Voracek has been a little underwhelming, but he has done more at a younger age than either Carter or Richards. Schenn has the bust factor, but we're looking at arguably the best forward prospect in hockey right now.
There is undeniable risk for Philadelphia here. But we have to remember that Voracek and Schenn are both superior prospects than Carter and Richards ever were. Both could bust, but both have upside to be at least as good as Carter and Richards were in their peak seaosns, and quite a bit better than both have been over the past two years. That isn't a given, but then the trades weren't one-for-one swaps.
it makes zero sense to write off the trade from Philly's perspective because of potential and hten overstate the case on Richards and Carter. Likewise, Columbus gave up a potential 50 goal guy, and LA gave up a potential great gritty scoring captain (as for citing the captaincy... that's a huge mark AGAINST Richards. I can't believe how many people are ignoring the fact that Philadelphia just elected to trade its 26 year old captain. That's very telling, imo).
I actually like Richards... Carter is a one dimensional scorer, though, and the gaudy totals from 08-09 look to me to be the result of a flukey first half. From January onwards he scored 19 in 45 (35 goal pace). This was followed by seasons of 33 in 74 (36 goal pace) and 36 in 80 (37 goal pace).
He's a 35ish goal guy who can possibly approach 40.
Yeah, this to me is a mistake. I'm not convinced that Bryzgalov is the answer in net.