• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Well that's not true at all now is it?

Hah? Kulemin put up some good numbers. The most underrated player in the NHL. If he was Canadian, hit just a little more and spat up beer on the ice between shifts, this guy would be sought after like crazy.

And Kadri being offered AS WELL???? Well I gotta tell you, it really tells you that once again, Leaf fans(myself included) are very much overrating Mr. Kadri.

Simmonds is a third liner now, so what does that say about Kadri?
 
I think they were the 1-2 punch in Holmgren's mind when he signed them, but I think it also became pretty clear that Giroux-Briere was the real 1-2 punch on that team now.

The Flyers didn't trade their 1-2 centre punch from last year - they just traded their #3 centre and #1 winger.
 
This was a deal organized by the Snider family who were puked out at Richards and Carter getting party time during a 4-0 drubbing by the Bruins.

And when Philly signs Brad Richards who is better than Richards M. and Carter combined, this deal will signify a Stanley Cup most likely. Let the good times roll in Philly.

Kulemin who is as good as M. Richards was offered AND Kadri for M. Richards. Which I think is overpayment. And we STILL got turned down.

That shows what OTHER TEAMS think of Kadri as well as Burke/Nonis. NOT FREAKING MUCH.

They. Don't. Have. The. Cap. Space.
 
Hah? Kulemin put up some good numbers. The most underrated player in the NHL. If he was Canadian, hit just a little more and spat up beer on the ice between shifts, this guy would be sought after like crazy.

And Kadri being offered AS WELL???? Well I gotta tell you, it really tells you that once again, Leaf fans(myself included) are very much overrating Mr. Kadri.

Simmonds is a third liner now, so what does that say about Kadri?

I think the acquisition of Colborne makes Kadri expendable in the teams eyes. I am not saying that Colborne is a good a prospect as him but if anyone is going to help us get a #1 centre in return its going to be Kadri

Burke loves his players to be big and having a skilled 6'5 centre to mold is very intriguing to him
 
I think the acquisition of Colborne makes Kadri expendable in the teams eyes. I am not saying that Colborne is a good a prospect as him but if anyone is going to help us get a #1 centre in return its going to be Kadri

Burke loves his players to be big and having a skilled 6'5 centre to mold is very intriguing to him

of course the ducks' top three scoring forwards in 06-07 were 6', 6' (very generously... kunitz ain't really 6') and 5'10
 
of course the ducks' top three scoring forwards in 06-07 were 6', 6' (very generously... kunitz ain't really 6') and 5'10

And year later his two leading scorers were both 6'3 and 6'4 whom he both drafted. There is no denying his track record with having bigger skilled forwards especially at centre
 
And year later his two leading scorers were both 6'3 and 6'4 whom he both drafted. There is no denying his track record with having bigger skilled forwards especially at centre

that's immaterial, though.

i just hate how burke is super obsessed with size and truculence, and completely ignores how much of his success in anaheim was based around finesse, skill and goaltending.

it also bothers me that in 2.5 years here he still hasn't addressed the whole truculence thing. the team is tougher than it used to be. but they're still not a big, mean team.
 
Voracek has been a little underwhelming, but he has done more at a younger age than either Carter or Richards. Schenn has the bust factor, but we're looking at arguably the best forward prospect in hockey right now.

There is undeniable risk for Philadelphia here. But we have to remember that Voracek and Schenn are both superior prospects than Carter and Richards ever were. Both could bust, but both have upside to be at least as good as Carter and Richards were in their peak seaosns, and quite a bit better than both have been over the past two years. That isn't a given, but then the trades weren't one-for-one swaps.



it makes zero sense to write off the trade from Philly's perspective because of potential and hten overstate the case on Richards and Carter. Likewise, Columbus gave up a potential 50 goal guy, and LA gave up a potential great gritty scoring captain (as for citing the captaincy... that's a huge mark AGAINST Richards. I can't believe how many people are ignoring the fact that Philadelphia just elected to trade its 26 year old captain. That's very telling, imo).

I actually like Richards... Carter is a one dimensional scorer, though, and the gaudy totals from 08-09 look to me to be the result of a flukey first half. From January onwards he scored 19 in 45 (35 goal pace). This was followed by seasons of 33 in 74 (36 goal pace) and 36 in 80 (37 goal pace).

He's a 35ish goal guy who can possibly approach 40.



Yeah, this to me is a mistake. I'm not convinced that Bryzgalov is the answer in net.

It's definitely boom or bust with Philly on this one. They got highly touted guys, who are better prospects than the guys they traded were, but Columbus and LA give up true potential with zero track record and got back guys with a baseline of 30 goals and 60 points who could be (and have been) better than that.

If Schenn become Tlusty 2.0 (and honestly, I haven't seen anything that impressive yet) and Voracek keeps chugging along as a 15 goal guy, these trades are epic, epic busts for Philly.

That said, Philly is in a position to roll the dice because they STILL have Briere and Giroux, so if they lose these deals badly, they haven't thrown away the whole franchise.

All I know is that if I'm Columbus I am ****ing thrilled because no way would I be able to get Carter to sign a relatively cheap ($5M) but long (11 years) and provide 35 goals at the very least per year. And if I'm LA I'm happy beyond words to give up the unfulfilled (so far) promise of Schenn and the way overrated Simmonds for a 26 year old gritty captain who has lots of room to improve. Huge wins for LA and Columbus, and potentially a long term lesser win for Philly (or a huge loss).
 
Yup, I agree with this. Colborne opens up the flexibility to trade Kadri and still have a true C prospect knocking on the door.

colborne doesn't come close to having kadri's potential, though.

i wouldn't be against trading kadri if you could stastny. i'm glad they didn't deal him for either of philadelhpia's guys, though.
 
Hah? Kulemin put up some good numbers. The most underrated player in the NHL. If he was Canadian, hit just a little more and spat up beer on the ice between shifts, this guy would be sought after like crazy.

And Kadri being offered AS WELL???? Well I gotta tell you, it really tells you that once again, Leaf fans(myself included) are very much overrating Mr. Kadri.

Simmonds is a third liner now, so what does that say about Kadri?

Kulemin = the best.
 
colborne doesn't come close to having kadri's potential, though.

i wouldn't be against trading kadri if you could stastny. i'm glad they didn't deal him for either of philadelhpia's guys, though.

I tend to sort of agree, but also not.

Because I think it's still possible that Kadri's talent (which really amounts to a bunch of dangles) doesn't translate to big time success at the NHL level. He may never be anything more than a great shootout guy. He may, but it's still pretty up in the air.

Colborne I've been pretty darn impressed with when I've watched him thus far, moreso than Kadri because he seems to bring a more complete game and should be way more effective once he fills in.

So yeah, JC doesn't have all the sick hands, but overall I think he could be a better player than Kadri.
 
So uhh Pat Morris (B. Richards agent) was on the Fan earlier, and he said some really interesting things. He said that he believes Toronto is a perfect fit, the only thing that they need to discuss is money and term, IF Toronto is interested.

He even said he expects Toronto to meet him face-to-face on July 1st since his office is in Oakville.

It sounds like it may be in Burkie's hands to give him a fat contract. Richards also has made it clear that he would like this to be his last contract so it'll be long-term. It would be nice to have a GM willing to give those crazy cap-circumventing long-term deals.. Burke said he would go over 5 years for the right player, but he would not do those contracts.. so annoying.

But yea, it certainly sounds like the highest bidder may be the winner in the end.
 
So uhh Pat Morris (B. Richards agent) was on the Fan earlier, and he said some really interesting things. He said that he believes Toronto is a perfect fit, the only thing that they need to discuss is money and term, IF Toronto is interested.

He even said he expects Toronto to meet him face-to-face on July 1st since his office is in Oakville.

Tamper-tastic stuff, seeing as to he's still a Star until July 1.
 
So uhh Pat Morris (B. Richards agent) was on the Fan earlier, and he said some really interesting things. He said that he believes Toronto is a perfect fit, the only thing that they need to discuss is money and term, IF Toronto is interested.

He even said he expects Toronto to meet him face-to-face on July 1st since his office is in Oakville.

Sick, thanks for the update!
 
Back
Top