• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

The much bigger part is fixing the 1st line.

that doesn't mean that you ignore other needs on your team.

especially since there's only one guy on the free agent market... and perhaps only one guy available right now period... who can address that problem.
 
yeah +1 to the guy who thinks that they signed him to a one way contract to play for the marlies.

again, i'm not denying the POSSIBLITY of a player taking that spot away from him but a one way contract means that they fully plan on keeping him on the roster.
 
Who cares if its a one way contract

That only means he will get NHL money playing for the Marlies...oh no, what are we going to do now.
 
that doesn't mean that you ignore other needs on your team.

How is Burkie ignoring the other needs on his team by signing Rosehill? If anything, its a proactive mood, and he has shown that he is being very proactive. Attempting to negotiate with Talbot? Proactive. Reported interest in Upshall? While it isn't confirmed by any means, im going to call his interest here pretty much cemented, which is also proactive.

Burke is not being ignorant. Signing Rosehill is in no way, shape or form a sign that he is.
 
anyways, i'm done debating this.

you guys can support the signing all you want but im' sick and tired of our gm's endless pursuit for 'truculence' which invariably results in him bringing in one fourth line hack after another... while completely ignoring important facts:

(1) you still need some tangible skill on the 4th line. not ppg skill. not even 30 point skill. but you need guys who can handle the puck, work the cycle and chip in with the odd timely goal. he has completely ignored that by bringing aboard one stiff after another with the likes of wallin, sjostrom, orr, brown and now rosehill.

(2) the truculence that wins is the truculence in your top six. sure, it's important to have forwards on yoru bottom lines who can crash and bang.. but just like it's important to have guys in your bottom six who can also contribute some offense to pick up the salck when the first two lines are slumping or tightly checked, it's importnat to have skill guys in the top six who can contribute offense and also play with some muster. burke has no brought in a single offensive forward with any truculence
 
Maybe Im wrong, but I thought free agency started tomorrow. Apparently we missed out all other possible signings already. Damn that Burke
 
anyways, i'm done debating this.

you guys can support the signing all you want but im' sick and tired of our gm's endless pursuit for 'truculence' which invariably results in him bringing in one fourth line hack after another... while completely ignoring important facts:

(1) you still need some tangible skill on the 4th line. not ppg skill. not even 30 point skill. but you need guys who can handle the puck, work the cycle and chip in with the odd timely goal. he has completely ignored that by bringing aboard one stiff after another with the likes of wallin, sjostrom, orr, brown and now rosehill.

(2) the truculence that wins is the truculence in your top six. sure, it's important to have forwards on yoru bottom lines who can crash and bang.. but just like it's important to have guys in your bottom six who can also contribute some offense to pick up the salck when the first two lines are slumping or tightly checked, it's importnat to have skill guys in the top six who can contribute offense and also play with some muster. burke has no brought in a single offensive forward with any truculence

If it is 60k if he plays in the AHL I am okay with this, guess he is there to protect the kids. If he gets it no matter what, then its almost as bad as paying my buddy Darcy Tucker in absentia.

And I will say again, I wouldn't mind a team of 2nd and 3rd liners like Boston with a Schenn like d and a great goalie. Its five on five hockey, you can POUND out wins if you know what you are doing. And Boston basically pounded OUT a better team. And made them look inferior. That is five on five hockey the Conn Smythe way.
 
Thats cool msun.

I think Burke's moves in FA season will have a domino type effect on the lineup. Signing a #1 center (Richards), basically puts Bozak on the 3rd line. If you also add a 4th line center like Talbot, that is a good offensive base in terms of 3rd/4th line production. But assume he doesn't sign Talbot. Kadri is a center. There are a lot of possibilities. Add Upshall to the mix, the possibilities increase even more.

Burke has a top 6 that is a mix of skill and physicality. Some were inherited, others he brought in.

MacA
Grabo
Kulemin
Lupul

All add 'muster' to the top 6. The only one who doesn't is Kessel.

Armstrong, for a 3rd liner, is a perfect fit.
 
How is Burkie ignoring the other needs on his team by signing Rosehill? If anything, its a proactive mood, and he has shown that he is being very proactive. Attempting to negotiate with Talbot? Proactive. Reported interest in Upshall? While it isn't confirmed by any means, im going to call his interest here pretty much cemented, which is also proactive.

you don't make your team better simply by being proactive.

yes, it's important to be 'proactive' but being proactive willonly improve your team if you make good decisions.

so far burke has made some good moves and some good decisions.. and also some bad ones.

as for using my own words against me... not the right context. one instance is concrete (they DID sign rosehill to a one way contract). the other is entirely speculative (and speculated by speculators who have a long history of being completely wrong, at that).

i will say that upshall is a step in the right direction, though. he'd be a good fit. he's exactly the sort of guy i want them to add, although i do worry a bit about dollar amount. still, having a good agitator who can play tough, bang and crash, and contribute 15-20 goals is exactly what i want on the third line.

Burke is not being ignorant. Signing Rosehill is in no way, shape or form a sign that he is.

he is, though. he keeps appealing to the need to add truculence but has managed (in two and a half years) to add just one piece who has actually improved this team's 'truculence' (at least in the sense i think burke uses the word). and he continuously (as i keep saying) ignores its importance in the top six.

there's a big problem when you add joffrey lupul to your lineup and he stands out for his size, and ability to fend off defenders while maintaing possession of the puck.
 
I just hope he gets to replace Orr. He is at least a bit of an upgrade over that guy (offensively anyways). As for being afraid of other players stuff, i only remember a time when we were up by 2-3 goals and the other team tried to get Rosehill to fight and he didn't want to...Sometimes it gets the other team going so i thought it was actually smart. I don't get what the complaining is about..Also stop putting Brown with the other guys..He actually has some skill, the cycle game and all that..just not enough from his line mates to put it all together.
 
nah, brown has no hands and no hockey sense.

he's fine as a 4th liner, but not when you're lining him up opposite rosehill or orr...
 
I agree we need truculence on the top 6, and that's really where we lacked grit last season (got better after Lupul got here) ... we're losing so many loose puck battles, never mind none of our top 6 would intimidate defensemen on their forechecks.

BUT at the same time, I don't see how signing Rosehill at peanuts actually changes the course on that. $600k is nothing and you can have Rosehill in the AHL, or in the NHL when you expect trouble, or when there are injuries. It's a nothing signing.
 
(1)as for using my own words against me... not the right context. one instance is concrete (they DID sign rosehill to a one way contract). the other is entirely speculative (and speculated by speculators who have a long history of being completely wrong, at that).

Again, I disagree. You assume that Rosehill is 'pretty much cemented' into the lineup because he signed a 1 way deal. That is equally as speculative as me stating that the Leafs have interest in Upshall because someone reported it. Seriously, $10 says Rosehill plays less than 30 games for the maple leafs next year.
 
That's not a good comparison. The amount of rumors that turned out to be true makes them statistically insignificant, while the number of players who sign one way contracts that play in the NHL is extremely significant
 
Back
Top