated. but i wouldn't exactly say the 'pressure was on' in those tournaments. i mean in 7 or 8 years out 10 canada's team is just ridiculous better than practically all the others.

i'm not saying i'm totally against bringing aboard nash. but he isn't a guy i'd throw away assets to get.

if you can get him by peddling a second liner like mac or kulemin plus a collection of picks and B-list prospects then great.

but i would simply have zero interest in trading a youngster like kadri to get him. i think kadri has the potential to be a flat out better player.
 
anytime you give a player the benfit of the doubt and think he will perform better once he gets traded ... well, that almost never happens.

People thought Olli Jokinen was a great player caught in a bad situation and he would perform better once traded to a better team ... that didn't happen.

People thought Paul Martin suffered offensively because he played for a trap team, and he'd be a 40-50 points guy on an offensive team ... that didn't happen, even though he played for the Pens.

People thought Horton would see a huge jump in points once he's been traded out of florida and again, that didn't happen.

So we're to believe Nash would be a 80-90 points guy because he'll be 'motivated' in Toronto? I don't buy that at all.

anytime people use Olympics performance or worse, WJHC performance as reason to bring a guy over, I'd be VERY, VERY concerned.
 
Nash is exactly the type of piece that this team needs ... unfortunately, it is his contract that takes away the luster of his presence.
Wouldnt trade Kadri for Nash ... are you nuts? One is a bonafide star, the other is having a hard time trying to make a non playoff club.
Columbus would want both first rounders and kadri and Macarther ...... funny /// but to the comment that "he has only 1 goal in 4 playoff games" when you play with the stiffs he has had to endure ... making the playoffs was a feat in itself.
Nash - Richards - Kessel ........ ya, who wouldnt want that line on their team.
 
Ok, so i know were not always suppose to "look at the stats" when evaluating trades. But i just have to here to some degree.

So people here are thinking we should, or it would take the following package to get Nash?
Kadri - Played at a 67pt pace since his callup.
Mac - 61 pts to date
Gardiner - It sounds like we got a gem in the beauch trade who has excellent speed. When's the last time we had pure speed on the back end?
1st - Well this is a long debate in itself, but theres no question it has value the way we have been drafting lately.

FOR

Nash - Sitting at 66 pts.

That seems just a tad lopsided to me. So okay, if you want to look at goals, Nash still only has 32 goals this year, of which, we have three guys hovering around that mark, who all three could arguably improve of their numbers due to age and obvious progression in recent seasons.

Not to mention the fact that, as someone mentioned, Kadri could turn out to be plain and simply better than Nash.

I think a lot of people get caught up on the name Nash, and don't realize that we could get fleeced in such a trade.
 
If Columbus is serious about a franchise turnaround, they need to look no further than their scouts and management.

10 top ten picks, with another one on the way and Rick Nash is the only one that is having any impact on their roster.

Since inception, a list of first round picks:

Rusty Klesla (2000, #4) traded at the deadline for Upshall/Lepisto
Pascal Leclaire (2001, #8) traded for Vermette
Rick Nash (2002, #1)
Nik Zherdev (2003, #4) traded for Tyutin
Alex Picard (2004, #8) traded for Kolarik
Gilbert Brule (2005, #6) traded for Torres
Derrick Brassard (2006, #6)
Jakub Voracek (2007, #7)
Nikita Filatov (2008, #6)
John Moore (2009, #21)
Ryan Johansen (2010, #4)

The Jackets have some nice pieces, but haven't the budget to really fill out a playoff roster IMO. They suffered with incompetent management early on, took too many risks at the draft and never really built the foundation that a team needs to compete in this league.

As of today, they are a loser squad that can't afford or attract free agents. They need to build competently through the draft, and hire a GM who can wheel and deal.
 
Last edited:
Nash is exactly the type of piece that this team needs ... unfortunately, it is his contract that takes away the luster of his presence.
Wouldnt trade Kadri for Nash ... are you nuts? One is a bonafide star, the other is having a hard time trying to make a non playoff club.
Columbus would want both first rounders and kadri and Macarther .......

here we go, again. another person who makes assumptions of trade value based not on what players are actually traded for, but their own ideas.

not one of heatley, thornton, kovalchuk, hossa, or richards was traded for a young player as good as kadri. not one of them. and yet, we are to believe that rick nash would net that despite the fact that he is the worst player of that group.

and as if kadri's struggles as a rookie mean anything.

Rick Nash's rookie season:

74 GP 17 G 22 A 39 Pts

Nazem Kadri's rookie pace, over 74 games:

74 GP 9 G 26 A 35 Pts

WE'RE DOOMED BECAUSE KADRI ISN'T PUTTING UP BIG POINTS IN 12 MINUTES A GAME WITH JOEY CRABB AND DARRYL BOYCE!!!!!!!!


kadri's going to be a hell of a player. he is going to be at least as productive as nash, and will be a much more complete hockey player. no question in my mind.

funny /// but to the comment that "he has only 1 goal in 4 playoff games" when you play with the stiffs he has had to endure ... making the playoffs was a feat in itself.

should we give him a chocolate bar for that?

the argument was that he rises to the occasion. he's yet to show that, outside of some big time performances at the second rate world championships.

how about this? 13 GP 2 G 4 A 6 Pts at the olympics.

there is this crazy assumption that nash is going to suddenly become better once he leaves columbus. but that isn't based on reality -- like #17 said, it's assumed of just about everybody on a bad team and it never turns out to be the case. ever.

Nash - Richards - Kessel ........ ya, who wouldnt want that line on their team

just about everybody would. but that's besides the point.
 
Back
Top