• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Would you pay Talbot Armstrong/Laich type money? It would not surprise me if that is what he got.

For 3-4 years at $3-4 million, I would consider it. Like Aberdeen said, its not a big deal for a shorter term.
 
I wouldn't go above $2.5 million to be honest, as much as I like the guy. That money should be allocated in areas of greater importance than a third or fourth-line energy guy, but if we can get him on the relatively cheap scale then I'm all for it.
 
Is Talbot really necessary? We already have Armstrong, and then we've already got Frattin coming up the pipe, who can provide the same amount of agitating presence, with hopefully more offense and on rookie contract to boot. There's even Kadri, who's got a lot of pest him him, though we hope he'll be providing that on the top two lines with a healthy amount of scoring.

And that goes along with what Volc was saying: ideally, your organization develops these 3rd/4th line agitator types themselves, and then when they become too expensive, let someone else overpay them and move the next guy you have coming up into their spot.
 
paying more than $1.5m for Maxime Talbot would be ludicrous, IMO.

Agreed, you don't give Grabo or Kulemin level money to this guy.

I'm not sure I would spend anything on him, to be honest. I prefer giving that third line center spot to Bozak if we sign Richards, so that it's Richards, Grabo, Bozak down the middle.

And if Colborne or Kadri is ready to take the 3rd line C spot, then you bump Bozak down to 4th and there's your center position all sewn up.
 
I would be ok with that line up too.

But at the same time, as ludicrous as it might be, I would bet that Talbot gets $3 plus per season somewhere.
 
may well be. had way better numbers than a shitload of ncaaer who became nhlers at the same age - and most of them didn't bring his physical element.
 
Its because Burke said, even though he loves the AHL, he could see Frattin skipping it.

Still, I wouldn't pencil him in. Bring in good players, fill out the roster, and if kids steal spots all the better.

Enough of this losing shit.
 
What's with all this Frattin on the Leafs talk lately?

Is he an NHLer or something all of a sudden?

From a few days ago...

“I believe that players benefit from spending time in the American Hockey League,” Burke said. “If you look at my track record, I had (all-star) Bobby Ryan, (NHL MVP) Corey Perry, (all-star) Ryan Getzlaf, Dustin Penner. . . I had all of those guys in the American.

“This might be one of the few guys who can skip that stage, because I think coach (Dave) Hakstol did a great job with him at North Dakota. This kid is a big guy with ability. He played one game with us. He had seven shots on goal and he speed-bumped a guy – just totally pancaked a guy with a hit. This guy might be ready to play. He might be ready to skip that step. And that’s very rare for me to even talk about someone doing that.”
 
yeah, not sure how frattin projects offensively but it looks like physically he's ready... and once a player is physically ready to play in the nhl (provided they're capable) then they probably should be playing there. but with an extended look at training camp they might find some deficiencies in his game. we'll see.

like leafman said, worry about putting together a competitive team and then, if a young player steals a spot, worry about it then.
 
So did Stalberg and a lot of other guys.

I'm not penciling him into my lineup just yet.

last I checked Stalberg was an NHLer at Frattin's age after making the jump from NCAA at the same time, and still is an NHLer now.

though Stalberg is yet another NCAAer whose stats paled in comparison to Frattin's, and who doesn't bring the physical element that Frattin does, either.
 
I'm all for improving the team, but I don't see a need to spend money in free agency on third liners, when we've already got the likes of Kadri, Frattin, Bozak, Armstrong, etc all in house.

If you want to improve the third line over and above those listed above, do it by adding talent to the first or second line and slidding a Lupul or MacArthur down.....not by spending cap space on UFA third liners.
 
I'm all for improving the team, but I don't see a need to spend money in free agency on third liners, when we've already got the likes of Kadri, Frattin, Bozak, Armstrong, etc all in house.

If you want to improve the third line over and above those listed above, do it by adding talent to the first and second line and slidding a Lupul or MacArthur down.....not by spending cap space on UFA third liners.

well, yeah, that's the point. i'd rather have to trade a guy like bozak or lupul because frattin stole his spot... than just hand a spot to frattin because he was better than caputi.
 
Age 21

M.Frattin (NCAA): 24gms, 11gls, 19pts (82gms, 38gls, 65pts)
B.Butler (NCAA): 38gms, 9gls, 30pts (82gms, 19gls, 65pts)
T.Bozak (NCAA): 41gms, 18gls, 34pts (82gms, 36gls, 68pts)
V.Stalberg (NCAA): 39gms, 10gls, 23pts (82gms, 21gls, 48pts)

Age 22

M.Frattin (NCAA): 44gms, 36gls, 60pts (82gms, 67gls, 112pts)
B.Butler (NCAA): 39gms, 29gls, 53pts (82gms, 61gls, 111pts)
T.Bozak (NCAA): 19gms, 8gls, 23pts (82gms, 36gls, 99pts)
V.Stalberg (NCAA): 39gms, 24gls, 46pts (82gms, 51gls, 97pts)

Age 23

M.Frattin (NHL): ?
B.Butler (NHL): 36gms, 10gls, 21pts (82gms, 23gls, 48pts)
T.Bozak (NHL): 37gms, 8gls, 27pts (82gms, 18gls, 60pts)
V.Stalberg (NHL): 40gms, 9gls, 14pts (82gms, 19gls, 29pts)


and Frattin is more physically ready for the NHL than any of those guys who spent only half a season in the AHL.
 
Last edited:
well, yeah, that's the point. i'd rather have to trade a guy like bozak or lupul because frattin stole his spot... than just hand a spot to frattin because he was better than caputi.


My point is in reference to people talking about spending money on the likes of Belanger or Talbot for our third line..

I'm more than confident in rolling with the best two of Kadri, Frattin or Bozak...
 
Last edited:
I'm all for improving the team, but I don't see a need to spend money in free agency on third liners, when we've already got the likes of Kadri, Frattin, Bozak, Armstrong, etc all in house.

A guy like Frattin shouldn't really be lumped in there. He's played one NHL game. Frankly after the year he had Bozak probably shouldn't be either.

Just handing guys spots has been a big problem for this team. Yeah its great if you can have a bunch of cheap rookies filling the roster. But they have to earn those spots. And bringing in talent for them to compete with just gives you trade chips for if/when they do earn those spots. There is no negative in it. While there is a ton of negative in holding spots open for rookies and then having them not be ready to be quality NHLers.
 
Back
Top