Agreed, teeds was the one who brought it up, and he's brought it up a few times recently for some reason. You did jump in yourself with your "nobody likes anyone to be right" comment though. And there's no lynch mob. Just trying to resolve a long-standing debate with facts. I also looked up preston mizzi's claim that he made a "call" about Brett Lebda the other day, and as I noted, it turned out Mizzi was right. If I'd gone back, looked and found out you were right, I'd have posted that too.
In all of the earliest threads about Kulemin that I pulled up and posted from above, you didn't have any comments in any of them. The earliest you seemed to start talking about Kulemin was when he was already in the NHL, though you are very positive about him right from the start (as are a number of other posters).
The posters I quoted? Nope.
Here's a thread about Kulemin getting sent down from Kuly's first season here. The vast majority of the posters around here defend Kulemin, and make it clear they don't like the move:
msun30:
MapleLeafBlueJayBoy:
Cojo:
Artnes:
MindzEye:
...and then those in that thread that do agree with sending him to the AHL, I don't see anyone jumping off the "Kuly-train", saying he's "nothing special" or writing him off as a prospect. They just hope that some time in the AHL will be beneficial to his development. In fact...if you go to page five of the thread,
you're one of the people defending the move to send him down, in order to shield him from a crappy NHL team and help the tank. I dunno LoF...I think you've just crafted this memory for yourself of everyone in the forum turning on Kulemin and you being the only guy with the foresight to defend him...but it just doesn't have any basis in reality.