mbow30
Spudmeister Supreme
I can give you a long list of players who were 30-40 goal guys but then had their huge years with elite playmaking linemates.
most of these guys did it regardless of their linemates
Alexander Mogilny
a one year spike. other than that one year, he put up 50 goal seasons whether he was playing with puck hogs (Bure) or 2nd/3rd liners (Brylin/Gomez)
Teemu Selanne
his best year was without an 'elite playmaking linemate.'
Brett Hull
sure, but it was 25 years ago and he was playing alongside a guy who fininshed his career with 1100 assists.
Brendan Shanahan
he followed up a 44 goal season alongside andrew cassels with a 46 goal season alongside steve yzerman
so... nope.
Ilya Kovalchuk
please. career high was without a set up man, too.
Dany Heatley
and yet his production has fallen playing alongside the best set up man he has ever played with
Marian Hossa
he's pretty much always played with an elite player
Daniel Alfredsson
Cam Neely
neely was a 50 goal scorer with craig janney centering him.
he might have done it two years earlier (42 points in 69 games) wtih ken linesman at centre.
i guess you could say oates had that impact. but again.. 1100 assists.
if your argument is that playing with one of hte best setup men ever is what helped him score then fine. we'll never know if he would have done it without them.
but (1) outside of sedin and thornton (and i guess crosby) nobody in the league is as adept a set up man as adam oates was
(2) even with those three in mind, it didn't do a whole lot to help out heatley and kunitz
John LeClair
leclaire managed just fine whenever lindros was out... just look at his 97-98 and 99-00 numbers, where lindros missed siginficant time to injury.