• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

BTW I am all for Carcillo, but I think that Rosehill probably means he will not be in the Blue and White, unfortunately. But hopefully I am proven wrong on that.
 
Carcillo can play i'll give you that..I just wouldn't want that guy because i'd be afraid he would ruin our games with stupid penalties. It just seems like a pattern with that guy.
 
you don't bring genuine toughness if you're scared to drop them with a heavyweight.

useless. he's a bad skater, too.

so now we have orr, brown and rosehill signed for next year. aren't you the guy that always bitches about signing useless hack 4th liners with zero hockey skill?

I couldn't disagree more.

He's a very good skater, and isn't a defensive liability either - he's actually quite responsible in his own zone.

But he's a very good forechecker, which is his strength. Him and Brown together gave us a nice grind line for the first time in forever. On top of that, he's a total gamer who drops them with anyone other than the heaviest of heavyweights.

He was a big upgrade on Orr whenever he was in the lineup last year.

And yes, i'm totally against giving up guaranteed money and draft picks for grinders - but I've got no problem with re-signing our own guy for near league minimum. This isn't giving up draft picks for Hollweg or Mayers here, it isn't giving $1m+ deals to guys like Orr and Primeau and Wallin either.

This $600k deal is the kind of deal which clearly doesn't guarantee him a starting spot, and unlike the Orrs/Wallins/Primeaus/Hollwegs they won't feel any obligation to start this guy in every game unless he's earning it.

Moreover, he wasn't clogging the roster in any way last year, and he won't be clogging the roster in any way this year, either.

Much happier with this signing than giving $1m+ multi-year to a jackass like Carcillo, thus obligating us to keep him in the starting lineup no matter how much he sucks.

Totally happy with this signing.
 
burke has mentioned a few times how people hated playing against his team in anaheim.

the biggest part of that was wronger, who is just miserable to play against. you aren't going to find another pronger. schenn might learn. it's why he brought in komisarek (probaly because of the crosschecking), but that guy's so far gone that he's useless. you won't replicate that.

up front i know that the ducks had some tough guys. but they were miserable to play against because they had guys who were big, played big and mean, at a high pace and who could force defensemen into mistakes and then make them pay for it.

i get that bangers can make defensemen tentative. but nobody finds mike brown and jay rosehill miserable to play against. so they land a few good bumps on the wall a game... the odd time a big hit can c hange the complexion of the game but not often.

i like a guy like carcille (and upshall too -- perhaps even moreso) because they can do that. because they can take a game that is tame, and change everything in a single shift. whether it's with a hit, or even skirting the rules, jumping onto the other team's bench.. whatever. sometimes those guys cross the line (See: ben eager). but those are hte instances that stick out in our minds as casual observers or those teams.

we all saw first hand what having some total pieces of shit can do, and how much it can help you even if they occasionally cross the line and DO somehow hurt the team
 
That's not a good comparison. The amount of rumors that turned out to be true makes them statistically insignificant, while the number of players who sign one way contracts that play in the NHL is extremely significant

Based on the statistics raw statistics alone, yes, it is not a good comparison. I get it, 4/100 rumors come true. 4/100 1 way contracts go to the NHL. (those #'s are in no way accurate, I made them up). Looking at that on paper, its kind of the exact opposite.

So, I apologize. It is not equally as speculative.

Still willing to bet $10.00 that Rosehill plays less than 30 games for the Leafs this year. Want in?
 
Carcillo can play i'll give you that..I just wouldn't want that guy because i'd be afraid he would ruin our games with stupid penalties. It just seems like a pattern with that guy.

this is so overstated it isn't even funny.

i posted the stats.. he took fewer minor penalties than richards and briere.

he really doesn't take a lot of penalties.
 
I couldn't disagree more.

He's a very good skater, and isn't a defensive liability either - he's actually quite responsible in his own zone.

But he's a very good forechecker, which is his strength. Him and Brown together gave us a nice grind line for the first time in forever. On top of that, he's a total gamer who drops them with anyone other than the heaviest of heavyweights.

He was a big upgrade on Orr whenever he was in the lineup last year.

And yes, i'm totally against giving up guaranteed money and draft picks for grinders - but I've got no problem with re-signing our own guy for near league minimum. This isn't giving up draft picks for Hollweg or Mayers here, it isn't giving $1m+ deals to guys like Orr and Primeau and Wallin either.

This $600k deal is the kind of deal which clearly doesn't guarantee him a starting spot, and unlike the Orrs/Wallins/Primeaus/Hollwegs they won't feel any obligation to start this guy in every game unless he's earning it.

Moreover, he wasn't clogging the roster in any way last year, and he won't be clogging the roster in any way this year, either.

Much happier with this signing than giving $1m+ multi-year to a jackass like Carcillo, thus obligating us to keep him in the starting lineup no matter how much he sucks.

Totally happy with this signing.

nah, that rosehill-brent-brown line spent ridiculous amounts of time hemmed in the leafs end. they were brutal. it wasn't until they put the almost as useless sjostrom back on the line (when he returned from injury) that they were decent on the forecheck and able to clear the puck. they coudln't break out.
 
nah, that rosehill-brent-brown line spent ridiculous amounts of time hemmed in the leafs end. they were brutal. it wasn't until they put the almost as useless sjostrom back on the line (when he returned from injury) that they were decent on the forecheck and able to clear the puck. they coudln't break out.

that's totally backwards. they were much better with Rosie there instead of Sjostrom.
 
Lupul - Richards - Kessel
MacA - Grabo - Kulemin
Upshall - Kadri - Army
Brown - Bozak - Rosie/(Orr?)

I like it.
 
I think the key of what you mentioned there is the fact most of us are casual observers...so sometimes we think a player would be of more value to us even though other teams have seen pros and cons and obviously don't think there's enough there. How many times we thought a player coming to the Leafs would make a significant impact and it just didn't happen?
 
Back
Top