• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

what is the orginal argument?

nash being better with a better centre?
or nash being overrated?
Well, one sort of leads into the other. gilmour93forever thinks that Nash is actually a 45 goal/80 point player if only he moves to a better team/gets better linemates than what he's got Columbus. And then everybody else pointed out that this kind of thinking is exactly what makes the 35 goal/65 point Nash one of the most overrated players in the league.
 
You can't claim he's over-rated because he has higher potential in a different situation. Instead you should see the value in his current production based on where he is. You're short-sightedness isn't doing you any favours.

If that was the case we wouldn't need to get a Brad Richards to help out Kessel.
 
We don't need Brad Richards to help out Phil Kessel.

We need Brad Richards because we don't have a legit front line offensive player, and Tyler Bozak is the first line centre. We need Brad Richards to help out the Toronto Maple Leafs, not to turn Phil Kessel into something better than he actually is.
 
Maybe he is. At this point he certainly is. Hopefully he can mature as a player, and get rid of those stupid slumps and stop playing like a pussy. He's still pretty young, so I'm holding out hope, but that has nothing to do with Brad Richards.

They need a guy like Brad Richards no matter what kind of player Phil Kessel is.
 
Maybe he is. At this point he certainly is. Hopefully he can mature as a player, and get rid of those stupid slumps and stop playing like a pussy. He's still pretty young, so I'm holding out hope, but that has nothing to do with Brad Richards.

They need a guy like Brad Richards no matter what kind of player Phil Kessel is.

That's a foolish thing to say though. In that case, Columbus needs a Brad Richards type guy too.

And if you don't expect Kessel to score more next year with a guy like Richards around that's just silly. In fact, if Kessel's production doesn't improve with a top-line centre I think there will be a whole lot of disappointed fans in Leafland.

And like I said Nash put together a four-month stretch playing 43/84 hockey.
 
No its not a foolish thing to say. Its the truth. Kessel is a 30 goal 65 point guy right now. Nothing more. He's also only 23 though.

The Leafs need for Brad Richards has nothing to do with Phil Kessel and everything to do with them not having a first line centre.

And who cares how well a guy plays for 4 months. Every player in the league has hot and cold streaks.

And yeah, Columbus also needs a first line centre. Are you suggesting the don't?
 
So Phil Kessel is a 30-35/65 guy?

At minimum.

Kessel's numbers with Savard, by the way, include him only playing 16 minutes and change in that 36 goal season. Without a lot of powerplay time, to boot. If you extrapolate his 21 year old season playing with an elite offensive centre to the minutes he gets with the Leafs, his production would rise about 16%. That works out to 42 goals and 70 points in the 70 games he played that year.

Unless you think he has gotten less skilled since then, I see no reason not to predict a nice rise in Kessel's numbers should Burke be successful at acquiring (for example) Richards.

Only a small handful of NHLers have scored 30 or more goals 3 seasons in a row, and at 23 Kessel is the youngest. This year he did it with an absolute black hole at centre and for most of the year.
 
I like to think his totals will improve with a better center, but a lot of Kessel's goals are complete solo efforts. He's clearly at his best when he's booking full speed into the offensive zone.
 
Well if those players have inflated stats, then the guys who scored the goals have inflated stats.
.

it's a relative argument. you can't compare 80 points in 92-93 to 80 points in 2010-2011.

just like you can't compare 50 goals in 92-93 to 50 goals in 2010-2011.
 
So do you think we could get him for Kadri? My contention is that Columbus would laugh at that offer.

IF Columbus ever traded Nash, they would first entertain offers for proven scorers or high-end puck-moving defencemen.

Otherwise it would be the highest available picks/prospects.

Kadri wouldn't be laughed at if it came to scenario #2.

I still think the Sens should consider flipping their pick this season ++ if he's available. Exactly what that team needs.
 
I like Nash, but PEOPLE, to be a great offensive player, who gets 40 plus goals, you pretty well gotta CHEAT on defence. Wayne Gretzky was the greatest cheater of all time and has never been called out for it. Wendel Clark and Rick Vaive may have been the worst defensive players of all time.

So when you discuss any possible player for Toronto/Burke, the player has to be YOUNG, CHEAP and responsible defensively. Nash is okay defensively. He ain't cheap AND Young. Burke will go expensive if the other two are checks. I don't think he will chase Brad Richards all that hard. That is Brian Burke smoke and mirrors.

Unless he thinks Richards is okay physically and can go hard for another five years. HARD. Because if he cannot, he is a bit time DRAG on a salary cap team.
 
At minimum.

Kessel's numbers with Savard, by the way, include him only playing 16 minutes and change in that 36 goal season. Without a lot of powerplay time, to boot. If you extrapolate his 21 year old season playing with an elite offensive centre to the minutes he gets with the Leafs, his production would rise about 16%. That works out to 42 goals and 70 points in the 70 games he played that year.

Unless you think he has gotten less skilled since then, I see no reason not to predict a nice rise in Kessel's numbers should Burke be successful at acquiring (for example) Richards.

Being on a bad PP is the same as not getting the chance to be on a good one. Kessel has similar PP stats that year to Nash this year.

Only a small handful of NHLers have scored 30 or more goals 3 seasons in a row, and at 23 Kessel is the youngest. This year he did it with an absolute black hole at centre and for most of the year.

Incorrect.

Alex Ovechkin did it at 21. Staal did it by 22.
Kovalchuk did it 4 times by 23 and missed a season to the lockout (and 'on pace' would have him in at 5).
If you want to work at 'on pace' both Crosby and Nash would have done it more than 3 times.
Bobby Ryan barely made it scoring 32 goals before his birthday in March.
And Steven Stamkos will most likely accomplish the same thing next year.

That wasn't even close to being right.
 
I like to think his totals will improve with a better center, but a lot of Kessel's goals are complete solo efforts. He's clearly at his best when he's booking full speed into the offensive zone.

Or hiding on the defense and find the weak spots. I would like to think Nash's would improve likewise.

[video=youtube;fllWQjnXdfY]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fllWQjnXdfY[/video]

Look at goal #8 who Nash is pulling away from.

His total package is just way too nice. Size, speed, hands. Like I said, he would be a god in this city.
 
Being on a bad PP is the same as not getting the chance to be on a good one. Kessel has similar PP stats that year to Nash this year.

Exactly.

With Richards or a #1 centre in the mix, I daresay our powerplay would be significantly improved.

Incorrect.

Alex Ovechkin did it at 21. Staal did it by 22.
Kovalchuk did it 4 times by 23 and missed a season to the lockout (and 'on pace' would have him in at 5).
If you want to work at 'on pace' both Crosby and Nash would have done it more than 3 times.
Bobby Ryan barely made it scoring 32 goals before his birthday in March.
And Steven Stamkos will most likely accomplish the same thing next year.

That wasn't even close to being right.

I meant in the last 3 seasons. A little thought should have made you realize I couldn't possibly have meant all time.
 
I like Nash, but PEOPLE, to be a great offensive player, who gets 40 plus goals, you pretty well gotta CHEAT on defence. Wayne Gretzky was the greatest cheater of all time and has never been called out for it. Wendel Clark and Rick Vaive may have been the worst defensive players of all time.

So when you discuss any possible player for Toronto/Burke, the player has to be YOUNG, CHEAP and responsible defensively. Nash is okay defensively. He ain't cheap AND Young. Burke will go expensive if the other two are checks. I don't think he will chase Brad Richards all that hard. That is Brian Burke smoke and mirrors.

Unless he thinks Richards is okay physically and can go hard for another five years. HARD. Because if he cannot, he is a bit time DRAG on a salary cap team.

That would be the major caveat that I see in terms of making a trade.

But if Burke even got a sniff at Rick Nash I think he would jump in a second and figure the rest out later.

Total package player.
 
My best bud is a real Rick Nash fanboy, and I used to think it was BS. The more I watch him though, he really is a spectacular talent.
 
Back
Top