• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Is it a matter of who is better, Canadians or Europeans? Is the issue that a team has to be full of one or the other?

No, it's that a Canadian team's front line players should not be ****ing yankees.
 
Because you will never get an American who wants nothing more than to win a Cup in Toronto.

You won't find a Wendel or Dougie in that crowd. You'll find a Blake.

And you'll lose. As we've been doing for the better part of a decade now.
 
Because you will never get an American who wants nothing more than to win a Cup in Toronto.

You won't find a Wendel or Dougie in that crowd. You'll find a Blake.

And you'll lose. As we've been doing for the better part of a decade now.

Oh ok that's a rational reason I can respect................:couch
 
Why, am I suicidal because I'm upset that we never get the best players?

You've done nothing but over-react. Yea, it sucks we didnt get Richards but turns out Richards didnt want us. We got the 2nd best center available. This wasnt a big year for FAs.
Overall I would rather have Connolly at 2 years than Richards at 7 or 8 where he might suck in year 3 or 4 on... who knows, its a gamble with any long term contact.
 
I'd rather have neither and go with Kadri or Colborne.


8100 of them spent...

crying.jpg


like a little girl
 
I'd rather have neither and go with Kadri or Colborne.
Colborne is still a beanpole that's adjusting to becoming a good player at the AHL level. He shouldn't be in the conversation at all when it comes to our top two center spots. Yet. And as much as I like Kadri, going into last season depending on either him or Bozak to be a #1 center for us was an unmitigated disaster. Connolly gives us an insurance policy, and the fact that he's only on a two year deal means that if any of Colborne, Kadri, McKegg or even Bozak step up in a large way the next year or two, or if Connolly himself disappoints, he'll be easy to get rid of.
 
I would wager that fully three-quarters of the American players in the NHL and in the minor and junior leagues have at least some Canadian blood or relatives in their extended family. Virtually all of the American roster at the World Juniors every single year was either born in Canada, played for a substantial portion of their life in Canada, had Canadian coaches, or has one or two Canadian parents. In Connolly's case, he's an upstate New York boy born in Syracuse, less than two or three hours from the Canadian border, and has two Canadian parents.

He's pretty much as Canadian as is possible without actually being born here and has strong Canadian familial ties. What's the problem? Is the fact that he didn't have the fortune to be born at Scarborough or North York General really a pressing problem here?
 
As well, too bad for Boston they have jerks like Chara, Thomas, Horton and Lucic. I bet those losers never grew up dreaming of hoisting the Cup in a Bruins jersey.
 
Is it a matter of who is better, Canadians or Europeans? Is the issue that a team has to be full of one or the other?

No, it's that a Canadian team's front line players should not be ****ing yankees.

The Leafs have a twenty six man roster:

*14 of those players are Canadian (including the team's starting goaltender, best defenceman, and top prospect)
*8 of those players are American (the team's leading scorer and most recent free agent acquisition amongst them)
*2 of those players are Swedish
*1 of those players is a Russian
*1 of those players is a Belarussian

What exactly is the issue here? Burke is an American married to a Canadian with a Canadian family and who has spent most of his career working in Canada for either the NHL Head Office in Toronto or with Vancouver or Toronto as those teams' General Manager. Wilson is a natural-born Canadian with citizenship who also happens to hold American citizenship and coached the United States on several occasions, but he was drafted by and also played for the Leafs. Most of the American players on this team with the exception of Liles, Kessel, and now Connolly, are playing supporting roles or are plugs (Crabb, Komisarek, Brown, Lebda, and Lashoff). The Leafs first pick in this year's draft was an American but that was primarily a strategic selection as they had the Canadian that they took in the first round three picks after ahead of Biggs on their best available players list.

Honestly, what am I missing that's so egregious?
 
The Leafs have a twenty six man roster:

*14 of those players are Canadian (including the team's starting goaltender, best defenceman, and top prospect)
*8 of those players are American (the team's leading scorer and most recent free agent acquisition amongst them)
*2 of those players are Swedish
*1 of those players is a Russian
*1 of those players is a Belarussian

What exactly is the issue here? Burke is an American married to a Canadian with a Canadian family and who has spent most of his career working in Canada for either the NHL Head Office in Toronto or with Vancouver or Toronto as those teams' General Manager. Wilson is a natural-born Canadian with citizenship who also happens to hold American citizenship and coached the United States on several occasions, but he was drafted by and also played for the Leafs. Most of the American players on this team with the exception of Liles, Kessel, and now Connolly, are playing supporting roles or are plugs (Crabb, Komisarek, Brown, Lebda, and Lashoff). The Leafs first pick in this year's draft was an American but that was primarily a strategic selection as they had the Canadian that they took in the first round three picks after ahead of Biggs on their best available players list.

Honestly, what am I missing that's so egregious?

Not to mention that Biggs' dad was a Canadian-born and bred Oshawa Generals scoring legend and Tyler played for the Toronto Jr. Canadiens minor hockey program. But yeah, pretty much a yankee through-and-through
 
If you check the ancestry of anyone, you'll find some element of some nation in there somewhere. Big deal.

We all identify with what we grew up with. If you grow up in the US, you're an American, your ties are to the US.

In the hockey context, grow up a Canadian or a Euro/Russian, and chances are you're a fan of one of the Canadian teams, or you never really had any allegiance to any North American team.

Are we really going to believe that Connolly didn't daydream of playing for a NY team when he was growing up? He doesn't give a shit about the Leafs, except to the extent they continue to pay him every two weeks.
 
You have an incredibly narrow-minded view of citizenship that is shared by few nations in the world. Based on your logic Tyler Myers is an American and Jason Pominville and Brett Hull are Canadians.

Are we really going to believe that Connolly didn't daydream of playing for a NY team when he was growing up? He doesn't give a shit about the Leafs, except to the extent they continue to pay him every two weeks.

Our recent first round draft pick grew up a Leafs fan while being born and bred in the United States. He had posters of Doug Gilmour on his walls. Why should Percy's allegience to the Leafs be deemed more significant because he happened to have the sheer luck to be born in Mississauga and Biggs was born in Cincinnati?
 
Back
Top