Because as good as Kessel, Lupul, and Phaneuf are, we still don't have a player that takes each game by the balls and sets the tone.
Those three guys are excellent cornerstones, and as the name sort of implies, they're each in a corner. We need someone at the center who this team can be rightfully built around along with those guys.
There's a void each and every game, both when we have good goaltending and bad goaltending. I'm by no means saying our goalie situation is good, but I still think that not having an elite center and gamechanger results in some sort of lack of character or leadership or something. It's like when Gilmour showed up - he literally took over and changed the team's fortunes overnight. We just don't have that guy, or someone who I think (though I know others don't) was just as good in Sundin.
It's not a goals for thing - though that would improve as well - it's overall character, leadership, tone, whatever you want to call it. That X Factor. We just don't have it.