Well, a few things about this really.
We're still one of the youngest teams in the league. So expecting a team that young and inexperienced to play with a consistent identity (which is really what I think you believe to be missing in this squad) just isn't realistic. When this team is playing with it's identity, it's one of the most ridiculously hard teams to stop in transition in the league, our problem imo (as I've mentioned recently) is when we **** the little defensive things up, and that stops our transition game cold.
The next is that there's really only what, 3-4 centres in the league who fit the bill of what you're talking about adding. Remember, Gilmour and Sundin are HOF'ers, they're not easy gets. Frankly, I think Kessel is that guy that you're craving for...if we had receieved better goaltending this year (this is a mu****ing recording) his exploits would be looking pretty legendary right now. The guy is playing out of his mind this season, an absolute treat to watch and a threat every time he's on the ice. He's crossed that mythical "makes his linemates better" line that separates good players from great ones imo.
We're a young club, with the typical problems of a young club. If we had .920 Reimer in net right now of last year, we'd look like a great young club about to break through into contender status instead of the highly volatile group of youngsters we look like now. Goaltending masks the deficiencies of young inconsistency. We're just not getting it (again).
Can't say I disagree with anything that you're saying here, Mindz.
But I think you're overstating my impression of this club. Fully recognizing (and in awe of) its youth, and expecting inconsistency, I am super impressed by our three-headed monster of Kessel, Lupul, and Phaneuf. In some ways, I think, crazy as it may sound, that Lupul might even be the best of the bunch. He is so amazing the way that he dominates this year. I mean, I'm not trying to start a debate about who's better, but they're all three awesome. And then you know my opinion of Kulemin, and I really like MacArthur, and know that they'll both rebound. Not to mention Schenn, Gardiner, and yes, I really like Aulie. And then there's my favorite prospect in Colborne almost ready. I'm very optimistic about what we have.
But sometimes I feel that just as great goaltending gives the rest of the team confidence, so does a star center. And LGM, I definitely put Sundin in that class. He may have never put us over the top, but he was always the best player on the ice on our team. Always. And I don't think we have that in any of our guys. A guy who is a cut above the rest on the team in almost all 82 games. All of our lines flounder too much for my liking. They're dangerous one shift, and then just as dangerous in our zone the next. That kills momentum. Have one outstanding line - i.e., star center, Kessel, and Lupul - and the rest builds off of that. Just like they almost do right now. But there's a glitch in our system still, the kinks are very noticeable. Unlike the Canucks for instance, who fired on every single ****ing cylinder last night. Uber impressive.
We've had two constants the past 5 years despite all the personnel changes - both in coaching staff and players - and those are 1) shit goaltending, and 2) shit PK. But maybe the problem is that we're not strong enough on the other end of the ice, that we don't have a Zetterberg or Datsyuk patrolling like a vulture on both ends of the ice, that we keep failing. Otherwise, how do we explain that all these good players keep coming, getting ruined, and leaving? I admit, the goaltending does look like it sucks all the time, but we keep making changes there with the same results. I'd like to see what happens if we add that star center. Maybe ramping up the first line, and upgrading every other line as a result, leads to better overall play and more confidence on the back end.
We have to get that spot of our lineup shored up anyway, whether our goalie situation is fixed or sucks. So, I'd focus on doing that first, and then seeing how the chips fall.