• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I can give you a long list of players who were 30-40 goal guys but then had their huge years with elite playmaking linemates.

most of these guys did it regardless of their linemates

Alexander Mogilny

a one year spike. other than that one year, he put up 50 goal seasons whether he was playing with puck hogs (Bure) or 2nd/3rd liners (Brylin/Gomez)

Teemu Selanne

his best year was without an 'elite playmaking linemate.'

Brett Hull

sure, but it was 25 years ago and he was playing alongside a guy who fininshed his career with 1100 assists.

Brendan Shanahan

he followed up a 44 goal season alongside andrew cassels with a 46 goal season alongside steve yzerman

so... nope.

Ilya Kovalchuk

please. career high was without a set up man, too.

Dany Heatley

and yet his production has fallen playing alongside the best set up man he has ever played with

Marian Hossa

he's pretty much always played with an elite player

Daniel Alfredsson

Cam Neely

neely was a 50 goal scorer with craig janney centering him.

he might have done it two years earlier (42 points in 69 games) wtih ken linesman at centre.

i guess you could say oates had that impact. but again.. 1100 assists.

if your argument is that playing with one of hte best setup men ever is what helped him score then fine. we'll never know if he would have done it without them.

but (1) outside of sedin and thornton (and i guess crosby) nobody in the league is as adept a set up man as adam oates was

(2) even with those three in mind, it didn't do a whole lot to help out heatley and kunitz

John LeClair

leclaire managed just fine whenever lindros was out... just look at his 97-98 and 99-00 numbers, where lindros missed siginficant time to injury.
 
what's also interesting is that a whole whack of guys that you listed saw their production spike in 92-93 and 93-94, which were, i think (league wide) the two highest scoring seasons ever (or had the most 100 point scoresr or something like that).

neely, andreychuk, clark, selanne, mogilny, etc. etc.
 
most of these guys did it regardless of their linemates



a one year spike. other than that one year, he put up 50 goal seasons whether he was playing with puck hogs (Bure) or 2nd/3rd liners (Brylin/Gomez)

Wrong.

A one year spike due to Lafontaine being there for him.
A second spike due to Bure being injured.
A third spike when he was with a pass-first centre (Gomez) and a playmaker on the other side (Sykora) who combined for 95 assists.

his best year was without an 'elite playmaking linemate.'

Zhamnov and Steen were no slouches when it come to being playmakers.

sure, but it was 25 years ago and he was playing alongside a guy who fininshed his career with 1100 assists.

Then tailed off gradually until Mike Modano and back up to 39. And then 37 in Detroit.

he followed up a 44 goal season alongside andrew cassels with a 46 goal season alongside steve yzerman

so... nope.

Cassels was a pretty good set-up man. He propelled Sanderson to a 46 goal year himself.

Add to that previously his spikes were from playing on a line with Brett Hull and Craig Janney (who you tremendously underrate, but we'll get to that).

please. career high was without a set up man, too.

Technical career high was with Savard. When he matched that he played with Hossa, Kozlov, Recchi, and White. So 1 star, 2 good players (at the time) and a mediocre one.

and yet his production has fallen playing alongside the best set up man he has ever played with

I see that as the law of diminishing returns. But even if you disagree, it doesn't always pan out.

he's pretty much always played with an elite player

Agreed.

neely was a 50 goal scorer with craig janney centering him.

he might have done it two years earlier (42 points in 69 games) wtih ken linesman at centre.

i guess you could say oates had that impact. but again.. 1100 assists.

You tremendously underrate Janney. The guy was a PPG player, who was a PURE pass-first guy. Reassess that one.

if your argument is that playing with one of hte best setup men ever is what helped him score then fine. we'll never know if he would have done it without them.

but (1) outside of sedin and thornton (and i guess crosby) nobody in the league is as adept a set up man as adam oates was

(2) even with those three in mind, it didn't do a whole lot to help out heatley and kunitz

I don't think Kunitz is all that good to be fair. Overrated at its finest. And I touched on my Heatley thoughts.

leclaire managed just fine whenever lindros was out... just look at his 97-98 and 99-00 numbers, where lindros missed siginficant time to injury.

You mean when Brind'Amour and Recchi stepped in? And Lindros didn't miss all that much time in either season to have drastic results.

That was a whole lot of fluff from you. You can do better.
 
what's also interesting is that a whole whack of guys that you listed saw their production spike in 92-93 and 93-94, which were, i think (league wide) the two highest scoring seasons ever (or had the most 100 point scoresr or something like that).

neely, andreychuk, clark, selanne, mogilny, etc. etc.

Neely spiked with Oates and Janney
Andreychuk with Gilmour
Clark with Gilmour
Selanne with Kariya and McDonald
Mogilny with Linden and then Gomez
Kovalchuk with Savard and Hossa/Kozlov/Recchi
Shanahan with Janney, Cassels, Yzerman
Lecavalier with St. Louis
LeClair with Lindros
Kovalev with Jagr
Stevens with Lemieux

You rarely see a guy score large amounts of goals without a quality disher.

You can add Alexei Yashin to the list who had no help and got 40. Scary stuff there.
 
Neely spiked with Oates and Janney

Janney kind of sucked. Sure, he had 100 point years. So did Joe Juneau. Janney was not an elite anything. He was a second line centre. Janney put up points because he got to play with Neely and Hull when they were in their primes. I'll grant you that Oates seemed to bring out the best in those two. But you're really reaching there. If you want to say that Nash would put up more points playing with Crosby then you may well be right. Though it's worth noting (once again) that playing with Thornton hasn't helped Heatley at all (you could argue it has hurt him). So it is far from a foregone conclusion and has more to do with chemistry than talent.

Look no farther than Kessel enjoying more success playing with Joey Crabb than Kris Versteeg.

Andreychuk with Gilmour

Andreychuk was playing at a 47 goal pace before the trade. He finished the season with 54. He scored 53 the following season. It might have had a marginal effect.

Clark with Gilmour

Clark didn't play on a line with Gilmour

Selanne with Kariya and McDonald

(1) Selanne 'peaked' with Zhamnov. His best season was with Zhamnov.

And McDonald? Seriously?

Mogilny with Linden and then Gomez

Linden and Gomez? Are you kidding? These are second liners. Mogilny did more to help Gomez and Linden than they did to help Mogilny.

Kovalchuk with Savard and Hossa/Kozlov/Recchi

Kozlov and Recchi? Good lord.

Shanahan with Janney, Cassels, Yzerman

Cassels?

Lecavalier with St. Louis

lecavalier has played with st louis before and after those two huge seasons, without the same effect

LeClair with Lindros

lindros's injuries very conveniently poitn to the fact that leclaire was just as good without lindros as he was with him

Kovalev with Jagr

they didn't play together

Stevens with Lemieux

kevin stevens got to play on a line with probably the two best players in the league, in the highest scoring season ever.
 
and really, you're getting off point.

the question isn't whether what these guys did with another elite player. it's what they did without them.

a couple of guys benefited from playing with oates. stevens benefited from playing with jagr and lemieux.

but (1) two players finding chemistry is far from a guarantee (it's why sundin and mogilny never really played on the same line -- they were no better or more productive together than apart).

(2) the fact that you included names like linden, gomez, janney, cassels, really undermines your position.

those guys were at best second liners. if anything, it's an inverse effect: their numbers were boosted because they got to play with some damn good players. some of the most talented players ever.

and the point about a lot of those guys is that they did it on multiple teams with varying quality of linemates.

mogilny scored nearly 80 points in 02-03 on a line with a 40 point centre and 35 point winger (reichel and tucker). only 5 of is 33 goals were scored on the pp.

leclaire scored 50 in 97-98 despite lindros missing 20 games.

shanahan scored as many goals alongside cassels as he did alongside yzerman.

selanne scored more goals playing on a line with mcdonald than he did playing on a line with forsberg (for half a seaosn, at least).
 
Aren't you a Leafs fan??

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendel_Clark

While Clark was known for grit and physical play (amassing 1,690 career penalty minutes), frequent injuries meant that he played only one full season. Nonetheless, he did manage an impressive 46 goals in 64 games for the Leafs during the 1993–94 season, playing on a line with Dave Andreychuk and Doug Gilmour. In the playoffs, the Leafs made a second consecutive trip to the Conference Finals, but fell 4–1 to the Vancouver Canucks, who were coached by future Leafs coach Pat Quinn.
 
and really, you're getting off point.

the question isn't whether what these guys did with another elite player. it's what they did without them.

a couple of guys benefited from playing with oates. stevens benefited from playing with jagr and lemieux.

but (1) two players finding chemistry is far from a guarantee (it's why sundin and mogilny never really played on the same line -- they were no better or more productive together than apart).

(2) the fact that you included names like linden, gomez, janney, cassels, really undermines your position.

those guys were at best second liners. if anything, it's an inverse effect: their numbers were boosted because they got to play with some damn good players. some of the most talented players ever.

and the point about a lot of those guys is that they did it on multiple teams with varying quality of linemates.

mogilny scored nearly 80 points in 02-03 on a line with a 40 point centre and 35 point winger (reichel and tucker). only 5 of is 33 goals were scored on the pp.

leclaire scored 50 in 97-98 despite lindros missing 20 games.

shanahan scored as many goals alongside cassels as he did alongside yzerman.

selanne scored more goals playing on a line with mcdonald than he did playing on a line with forsberg (for half a seaosn, at least).

One of the best scenarios a goal-scoring winger can have is a pass-first centre.

Janney - 751 pts, 75% of which were assists
Cassels - 732 pts, 72% assists
Gomez - 674 pts, 75% assists


Or productive guys their whole career like:
Recchi - 1500 pts
Kozlov - 850 pts
Linden - 850 pts
Steen and Zhamnov - 800 and 700 pts


Situationally they become great linemates for a scoring winger. Like Rick Nash has never had.
 
One of the best scenarios a goal-scoring winger can have is a pass-first centre.

Janney - 751 pts, 75% of which were assists
Cassels - 732 pts, 72% assists
Gomez - 674 pts, 75% assists


Or productive guys their whole career like:
Recchi - 1500 pts
Kozlov - 850 pts
Linden - 850 pts
Steen and Zhamnov - 800 and 700 pts


Situationally they become great linemates for a scoring winger. Like Rick Nash has never had.

kozlov, linden, steen, janney, cassels and gomez are no better than the supporting casts that rick nash has had.
 
And furthermore, Kovalev did play with Straka and Jagr prior to Mario's return. Hence why he was termed a C/RW for a period of time.

him and straka occasionally played centre.

that wasn't a line.

kovalev's big season was spent playing with straka and lang for the vast majority of the season.
 
And when Mogilny was with Sundin they were tearing it up to start 2002-03, but there wasn't enough production coming from the other lines, so Quinn bounced them around a lot.

First it was Tucker - Sundin - Mogilny. But we started the year 2-6-1.

So Tucker and Renberg got swapped. Then Quinn would shuffle the guys around regularly.

Again, the law of diminishing returns. That line was ridiculous to start the year, but we would have cost ourselves a playoff spot keeping it together.
 
Yes they are. Nash has never had a pass-first centre in his prime.

In fact, if any of the guys Nash has played with hit 600 pts I'll be shocked.

linden, steen, janney and cassels played in the highest scoring era . their stats are massively inflated when you compare them to guys who play now.
 
And when Mogilny was with Sundin they were tearing it up to start 2002-03, but there wasn't enough production coming from the other lines, so Quinn bounced them around a lot.

First it was Tucker - Sundin - Mogilny. But we started the year 2-6-1.

So Tucker and Renberg got swapped. Then Quinn would shuffle the guys around regularly.

Again, the law of diminishing returns. That line was ridiculous to start the year, but we would have cost ourselves a playoff spot keeping it together.

the law of diminshing returns, aka 'their starting goaltender broke his hand in the first game of the season and their backup surrendered 14 goals in 4 games'
 

Well if those players have inflated stats, then the guys who scored the goals have inflated stats.

The fact that Rick Nash will probably get to 600 goals before it's all said and done has to be applauded that much more. At very least, I would say he ends up in the top-50 goal-scorers all-time. and that would be playing in Columbus at this pace for the rest of his career.
 
what is the orginal argument?

nash being better with a better centre?
or nash being overrated?
 
Heh. Nah Nash isn't overrated at all. He's just a 70 point player who only isn't performing up to his true talent level because he plays all by himself, and will surely go down as one of the greatest scorers in the history of the game.

You aren't doing yourself any favours here bud.
 
Back
Top